SC tells excluded voters not to fear prosecution; ECI insists on Form 6
Source: The Hindu, 5 November 2026
Summary
- In the special intensive revision (SIR) of Delhi's electoral rolls, voters excluded under the Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD) categories are being asked to apply again through Form 6, the form meant for new voters. The Supreme Court assured petitioners that no voter will face criminal prosecution for this. The matter will be heard next on 19 November.
- The ECI has also split the online Form 6 from the SIR declaration, so each now needs a separate OTP and e-sign.
- A Hindu investigation in Delhi's Mustafabad found that most BJP-appointed Booth Level Agents (BLAs) named as objectors in Form 7 deletion applications deny filing them. All the applications target Muslim electors.
Key facts for Prelims
- Form 6: registration of new electors (Registration of Electors Rules, 1960). Form 7: deletion or objection. Form 8: correction or shifting of residence.
- ASDD = Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate. These are the categories under which voters are removed during SIR.
- Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950: penal provision. The ECI's press note promised no penal action by EROs under it against electors merely for earlier enrolment plus a Form 6 during or after SIR.
- Article 324: ECI's superintendence of rolls and elections. Article 326: adult suffrage at 18.
- Roles: BLO (official, polling-station level), BLA (party-appointed), ERO (constituency-level registration officer) and CEO (State-level head of election machinery).
- The ECI's Delhi CEO website carries the public list of Form 7 applications.
Data and details
- Supreme Court (Delhi SIR case)
- On 28 October the Court said the ECI was in "error" to force deleted pre-existing voters to apply as new voters under Form 6.
- It orally suggested Form 8 (change of residence) or the SIR enumeration form for such voters.
- Petitioners are activists Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri, represented by Prashant Bhushan and Cheryl D'souza. They argued that voters were being made to misrepresent themselves as new applicants, an offence attracting imprisonment.
- On Wednesday Mr. Bhushan said voters were "in the horns of a dilemma". The CJI replied that the Court was dealing with the matter and asked how they could feel so. The Bench asked for an application on this aspect and listed the matter for 19 November.
- ECI press note (Tuesday)
- Submitting Form 6 for inclusion under SIR or afterwards is "not, by itself, false merely because the elector was previously enrolled".
- It promised no penal action under Section 31 of the RP Act, 1950 by EROs on that ground alone.
- Mr. Bhushan said this showed the Court's oral suggestions (Form 8 or enumeration forms) were not put into practice.
- Online Form 6
- The ECI separated Form 6 from the accompanying SIR declaration in States where SIR is under way. In September it had already withdrawn the declaration from digital platforms in States where SIR was complete.
- Since the Bihar SIR a separate declaration was added to physical forms. Online, it was a single form including the declaration.
- Combining them under one OTP had led to suggestions that the form was altered without Union Law Ministry approval.
- The change had been flagged in dissent notes by Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi.
- The ECI says it previously used a single OTP and e-sign "for operational convenience". Each document now needs its own OTP and e-sign, and both steps must be completed.
- A counter affidavit filed in court last week cited a 21 October decision of the ECI's electoral roll division that online Form 6 be divided into two parts: Form 6 as prescribed in the Rules, and the SIR Declaration.
- Mustafabad (Delhi), Form 7 deletion applications
- At least 77% of the 1,021 deletion applications filed so far list BJP-appointed BLAs as "objectors".
- The Hindu contacted all 20 BJP BLAs registered in ECI records. They are named as filers of 787 Form 7s citing reasons such as "absent/permanently shifted", "already enrolled" and "death".
- All the applications are against Muslim electors. 16 of 20 BLAs denied filing or signing any form since the claims and objections phase began on 31 August.
- The 787 applications are 94% of the 837 deletion applications filed by third parties on the Delhi CEO list.
- BLA Ankit Yadav, named in 32 applications, denied filing any, and said he had complained and resigned as BLA.
- Chandra Shekhar Nainwal, named in applications for 28 Muslim electors, denied filing them and said he was not associated with the BJP. Four others said they were no longer associated with the BJP in that capacity.
- Robin Singh Dhama, named in 57 cases, is the exception. He acknowledged filing Form 7s and claimed to have submitted "500 of those".
- With the area BLO's help, The Hindu verified that all the electors concerned live at their registered addresses. The BLO said he had received no physical copies of Form 7s.
- The district election officer, Delhi CEO and ECI did not respond to The Hindu's questions.
- An earlier Hindu report (30 October) found BJP BLAs named as objectors against Muslim electors who were living at their addresses.
Static–dynamic linkage
The ECI has constitutional "superintendence, direction and control" of the preparation of electoral rolls and conduct of elections (Art. 324). Article 326 guarantees adult suffrage to citizens aged 18 and above. Rolls are prepared by statute and rules (Representation of the People Act, 1950 and Registration of Electors Rules, 1960). Different forms serve different functions: Form 6 is for new voters, Form 7 for deletion or objection and Form 8 for correction or shifting. The dispute is about whether the ECI is using the right form for existing voters who were purged. A wrong form can expose a voter to a charge of false declaration. The case tests the balance between a "pure" roll (removing ineligible entries) and inclusiveness ("no eligible citizen left out").
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Election Commission (Art. 324), electoral rolls and the Representation of the People Acts; free and fair elections; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability of constitutional bodies.
Background primer
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- An intensive verification and re-enumeration drive by the ECI, using house-to-house enumeration to build fresh rolls by removing deceased, shifted, duplicate and ineligible voters.
Who does what
The forms
Additional context
- Why excluded voters are pointed to Form 6: If the enumeration form is not deposited with the BLO, the name does not appear in the draft roll. A person who then wants to enrol can file Form 6 with the Declaration Form during the claims and objections period.
- ECI training material for SIR says an elector unable to submit the enumeration form in time may file Form 6 with the prescribed Declaration Form during claims and objections.
Mains dimensions
- Procedural fairness in roll revision: Purged voters are pushed into a "new voter" form whose false declaration carries imprisonment. This creates fear of prosecution even though the ECI says no penal action will follow. The Supreme Court had to intervene orally on 28 October and again at the Wednesday (4 November) hearing. The gap between oral assurances and the ECI's actual forms and portals is the core issue.
- Franchise and inclusion: Article 326 and the principle that "no eligible citizen is left out" collide with the purity objective. Burdens fall on the migrant, poor and marginalised, who are least able to navigate forms and documents.
- Misuse of the objection mechanism: In Mustafabad, 77% of 1,021 deletion applications list BLAs who mostly deny filing, and all target Muslim electors. This points to possible impersonation and targeted deletion. The BLO's confirmation that electors live at their addresses undermines the stated grounds. Lack of ECI response is an accountability gap.
- ECI's institutional credibility: Dissent notes by two Election Commissioners on the online Form 6 change, and the question of whether the Law Ministry approved the change, raise concerns about collegial functioning and about forms being altered without legal process.
- Safeguards that exist: First appeal to the DM and second appeal to the CEO. The BLO field-verifies and the ERO decides after satisfaction.
- Way forward: Use the correct form for each category (Form 8 or enumeration form for existing voters), statutory penal protections stated in the rules themselves, scrutiny and audit of Form 7 filings, and independent oversight of the revision.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls aims at purity but may undermine inclusion. Critically examine with reference to the Election Commission's powers under Article 324 and recent controversies."
Related topics
- Article 324–329; Representation of the People Act, 1950 (rolls) and 1951 (conduct and disqualification)
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960; ERO, BLO and DEO hierarchy
- Appointment and independence of the ECI (CEC and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023)
- Right to vote: constitutional vs. fundamental right; universal adult suffrage
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 5 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs