SC issues notice to Centre on plea by news publishers against data privacy law
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 28 October 2026
Summary
- The Digital News Publishers Association (DNPA) says the DPDP Act, 2023 and the DPDP Rules, 2025 will "shut down news rooms and usher in an era of censorship".
- A Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant issued notice to the Centre. The case is listed for detailed hearing on 17 November.
- The CJI said the Court cannot pass ex parte stay orders, and invited the DNPA to suggest how to balance citizens' rights against misuse of press freedom.
Key facts for Prelims
- DPDP Act, 2023: Act No. 22 of 2023, assented 11 August 2023. It covers digital personal data processed in India, whether collected in digital form or digitised later, and also some processing outside India linked to offering goods or services in India.
- The Act does not apply to personal data that the individual herself has made publicly available (e.g. her own blog or social-media post).
- Data Principal: the individual to whom the data relates (the article's own gloss). Data Fiduciary: an entity that decides why and how personal data is processed.
- Rights of Data Principals include access to information about data processed, and correction and erasure.
- The Act's exemptions include notified government agencies (security, sovereignty, public order) and research, archiving or statistical purposes.
- Puttaswamy (2017): privacy is a fundamental right under Art. 21.
- Art. 19(1)(a): freedom of speech and expression; Art. 19(2) lists eight reasonable restrictions including public order, decency, morality and defamation.
- The Press Council of India is the statutory regulator for print media, cited by the DNPA as the existing regulation of traditional media.
Data and details
- DNPA: article describes it as a group of 21 publishers (also says it represents 22 media publishers), including ones owned by the Ambani and Adani groups and The Hindu Group Publishing Private Ltd.
- Representation: senior advocate Madhavi Divan and advocate Anuj Tiwari for the DNPA.
- Hearing: notice issued; detailed hearing on 17 November. The DNPA said it wasn't asking for a stay as such but wanted the Centre to answer its interim-stay plea. The CJI said: "We cannot pass ex parte orders of stay."
- DNPA arguments:
- The law was not meant for journalists.
- Its objectives did not intend to fetter traditional, recognised media houses, who are already regulated by bodies like the Press Council of India.
- Being "left to the mercy of the data principal" would close newsrooms and "change the very concept of news".
- Publishers who report inaccurately already suffer consequences, so having to "ask them before publishing" is unjustified.
- The law contradicts the Supreme Court's privacy judgment, which held privacy inviolable and fundamental to human dignity and life.
- The petition says the law "impermissibly restrict[s]" the fundamental right to information and freedom of speech and expression.
- The CJI asked the DNPA to say how a balance can be struck between innocent citizens' rights and misuse of press freedom, while protecting the media's right to disseminate information.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Static concept.
- Freedom of the press flows from Art. 19(1)(a) and is subject to Art. 19(2) restrictions.
- Privacy is part of Art. 21 (Puttaswamy, 2017).
- A data-protection statute therefore has to balance two fundamental rights, using the proportionality test.
- The bridge. The DNPA says the statute treats a newsroom like any other data processor. A newsroom would then need consent from the "data principal" (the person the data concerns), who also gets control over their data. In its view that defeats public-interest reporting.
- Court's approach. The CJI declined an ex parte stay. The Centre has to respond first, and the Court wants workable balancing proposals from the media.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Fundamental Rights; judiciary; statutory/regulatory bodies; government policies and interventions (data protection). GS3 — S&T: IT and cyber law.
Background primer
Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023
- What it is:
- an Act to provide for processing of digital personal data in a manner that recognises both the right of individuals to protect their personal data and the need to process it for lawful purposes.
- Why it matters:
- to confer rights on individuals, place obligations on entities that process personal data, and lay down a compliance mechanism.
Additional context
- Drishti IAS notes that neither Section 7 (certain legitimate uses) nor Section 17 (exemptions) provides a statutory carve-out for media. It says this treats reporters as "data fiduciaries" who would have to seek prior consent from the public functionaries they investigate.
- It adds that Section 36 lets the Centre demand information from fiduciaries, which could compromise source confidentiality.
- It adds that Section 37 empowers the Centre to block online information after a Data Protection Board reference involving at least two monetary penalties, subject to a hearing and written reasons, raising pre-censorship concerns.
- It also says the Act removed the public-interest qualification from the RTI personal-information exemption, so all "personal information" is broadly exempt from RTI disclosure.
- The DNPA plea is linked to the pending Venkatesh Nayak v. Union of India (2026), which questions the DPDP framework on right to information, excessive government access and surveillance safeguards.
- Earlier in 2026, the Supreme Court referred the petitions challenging Section 44(3) of the DPDP Act (the amendment to Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act) to a Constitution Bench.
- The Centre has pointed to the difficulty of legally defining "journalists" in the era of independent social-media creators.
- The Editors Guild of India had earlier asked that journalistic activities be exempted.
- The Act empowers the Centre to exempt any data processor or class of processors from provisions of the law.
Mains dimensions
- Rights collision, not rights hierarchy. Privacy (Art. 21, Puttaswamy) and press freedom (Art. 19(1)(a)) are both fundamental. Any restriction must satisfy legality, legitimate aim and proportionality. The DNPA's argument is that consent-and-erasure rights over personal data cut into the public-interest function of the press.
- Design gap. The Act has no statutory journalistic exemption and relies on executive notification under Section 17. This puts press freedom at executive discretion, and the Srikrishna draft had gone the other way.
- Accountability journalism. A requirement of prior consent would protect the very officials, politicians and fraudsters under scrutiny. This links to the RTI personal-information exemption change and to source confidentiality (Sections 36/37 concerns).
- Counter-concerns. Ordinary citizens, victims and minors need protection from intrusive publication, and media trials affect fair-trial rights (Art. 21). The CJI's call for balancing proposals acknowledges this, and so does the Centre's point about the difficulty of defining "journalist".
- Judicial process. Refusing ex parte stays while seeking the Centre's reply shows institutional restraint. The linked Venkatesh Nayak case, and the reference of the RTI-amendment challenge to a Constitution Bench, point to a wider constitutional examination of the framework.
- Way forward.
- A clear, objective, public-interest safe harbour for journalism, by statute or by non-discretionary Section 17 rules.
- Self-regulatory codes with the Press Council and broadcasting bodies.
- Narrow tailoring of erasure and consent rights for public figures' public-role data.
- Safeguards for source confidentiality.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 has been challenged by news publishers as a threat to press freedom. Examine how the Act balances the right to privacy with freedom of the press, and suggest a way forward."
Related topics
- Puttaswamy (2017) and the proportionality test; Art. 19(1)(a) and 19(2); Art. 21
- RTI Act, 2005 (Section 8(1)(j)) and the DPDP amendment
- Press Council of India; media regulation; Shreya Singhal (2015) and the Information Technology Act, 2000
- Data Protection Board; Srikrishna Committee (2018); GDPR as a comparator
- Government surveillance exemptions and cross-border data flows
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 28 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs