BrainParrot

SC issues notice to Centre over Vande Mataram petitions

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 October 2026

Summary

  • A Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant issued notice to the Centre on two petitions by B.D. Borkar (a Phule-Ambedkarite) and former IAS officer Balakrishnan Sathyabhama Mavoji. They challenge government orders making the six-stanza Vande Mataram compulsory for the people.
  • Counsel is Mohan Gopal, a jurist and advocate. The petitioners call the six-stanza version a "divisive religious war song" and a step towards theocracy.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Fundamental Rights (Arts. 14, 19, 25–28), national symbols; GS1 — History/Culture: Vande Mataram in the freedom movement

Key facts for Prelims

  • On 24 January 1950 the Constituent Assembly President, Dr Rajendra Prasad, stated that Vande Mataram would be honoured equally with Jana Gana Mana. Only the first two stanzas have been treated as the National Song.
  • The National Song's status rests on that statement and established governmental practice, not a constitutional provision.
  • Art. 51A(a): duty to respect the Constitution, ideals, institutions, National Flag and National Anthem; it does not mention the National Song.
  • Bankim Chandra Chatterjee: composed Vande Mataram in 1875; it was later included in his novel "Anandamath" (1882).
  • Tagore first sang it at the 1896 INC session in Calcutta.
  • Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971 and its 2026 amendment (protects the Flag, the Constitution and the Anthem) — the 2026 amendment extends Section 3 to Vande Mataram.
  • Art. 25: freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion; Arts. 25–28 form the right to freedom of religion.
  • Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala (1986): no compulsion to sing the National Anthem (static background).

Data and details

  • Petitioners: B.D. Borkar (Phule-Ambedkarite) and Balakrishnan Sathyabhama Mavoji (former IAS officer); counsel Mohan Gopal. Both call the six-stanza version a "divisive religious war song" and a step towards theocracy.
  • Government orders challenged: two successive orders, dated 28 January and 9 July.
  • Petition claims:
  • The orders impose a "sectarian prayer to particular goddesses of one particular religion" as the National Song, violating fundamental rights of religion and attracting criminal law.
  • State compulsion would deepen communal division, outraging the religious and spiritual feelings of minority religions.
  • Borkar's argument: the six-stanza version in "Anandamath" would promote enmity between communities by advancing the supremacy of a dominant community, and "mutilate" the fabric of unity forever.
  • Court action: notice issued to the Centre on both petitions; no interim order is reported.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Static concept. National symbols sit in a constitutional grey zone.
    • The Constitution does not mention a "National Song"; its status rests on a resolution and established governmental practice.
    • Art. 51A(a), the Fundamental Duty, covers the Constitution, the National Flag and the National Anthem, but not the National Song.
  • Bridge. Where a State order compels participation in an expression with religious imagery, courts weigh Arts. 19(1)(a) and 25 (freedom of conscience and religion) against State interest in national unity. The classic precedent is Bijoe Emmanuel (1986): students who, on religious conscience, stood respectfully but did not sing the anthem could not be penalised.
  • Core dispute. The petitions say two successive government orders (28 January and 9 July) impose the six-stanza version, which they say invokes goddesses of one religion, hurting minority religious feelings. The official National Song status was given to the first two stanzas (see 2a).

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Fundamental Rights; religious freedom; secularism; judicial review of executive orders. GS1 — Modern Indian history (Swadeshi movement, nationalist symbols).

Background primer

Vande Mataram (National Song)

What it is:
India's National Song, accorded status equal to the National Anthem.
Why it matters:
recognition of its historic role in the freedom struggle.

Additional context

  • The Congress Working Committee had in 1937 adopted the first two stanzas as the National Song.
  • The Prevention of Insults to National Honour (Amendment) Bill, 2026 was introduced in the Rajya Sabha on 24 July 2026. The Rajya Sabha passed it on 29 July and the Lok Sabha on 30 July. It amends Section 3 of the 1971 Act to extend to Vande Mataram the same protection as the National Anthem. Intentionally preventing its singing, or disturbing an assembly engaged in singing it, is punishable with up to three years' imprisonment, a fine, or both. Repeat offences carry a minimum of one year. This fixes the earlier gap that the National Song had no statutory protection. The law does not specify which stanzas must be sung.
  • An MHA order dated 28 January 2026 prescribes the six-stanza "official version" (about 3 minutes 10 seconds) for official functions. It also says Vande Mataram is played before Jana Gana Mana when both are played, and that schools should begin the day with community singing. This order is probably one of the two orders challenged. The source does not say what the 9 July order is, and that is not confirmed from a trusted source.

Mains dimensions

  • Rights framework.
  • Compulsion by executive order engages Arts. 19(1)(a) and 25, and Arts. 14–15 (equal treatment of religions).
  • The petitioners also say criminal law is attracted.
  • Bijoe Emmanuel shows that courts distinguish respect (non-disruption) from compelled participation.
  • Secularism and civilizational nationalism. The song's role in the freedom movement (Swadeshi movement) versus its religious imagery in the "Anandamath" context. The question is whether symbols of national unity can be one-community-coded under Indian secularism, which is principled distance and equal respect, not exclusion.
  • Constitutional status. The Constitution is silent on a National Song and the Art. 51A(a) duty excludes it. Hence the legal weight of executive orders and of the protective statute (the 2026 amendment to the 1971 Act) is itself a question.
  • Historical nuance. Only the first two stanzas were given National Song status (1937 CWC; 1950 Assembly). Extending compulsion to all six is the contested step. The 2026 amendment penalises intentional obstruction or disturbance, not peaceful non-participation.
  • Federalism and education. Protocols for schools raise the question of how national symbols are taught across states and minority institutions (Art. 28/30).
  • Way forward.
  • Keep the 1950 two-stanza convention.
  • Allow conscientious non-participation where respect is shown.
  • Rely on dialogue and constitutional morality rather than compulsion.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 10 marks:** "Discuss the constitutional status of national symbols such as the National Song. Can the State compel citizens to sing them? Examine in light of judicial pronouncements."

Related topics

  • Art. 51A and Fundamental Duties; Arts. 25–28
  • Bijoe Emmanuel (1986) and Shyam Narayan Chouksey (2016, anthem in cinemas)
  • Secularism as a basic feature (S.R. Bommai, 1994)
  • Swadeshi and anti-partition movement, 1905; Anandamath and Sanyasi rebellion context
  • Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs