BrainParrot

What are the alternatives to the SWIFT payment system?

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 25 September 2026

Summary

  • The New Delhi Declaration of the recent BRICS Summit committed members to raise intra-bloc trade and payments in national currencies.
  • Days earlier, a Reuters report said India would push to link central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) for cross-border BRICS payments, despite political and technical hurdles. The CBDC-linking proposal was not part of the Declaration.
  • The explainer reviews the main alternatives to the Belgium-based SWIFT system and how they are faring, including how India-Russia trade settles.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Economy: banking and payments, international finance; GS2 — IR: BRICS

Key facts for Prelims

  • SWIFT: Belgium-based messaging system (not a settlement system).
  • Alternatives named in the article:
  • Project mBridge: a multi-CBDC platform.
  • CIPS: China's Cross-Border Interbank Payment System.
  • SPFS: Russia's System for Transfer of Financial Messages.
  • SEPAMA: Iran's interbank telecom system.
  • mBridge participants per the article: Bank of Thailand, Central Bank of the UAE, Digital Currency Institute of the People's Bank of China, Hong Kong Monetary Authority, Saudi Central Bank.
  • The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) is an international financial institution owned by central banks, to foster international monetary and financial cooperation.
  • Special Drawing Right (SDR): an international reserve asset created by the IMF. The renminbi is in the SDR basket.
  • Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC): digital legal tender issued by a central bank.
  • Other systems: US-based Clearing House Interbank Payments System (CHIPS), a much larger established system.

Data and details

  • Reuters (pre-summit): India would push to link BRICS CBDCs. The limited adoption of digital currencies globally could complicate implementation. The proposal was not in the New Delhi Declaration.
  • CIPS:
  • Launched in 2015 and backed by the People's Bank of China, to internationalise the yuan.
  • It lets global banks clear cross-border yuan transactions directly onshore, without offshore yuan clearing hubs.
  • It has participants in 120+ countries, including all BRICS members except India.
  • It processed an average of 679.8 billion yuan per day in 2025 (SCMP), still far smaller than CHIPS.
  • Biswajit Dhar (The Hindu, Nov 2025) says the renminbi's inclusion in the SDR basket has boosted CIPS acceptance.
  • A Tsinghua University study (Ju Jiandong) sees Beijing moving toward a global multi-currency platform.
  • SPFS:
  • Developed by Russia in 2014 to bypass Western sanctions. It helped when Russian banks were cut off from SWIFT in 2022.
  • In 2023, 50 new entities joined, taking the total to 440, of which more than 100 are non-residents (Alla Bakina, Russian central bank).
  • SEPAMA: per the Central Bank of Iran in 2023, 52 branches of Iranian banks and four unnamed foreign banks connected with 106 banks using the SPFS.
  • mBridge:
  • BIS hand-held it from 2019, when the Hong Kong Monetary Authority and the Bank of Thailand launched the system.
  • It reached minimum viability status in 2024 and uses a custom-built mBridge Ledger blockchain for peer-to-peer CBDC settlement without correspondent banks.
  • BIS exited on 31 October 2024. Media reports said the exit was because mBridge could support a BRICS initiative to bypass sanctions on Russia.
  • A Forbes report said that by late 2025 mBridge was in practice a renminbi-denominated wholesale settlement rail for China–Gulf trade, outside the dollar correspondent system.
  • India-Russia:
  • Roubles and rupees account for 96% of bilateral trade (Ivan Nosov, head of Sberbank in India).
  • 22 Russian banks (including Sberbank, Russia's largest lender, which was tasked with building the infrastructure) and 17 Indian banks service trade.
  • Nosov called it one of the best-established payment mechanisms Russia has with other countries.
  • India is the second-largest importer of Russian oil.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Static concept: International payments need two things: a messaging layer (instructions between banks) and a settlement layer (actual movement of funds, via correspondent banks, clearing systems or central banks). SWIFT is the messaging layer. A currency's international role (reserve, invoicing, payments) gives its issuer power. Sanctions can cut a country off from the system.
  • De-dollarisation drive: Wars and the US use of the dollar for sanctions are pushing the Global South toward alternatives. The article calls the attempts patchy.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: Banking, payments systems, external sector, CBDC; GS2 – IR: Groupings (BRICS), weaponisation of finance, sanctions

