BrainParrot

The Siang dam and a threatened homeland

GS3Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 7 November 2026

Summary

  • The article reports on resistance by the Adi community to the 11,000 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP) in Arunachal Pradesh. The State is pushing the Pre-Feasibility Report (PFR) study, citing China's Medog dam on the Yarlung-Tsangpo.
  • Protests in October 2026 saw alleged lathi-charges and arrests, and arson at NHPC premises. The article also reports allegations that villagers' signatures on "irrevocable" PFR MoUs were obtained by deceit, force or threat of denying scheme benefits.
  • The SIFF rejected a fresh invitation for talks in Itanagar on 5 November. It demands release of detainees, withdrawal of security forces and a Chief Minister's visit to the affected areas.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: dams, displacement; GS2 — Federalism, tribal rights, Art. 371H; GS2 — IR (Brahmaputra/China)

Key facts for Prelims

  • SUMP: Siang river, Arunachal Pradesh (Siang/Upper Siang); executing agency NHPC; declared a national project in 2008 per the article; proposed sites include Parong, Uggeng and Dite Dime.
  • The Siang is the upper course of the Brahmaputra; Yarlung-Tsangpo is its Tibetan name; China's Medog dam is on the Yarlung-Tsangpo.
  • Adi tribe: Donyi Polo is their religion (per the article); Ridin grass thread is worn on the wrist.
  • Article 371H (55th Amendment, 1986): Governor's special responsibility for law and order in Arunachal; assembly of at least 30 members.
  • Articles 371A (Nagaland) and 371G (Mizoram) are the comparator provisions.
  • A Pre-Feasibility Report (PFR) is the technical study that precedes construction approvals; Environmental Clearance is needed before construction.
  • Arunachal Pradesh Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 2014: State law used to arrest anti-dam activists (per article).
  • RTI requests were filed (by SAAYA) seeking MoU details and were stonewalled (per article).

Data and details

  • The project was declared a national project in 2008. The SIFF formed in about 2012. Capacity: 11,000 MW.
  • Three proposed sites identified by the State for the PFR: Parong, Uggeng and a third site. Parong has a check post with Central forces and barricades, where anyone without "clearance" is stopped from reaching the Siang.
  • Medog (China) is described as several times the size of SUMP and billed as the world's largest dam project.
  • Chronology of events:
  • 4 Oct: Elderly protesters in Uggeng were allegedly lathi-charged; 54 were injured, along with a CRPF official.
  • 9 Oct: Prominent anti-dam activists from Geku were arrested under the Arunachal Pradesh Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 2014. Six more organisers from Riga were arrested in the following weeks.
  • 23 Oct: A youth solidarity march in Pasighat was allegedly met with lathi-charge and tear gas; mobs set fire to the NHPC premises. Youth protesters were detained the next day, and SIFF legal advisor Ebo Mili was arrested. More Central forces, armoured vehicles and barricades were deployed, and SIFF called bandhs.
  • 4–5 Nov: SIFF youth leader Dubit Siram said talks could not happen "while they are pointing guns" and set out demands (release of detainees, withdrawal of forces, CM to come to the affected areas). On 5 Nov, SIFF rejected the CM's office's invitation for talks in Itanagar.
  • The Simong villagers' blockade had lasted 11 days (Amoti Nopi, 62).
  • Impact claims: SIFF youth leader Jacob Ering said 27 villages would be fully submerged in the storage area, with the total possibly as high as 40. Toto Kombo (62, Simong) said ancestors are buried on the banks.
  • MoUs:
  • They date from September 2025, signed by one authorised member per village; the document does not say how or when representatives were picked.
  • An MoU (executed in the presence of Hydro-Power Department and SUMP nodal officers) records "irrevocable consent" to the PFR only, says this is not consent for the dam, and offers a "special relief package" coordinated by the State and Centre.
  • Villagers say 600 to 1,000 signatures appeared on these MoUs. In Riga, villagers say BJP representatives linked housing and livelihood scheme benefits to signing. In Geku, people say they signed blank papers for "development schemes". In Karko, Akkulung Apang (31) says he was told it was for an orange-orchard livelihood scheme. In some villages the administration cites individual signatures as consent of whole households.
  • MLA Oni Payang called a meeting at his Geku home in early June 2026 asking people to sign. Villagers then vandalised homes of suspected signatories and Payang's residence. Soon after, 34 residents swore an affidavit denying consent.
  • SIFF's alternative: dam smaller tributaries, which it says could generate at least twice SUMP's power (SIFF General Secretary Likeng Libang). Nopi: "no problems with smaller dams". SIFF's new president is Nabeng Burang.
  • Allegations of the political-economic backdrop:
  • Kaling Jerang (vice-president, People's Party of Arunachal, an ally of the Khandu government) says there is no account of what the State owes NHPC. Many in the region (the article attributes this to locals generally, not to Jerang) link the government's "desperation" to a soft loan from NHPC to revive the State's cooperative Apex Bank, months after Dorjee Khandu became CM in 2007.
  • He says the Dorjee Khandu government signed 143 MoUs/MoAs opening the State's river systems to hydropower, most of which never took off.
  • He traces the problem to Article 371H, which did not encode the protections given to Nagaland and Mizoram.
  • Tabiram Tatin (SIFF action committee chairperson for six years) says Riga is where the Adi settled first. He sees the PFR push as a "desperate last attempt" and notes the community's culture is under threat from modernity and "Christian proselytization".
  • Ering says he is followed by plainclothes officials and the community uses messengers for fear of phone monitoring. SAAYA president Geni Nangkar says RTI requests have been stonewalled.
  • SIFF and SAAYA have written to CM Pema Khandu declaring "collective non-consent" for both the dam and the PFR study. They also held rallies, angered by BJP MPs' and MLAs' claims that the dam will be built at any cost. Roadside graffiti between Geku and Riga reads "No Dam, No Survey", and a bridge over the Siang is manned by a large Rapid Action Force battalion. Villagers from Yinkiong, Riyu, Riga, Geku and Karko say signatures were obtained by deceit, force and threats of denying scheme benefits.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Large hydropower projects are justified on energy, flood-moderation and strategic grounds. They collide with indigenous communities' livelihood, cultural and consent rights, and with the legal need for a transparent, participatory EIA and R&R process.
  • Consent is the core issue. A PFR is a technical study (drilling, testing), but the article says the MoUs were used to manufacture consent. The concerns are about the quality of free, prior and informed consent and whether community-level (village meeting) decision-making was bypassed.
  • Strategic infrastructure on a transboundary river (Siang/Brahmaputra) raises questions of national security versus local rights. India has no international water treaty with China on this river, a gap the villagers raise.
  • Article 371H gives Arunachal's Governor a special law-and-order responsibility, but the article's source argues it lacks the land and cultural protections that Articles 371A and 371G give Nagaland and Mizoram.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: EIA, displacement and large dams; GS2 – Polity: Art. 371H, Centre-State and tribal governance; GS2 – IR: transboundary rivers (India-China, Brahmaputra)

Background primer

Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP)

What it is:
A proposed 11,200-MW multipurpose mega-hydropower and water-storage project on the Siang, intended to generate clean energy, regulate transboundary flows and moderate downstream floods. The article puts the capacity at 11,000 MW.
Mandate:
The pre-feasibility stage involves geological drilling, rock testing and seismic studies to assess technical viability, environmental risk and site suitability before construction approvals.
Why it matters:
It is seen as strengthening India's downstream storage and flow-regulation capability against China's upstream hydropower expansion. The Siang is the upper course of the Brahmaputra. Upstream in Tibet it is known as the Yarlung Tsangpo.

Article 371H (Arunachal Pradesh)

What it is:
A special constitutional provision for Arunachal Pradesh, recognising its administrative, geographical and security challenges.
Founded:
Inserted by the Constitution (55th Amendment) Act, 1986, effective 20 February 1987, when Arunachal attained full statehood.
Why it matters:
Arunachal's sparse population, tribal composition and sensitive international borders.

Additional context

  • In December 2024, CM Pema Khandu said the project was planned only to counter China's project, which he described as generating about 60,000 MW on the Yarlung Tsangpo before it enters India. He also said that if people did not want a dam, there would not be one ("Chapter closed"). The villagers' present stance, in the article, is "non-consent" for even the PFR.
  • A Rajya Sabha reply from the Ministry of Power (answered 5 August 2024) said the project was at a preliminary stage of investigation, that villagers had raised concerns, and that these were being addressed through outreach and awareness activities.
  • An explainer in July 2026 described the project as stalled, with SIFF and Adi Banne Kebang protests blocking NHPC's pre-feasibility surveys.
  • After the Pasighat protests escalated, an NHPC office and a police station were reported targeted in arson.
  • A report summarised by StudyIQ, citing The Indian Express, said NHPC awarded a PR firm a ₹8.73-crore contract in July 2025, extended until 6 November 2026 and raising the total to about ₹10.91 crore.

Mains dimensions

  • Consent and participation: The "irrevocable" MoU, signatures allegedly taken through scheme-benefit threats or blank papers, and the bypassing of village meetings raise the question of whether consent was free, prior and informed. Individual signatures were used to claim household consent. RTI stonewalling deepens the trust deficit.
  • Security vs. rights: The State justifies the PFR as a counter to Medog. Villagers ask why they should pay for the Union's failure to secure a water treaty with China. The Central forces' deployment and the arrests under the State's 2014 Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act show the securitisation of dissent.
  • Development alternatives: SIFF's tributary-dam proposal (claimed at least twice SUMP's power) and "no problem with smaller dams" show that opposition is to scale and submergence, not to development. EIA should compare alternatives.
  • Federal and constitutional angle: Article 371H gives the Governor a law-and-order role but, in the article's critique, no land or cultural safeguards like Articles 371A and 371G. The Centre's awareness of the State's tactics is questioned.
  • Culture and environment: Riga's role in Adi history, ancestral burial sites, and the grass Ridin (said not to grow elsewhere) show that displacement here means loss of civilisational heritage. Ecological and seismic concerns in the Eastern Himalayas add to this.
  • Governance and probity: The alleged NHPC loan and the 143 MoUs/MoAs raise questions about State-PSU financial entanglements and policy continuity.
  • Way forward: Pause the PFR and release detainees, then hold independent consultations at the village level. Conduct a transparent social and environmental impact study, publish MoUs, consider smaller run-of-river alternatives, and pursue India-China hydrological data-sharing and treaty diplomacy.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 / GS2, 15 marks:** "Large strategic hydropower projects in the Himalayas often pit national security and energy goals against indigenous communities' rights. Discuss with reference to the Siang Upper Multipurpose Project."

Related topics

  • Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006; Environmental Clearance and public hearings
  • Free, Prior and Informed Consent; RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and displacement
  • Articles 371A–371J and asymmetric federalism; Nabam Rebia case
  • Brahmaputra basin, India-China river issues, Brahmaputra Board
  • Dam-induced displacement (Tehri, Sardar Sarovar) and hydropower in the Northeast

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 7 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs