BrainParrot
PolityGS2

Basic Structure, Landmark Judgements and Doctrines of Interpretation

This topic covers three things. First, the basic structure doctrine: the rule, made by the judges, that Parliament may amend any part of the Constitution but may not destroy its core. Second, the landmark judgements of the Supreme Court and what each one changed. Third, the doctrines of interpretation: the tools the courts use to read the Constitution and decide whether a law is valid. Many of the cases have already been told in full in earlier topics (Fundamental Rights I, Fundamental Rights II, Directive Principles, Amendment of the Constitution). Here they get a one-line holding and a pointer, and the space goes to what is new.

Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes

In this note
  1. 1. 1. The road to the Basic Structure
  2. 2. 2. Kesavananda Bharati (1973): the case that changed everything
  3. 3. 3. Elements of the Basic Structure (master table)
  4. 4. 4. Basic Structure applied: later cases
  5. 5. 5. Debate on the doctrine (criticism and defence)
  6. 6. 6. Landmark judgements and their impact
  7. 7. 7. Doctrines of constitutional interpretation
  8. 8. For Mains: Analysis
  9. 9. Quick Revision
  10. 10. Common Exam Traps

1. The road to the Basic Structure

The question. Article 368 lets Parliament amend the Constitution. Article 13(2) says the State shall not make any "law" that takes away or abridges a Fundamental Right. Is a constitutional amendment a "law" in this sense? If it is, Parliament cannot amend Fundamental Rights at all. If it is not, Parliament can amend anything. The Supreme Court answered the question three different ways in twenty-two years. The full timeline is in the Amendment of the Constitution topic (Section 6); the short version:

YearCase or ActWhat it held or did
1951Shankari Prasad v. Union of IndiaParliament can amend Fundamental Rights. "Law" in Article 13 means ordinary law, not constituent law (an amendment). Upheld the 1st Amendment (1951), which curtailed the right to property
1964Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan (30 October 1964)Reaffirmed Shankari Prasad by majority. But in separate opinions Justices M. Hidayatullah and J.R. Mudholkar doubted it. Mudholkar J asked whether changing a "basic feature" of the Constitution is an amendment or a rewriting of it, citing a 1963 Pakistan Supreme Court ruling on "fundamental features". This is the first appearance of the idea
1967I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab (27 February 1967; 11 judges; 6:5)Reversed both: Fundamental Rights have a "transcendental and immutable" position; an amendment is "law" under Article 13(2), so Parliament cannot abridge or take away Fundamental Rights. By prospective overruling, the 1st, 4th and 17th Amendments stayed valid
197124th Amendment ActAdded Article 13(4) and Article 368(3): an amendment is not "law" under Article 13
197125th Amendment Act"Amount" for "compensation" in Article 31(2); new Article 31C with a declaration clause barring courts
197229th Amendment ActTwo Kerala land reform Acts into the Ninth Schedule (Parliament places Acts there by constitutional amendment, using Article 31B)
1973Kesavananda Bharati v. State of KeralaOverruled Golaknath but added a new limit: the basic structure (Section 2)

So by 1973 Parliament had claimed an unlimited amending power, and the Court had once denied it any power over Fundamental Rights. Kesavananda found a middle path.

Exam tip: Golaknath and Kesavananda both limited Parliament, but differently. Golaknath: Fundamental Rights cannot be abridged at all. Kesavananda: anything, including Fundamental Rights, can be amended, but not the basic structure. The seed of the idea lies earlier, in Mudholkar J's opinion in Sajjan Singh (1964).

2. Kesavananda Bharati (1973): the case that changed everything
3. Elements of the Basic Structure (master table)
4. Basic Structure applied: later cases
5. Debate on the doctrine (criticism and defence)
6. Landmark judgements and their impact
7. Doctrines of constitutional interpretation
For Mains: Analysis
Quick Revision
Common Exam Traps
Unlock the full note, MCQs and flashcards

Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.

Get started free