Federal System and Centre–State Relations
Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes
- 1. 1. What federalism means (and India's model)
- 2. 2. Federal and unitary features of the Constitution (tables)
- 3. 3. Nature of Indian federalism: debates and models
- 4. 4. Legislative relations
- 5. 5. Administrative relations
- 6. 6. Financial relations
- 7. 7. Tensions and trends in Centre–State relations
- 8. 8. Commissions and committees on Centre–State relations (table)
- 9. 9. Federalism in practice: conflicts, autonomy demands and special provisions
- 10. For Mains: Analysis
- 11. Quick Revision
- 12. Common Exam Traps
1. What federalism means (and India's model)
1.1 Unitary and federal governments
Governments are classed as unitary or federal by how the national government relates to the regional governments.
- In a unitary government, all powers vest in the national government; regional governments, if any, derive their authority from it and can be changed or abolished by it. Examples: Britain, France, Japan, China, Italy, Sweden.
- In a federal government, powers are divided by the Constitution itself, and each level works independently in its own sphere. Examples: the US, Switzerland, Australia, Canada, Russia, Brazil, Argentina.
In a federation the national government is called the Federal, Central or Union government and the regional one the State or Provincial government. The units go by different names: states (US), cantons (Switzerland), provinces (Canada), republics (Russia).
| Federal government | Unitary government |
|---|---|
| Dual government: national and regional | Single government: the national government, which may create regional governments |
| Written Constitution | May be written (France) or unwritten (Britain) |
| Division of powers between the two levels | No division; all powers with the national government |
| Supremacy of the Constitution | Constitution may be supreme (Japan) or not (Britain) |
| Rigid Constitution | May be rigid (France) or flexible (Britain) |
| Independent judiciary | Judiciary may or may not be independent |
| Bicameral legislature | Bicameral (Britain) or unicameral (China) |
1.2 Federation and how federations are formed
'Federation' comes from the Latin foedus, 'treaty' or 'agreement'. A confederation is a looser league of sovereign units that keep the right to leave; a federation creates a single, lasting state.
| Way of formation | What happens | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Integration ("coming together") | Independent, militarily weak or economically backward states come together to form a strong union | US |
| Disintegration ("holding together") | A unitary state is converted into a federation by granting autonomy to the provinces | Canada; India |
The US (1787; 50 states, originally 13) is the oldest federation and the model one. Canada (1867) has 10 provinces (originally 4).
1.3 India: a "Union of States"
The framers chose a federal system because of the country's large size and socio-cultural diversity: it ensures efficient governance and reconciles national unity with regional autonomy.
Yet the word 'federation' is used nowhere in the Constitution. Article 1 calls India a 'Union of States' (see the Union and its Territory topic). Dr. B.R. Ambedkar said the term shows two things:
- The Indian federation was not created by a compact of the states, unlike the American one.
- The states have no right to secede; the Union is indestructible.
Canadian, not American, model. India resembles Canada in its formation (by disintegration), in preferring the term 'Union', and in its centralising tendency (a very strong Centre).
Why a strong Centre? Before Partition, a formula giving large powers to the regions was discussed to meet the Muslim League's demands. Once Partition was settled, Nehru argued that a weak central authority "would be injurious to the interests of the country". A strong Centre was also needed to integrate over 500 princely states and to fight poverty, illiteracy and inequality through planning; T.T. Krishnamachari noted that the drift "in all constitutions has been towards the centre" as states became welfare states.
Lessons from elsewhere. Form alone does not guarantee unity: the USSR broke up after 1989 partly through excessive centralisation; Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia and Pakistan also split; and the West Indies federation (1958), with a weak Centre, dissolved in 1962. The practice of federalism, a culture of trust and restraint, matters as much as its design.
Core idea. Federalism accommodates two sets of polities, regional and national, each autonomous in its own sphere; people carry two identities (for example Gujarati and Indian). A written, supreme constitution is the source of power of both levels, and an independent judiciary settles disputes over the division of powers.
Exam tip: India is a "holding together" federation formed by disintegration, on the Canadian pattern. The Constitution never uses the word "federation"; Article 1 says "Union of States".
Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.
Get started free