BrainParrot
PolityGS2

Salient Features, Sources and Philosophy of the Constitution

The Constituent Assembly took almost three years to write the Constitution. This topic asks what kind of document it produced: what it contains (its salient features), where its ideas came from (its sources), how far the charge of borrowing holds, and the moral vision behind it (its philosophy). How British rule shaped the text is covered in Historical Background, and how the Assembly worked in Making of the Constitution.

Many original features have changed through amendments, especially the 7th, 42nd, 44th, 73rd, 74th, 97th and 101st. The 42nd Amendment (1976) made so many changes that it is called the "Mini-Constitution". In the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973) the Supreme Court held that Parliament's power under Article 368 does not extend to altering the "basic structure". The features below describe the Constitution as it stands today.

Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes

In this note
  1. 1. 1. What a constitution is (and constitutionalism)
  2. 2. 2. The Constitution at a glance
  3. 3. 3. Salient features
  4. 4. 4. Sources of the Constitution
  5. 5. 5. Criticism and replies
  6. 6. 6. Philosophy of the Constitution
  7. 7. 7. Limitations and debates
  8. 8. For Mains: Analysis
  9. 9. Quick Revision
  10. 10. Common Exam Traps

1. What a constitution is (and constitutionalism)

Meaning, functions and qualities

The word comes from the Latin constituere, "to establish". A constitution is the set of principles that lays down how the government is organised and works, and how it relates to the people through their rights and duties. It is called the "fundamental law of the land", the "supreme law of the state", the "instrument of government" and the "grundnorm" of the country. The classic definitions (Gilchrist, Gettell, K.C. Wheare, Wade and Phillips) stress the same three things: the organs of government, the distribution of powers among them, and the principles on which those powers are used. Wheare's is the best known: "the whole system of government of a country, the collection of rules which establish and regulate or govern the government".

Functions. Elliot Bulmer lists eight: declare the boundaries of the political community; declare its nature and authority; express its identity and values; define citizens' rights and duties; set up and regulate political institutions; divide or share power between layers of government; declare the state's religious identity and the relation between sacred and secular authority; and commit the state to social, economic or developmental goals. India's Constitution does most of these (territory in Articles 1–4, rights and duties, institutions, Union–state division, goals in the Directive Principles). On religion it does the opposite of declaring a faith: it makes the state secular.

Qualities of a good constitution: brevity, clarity, definiteness, comprehensiveness, suitability, stability and adaptability (a living document). India's scores high on all but brevity, which is why critics call it "elephantine" (Section 5).

How constitutions are classified, and where India stands

BasisTypesExamplesIndia
EvolutionEvolved (cumulative): grows through conventions, practices and judgments. Enacted (conventional): deliberately made by an assemblyEvolved: Britain. Enacted: USA, IndiaEnacted
FormWritten (codified) vs unwritten (mostly conventions, statutes, judgments)Written: USA, Canada, Japan, France, India. Unwritten: UK, New Zealand, IsraelWritten, and the lengthiest in the world
Method of amendment (Lord James Bryce)Rigid: special procedure, so constitutional law differs from ordinary law. Flexible: amended like ordinary lawRigid: USA, Australia, Switzerland. Flexible: UK, New ZealandA synthesis of both
Centre–region relationsFederal: powers divided, each government independent in its sphere. Unitary: regional units are agents of the national governmentFederal: USA, Switzerland, Australia, Canada. Unitary: UK, France, Japan, ChinaBoth federal and unitary provisions: "quasi-federal" (K.C. Wheare)
Nature (Elliot Bulmer)Procedural: structures and legal limits of power. Prescriptive: also states common goalsStrongly prescriptive (Preamble, Directive Principles) on a procedural frame

Constitutionalism

Having a constitution is not the same as having constitutionalism. A dictatorship may have a constitution; what it lacks is limits on power. Constitutionalism means limited government: rule under a constitution that ensures limited government and the rule of law, as against arbitrary or totalitarian rule. Arbitrary power negates constitutionalism even when a constitutional document confers it. So a constitutional government is a government limited by the terms of the constitution; it places effective restrictions on the authority of the State in the interest of individual liberty, and the chief purpose of a constitution is to define and limit the powers of government.

Friedrich called constitutionalism "a system of effective restraints upon governmental action"; K.C. Wheare, government "according to rule as opposed to arbitrary government". Roucek ("essentially limited government") and Ybema (rulers subject to limiting rules) say the same. Louis Henkin lists eight elements: popular sovereignty, rule of law, democratic (accountable) government, separation of powers, an independent judiciary, civilian control of the military, police governed by law, and respect for individual rights.

Rule of law. As explained by A.V. Dicey, it has three parts: absence of arbitrary power (no punishment except for a breach of law), equality before the law (officials and citizens alike answer to the ordinary courts), and the primacy of individual rights. In short: limitation of powers, equality before law, and liberty and civil rights. The government answers to the people, not the people to the government.

In India, constitutionalism works through the Fundamental Rights (Article 13 voids laws that violate them), judicial review (Articles 13, 32, 226), equality before law (Article 14), an independent judiciary, independent bodies such as the Election Commission and CAG, and the basic structure limit on amendment.

Separation of powers and checks and balances

Separation of powers is the classic safeguard of liberty: power divided is power limited. India has no strict separation. It has a limited separation with checks and balances. In Ram Jawaya Kapur v. State of Punjab (1955) the Supreme Court said the Constitution does not recognise the doctrine "in its absolute rigidity", though the functions of the organs are "sufficiently differentiated". In Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975) it held separation of powers to be part of the basic structure: no organ can take over the essential functions of another.

CheckHow it works
Legislature over executiveCollective responsibility to the Lok Sabha (Article 75(3)); no-confidence motion; questions and debates
Executive over legislatureOrdinances (Article 123); summoning and dissolution of the Lok Sabha on ministerial advice
Judiciary over bothJudicial review (Articles 13, 32, 226); basic structure limit on amendments
Executive and legislature over judiciaryJudges appointed by the President; removal of judges by Parliament (Article 124(4))
Mutual restraintNo discussion of a judge's conduct in the legislature (Articles 121, 211); courts cannot question the validity of legislative proceedings (Articles 122, 212); immunity of the President and Governors (Article 361); separation of the judiciary from the executive (Article 50)

Judicial activism through public interest litigation (court-framed guidelines where law is silent) tests this balance; it is covered in the judiciary topic.

Constitutional morality

Moving the Draft Constitution on 4 November 1948, Ambedkar quoted the historian George Grote: constitutional morality means "a paramount reverence for the forms of the Constitution". He warned that it "is not a natural sentiment. It has to be cultivated." The Supreme Court now uses it as a guide to interpretation and a check on public power. In Manoj Narula v. Union of India (2014) it said constitutional morality means bowing to the norms of the Constitution and not acting arbitrarily. In Navtej Singh Johar (2018), which read down Section 377 IPC, and Indian Young Lawyers Association (Sabarimala, 2018), which ended the exclusion of women of a certain age from the temple, it held that constitutional morality (justice, equality, liberty, fraternity, dignity) must prevail over popular or societal morality.

Concepts the exam tests

  • Liberty is both the absence of restraints and the opportunity to develop oneself fully; the positive meaning is the more complete one. Liberty is not licence: it exists within law, and without laws there would be no liberty, only the rule of the strong. Hence reasonable restrictions on rights.
  • Equality implies the absence of special privileges (hence Articles 17 and 18).
  • Rights are claims of citizens against the State, and rights are correlative with duties: one person's right is another's duty.
2. The Constitution at a glance
3. Salient features
4. Sources of the Constitution
5. Criticism and replies
6. Philosophy of the Constitution
7. Limitations and debates
For Mains: Analysis
Quick Revision
Common Exam Traps
Unlock the full note, MCQs and flashcards

Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.

Get started free