BrainParrot
PolityGS2

Making of the Constitution

Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes

In this note
  1. 1. 1. Why a constitution?
  2. 2. 2. Timeline at a glance
  3. 3. 3. The demand for a Constituent Assembly
  4. 4. 4. Composition of the Constituent Assembly
  5. 5. 5. Working of the Assembly (first sessions, Objectives Resolution)
  6. 6. 6. Changes by the Indian Independence Act, 1947
  7. 7. 7. Committees of the Constituent Assembly (tables)
  8. 8. 8. Enactment and enforcement of the Constitution
  9. 9. 9. Criticism of the Constituent Assembly
  10. 10. 10. How the Assembly worked: consensus, debate and legitimacy
  11. 11. 11. Important facts (time, cost, calligraphy, Hindi text, symbols)
  12. 12. For Mains: Analysis
  13. 13. Quick Revision
  14. 14. Common Exam Traps

1. Why a constitution?

Imagine a large group of people who differ in religion, profession, wealth, age and taste, and who disagree on almost everything: how much property one may own, whether every child must go to school, how much to spend on security. Yet they depend on one another and must live together. What lets such a group live together peacefully? A set of basic rules that everyone knows and that can be enforced. A society's constitution is that set of basic rules.

A constitution is a body of fundamental principles according to which a state is constituted or governed. In most countries it is one compact document of articles. The United Kingdom has no single document; there, a series of documents and decisions together make up the constitution. The word comes from the Latin constituere, "to establish" or "to set up". It is also called the "fundamental law of the land", the "supreme law of the state" or the "grundnorm" of the country.

Five functions of a constitution

FunctionWhat it meansIndian illustration
1. Coordination and assuranceBasic rules, publicly known and legally enforceable, so that each person is sure others will follow them tooThe Constitution is the supreme law that everyone must obey
2. Who decidesThe basic allocation of power: who makes laws and how the government is constitutedParliament makes most laws; the President appoints the Prime Minister
3. Limits on governmentLimits the government may never cross, mostly through fundamental rights; the constitution itself says when rights may be suspended (for example, in an emergency)The government cannot order a citizen to follow or not follow any religion
4. Aspirations and goalsEnables the government to take positive measures for a just society, so that each person has "minimal dignity and social self-respect" (material well-being, education)Enabling provisions sit in the Fundamental Rights and the Directive Principles, backed by the Preamble; India aims at a caste-free society, South Africa at ending racial discrimination
5. Identity of a peopleBy agreeing on basic norms a people comes into being as a collective and forms its political and moral identity; the Centre–region relationship is part of national identityIndian citizenship does not depend on race, caste or religion (unlike an ethnic definition of German identity)

Of these, the function most often called the chief purpose of a constitution is the third: to define and limit the powers of government. That is why constitutional government means limited government: a government bound by the terms of the constitution, which restricts State authority in the interest of individual liberty.

The Indian Constitution is often cited as the finest twentieth-century example of a constitution that does more than limit power: it empowers the State to work for social and economic justice. It in turn became an exemplar for other constitutions, most notably South Africa's. South Africa's constitution (housing, health care, protection from discrimination) and Indonesia's (a national education system, care for poor children) carry similar enabling provisions.

What makes a constitution effective?

Many constitutions exist only on paper. Three factors decide whether a constitution actually shapes people's lives.

  1. Mode of promulgation (how it came into being). Constitutions crafted by military rulers or unpopular leaders often stay defunct. The most successful ones (India, South Africa, the United States) came out of popular national movements. India's was framed by leaders with immense public credibility. It was never put to a referendum, but the people adopted it as their own by abiding by it.
  2. Substantive provisions. A constitution must give everyone some reason to go along with it. If it lets permanent majorities oppress minorities, or entrenches small groups, it loses allegiance. No constitution achieves perfect justice, but it must convince people that it provides a framework for basic justice.
  3. Balanced institutional design. Constitutions are usually subverted "not by the people, but by small groups". So power must be fragmented: legislature, executive, judiciary and independent bodies such as the Election Commission check one another. A constitution must also balance core values with flexibility; India's is called a "living document" for striking this balance.

Nepal shows the contrast. Its constitutions of 1948, 1951, 1959, 1962 and 1990 were all "granted" by the King. After long agitation for an elected constituent assembly, Nepal became a democratic republic in 2008 and adopted a new constitution in 2015.

Nehru saw a constituent assembly as more than a gathering of able lawyers: it was "a nation on the move, throwing away the shell of its past political and possibly social structure, and fashioning for itself a new garment of its own making". On this view constitutions exist not only to limit those in power but also to empower those traditionally deprived of it.

2. Timeline at a glance
3. The demand for a Constituent Assembly
4. Composition of the Constituent Assembly
5. Working of the Assembly (first sessions, Objectives Resolution)
6. Changes by the Indian Independence Act, 1947
7. Committees of the Constituent Assembly (tables)
8. Enactment and enforcement of the Constitution
9. Criticism of the Constituent Assembly
10. How the Assembly worked: consensus, debate and legitimacy
11. Important facts (time, cost, calligraphy, Hindi text, symbols)
For Mains: Analysis
Quick Revision
Common Exam Traps
Unlock the full note, MCQs and flashcards

Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.

Get started free