Background primer

SWIFT (Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunication)

What it is:
A standardised secure messaging network banks use to send instructions such as money transfers. It is a messaging platform, not a settlement system or a bank that holds funds.
Founded:
1973, headquartered in La Hulpe, Belgium. It was built to replace error-prone telex with a reliable automated network.
Members:
A member-owned cooperative under Belgian law, supervised collectively by the G10 central banks.
Mandate:
Secure, standardised cross-border financial messaging.
Why it matters:
Reliable global bank-to-bank communication. Because of its central position, SWIFT access can be used as a sanctions tool.

BRICS Pay / BRICS Cross-Border Payments Initiative

What it is:
A proposed system for trade and financial transactions among BRICS members in local currencies, to reduce dependence on SWIFT and the USD.
Why it matters:
Financial sovereignty and resilience against sanctions.

Additional context

  • Project Nexus: Conceptualised by the BIS Innovation Hub, it interlinks domestic fast payment systems for instant multilateral cross-border retail payments, building on India's UPI and existing bilateral fast-payment linkages. India and four ASEAN countries (Malaysia, Philippines, Singapore and Thailand) are founding members. The agreement was signed with the BIS in Basel on 30 June 2024.
  • Over 95% of settlement volume on the mBridge CBDC platform is reportedly executed in China's digital yuan.
  • Challenges for SWIFT alternatives: secondary-sanctions risk for institutions that join a SWIFT alternative alongside heavily sanctioned nations, yuan-dominance risk, geopolitical differences, regulatory fragmentation, scalability and cybersecurity concerns.
  • Suggested approach: begin with bilateral local-currency settlements, then evolve into a digital payment network.

Mains dimensions

  • Why alternatives: Sanctions and the weaponisation of the dollar, seen in the 2022 cut-off of Russian banks from SWIFT, make countries want options that cannot be switched off.
  • Fragmented architecture:
  • CIPS is China's yuan rail.
  • SPFS is Russia's sanctions-driven system.
  • mBridge links central banks without Western participants.
  • Each reflects a single country's strategic needs, so they don't add up to a single BRICS system.
  • Yuan dominance risk for India: mBridge works as a renminbi settlement rail, and CIPS covers every BRICS member except India. India's concern is substituting dollar dependence with yuan dependence.
  • India's approach: India prefers CBDC linking and local-currency settlement. The India-Russia rupee-rouble mechanism (96% of trade) is a working model of bilateral settlement. India's proposal did not make it into the Declaration, which shows the limits of consensus.
  • Scale and technical limits: CIPS handles 679.8 billion yuan daily but remains much smaller than CHIPS. CBDC adoption is limited globally, and interoperability is technically hard.
  • Way forward for India:
  • promote UPI and rupee settlement;
  • continue bilateral local-currency deals;
  • keep interoperable, neutral rails;
  • hedge against sanctions without breaking from global finance.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 / GS2, 15 marks:** "Alternatives to SWIFT are emerging as countries seek insulation from financial sanctions. Evaluate their prospects and discuss the options available to India."

Related topics

  • Central Bank Digital Currency (e-rupee), UPI and its international linkages
  • BRICS: New Development Bank, Contingent Reserve Arrangement; BRICS expansion
  • Rupee internationalisation: RBI's Special Rupee Vostro Accounts and local-currency settlement
  • IMF's SDR and the international monetary system
  • Sanctions and secondary sanctions; de-dollarisation
  • India-Russia economic ties (oil trade)

Topics: GS3Economy

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 25 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs