What the BRICS carbon market partnership needs
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 5 November 2026
Summary
- At the 18th BRICS Summit in New Delhi (12 September), the New Delhi Declaration repeated the BRICS commitment to implement the MoU on the BRICS Carbon Markets Partnership. The commitment is modest: capacity-building and experience-sharing only.
- The author argues that, with India's BRICS presidency in its last quarter, the partnership needs a common measurement, reporting and verification (MRV) rulebook rather than a joint trading platform.
- He adds a small pilot built on Article 6.2 of the Paris Agreement, and institutional support from the New Development Bank.
Key facts for Prelims
- CCTS legal basis: Energy Conservation (Amendment) Act, 2022. BEE is the administrator and CERC regulates trading. One certificate equals 1 tCO₂e.
- CCTS gradually absorbs the PAT scheme (energy-efficiency based, started 2012) and focuses on emissions intensity, not absolute emissions.
- Paris Agreement Article 6.2 = bilateral cooperative approaches (ITMOs). Article 6.4 = UN-supervised crediting mechanism. Corresponding adjustment prevents double counting.
- CBAM = EU's carbon border tax. It covers steel, aluminium, cement, fertilisers, hydrogen and electricity, and entered its definitive phase on 1 January 2026.
- The UK's CBAM equivalent follows in January 2027.
- India has a Joint Crediting Mechanism with Japan.
- ISO 14064 (GHG quantification, reporting and verification) and ISO 14065 (accreditation of verifiers) are the standards named in the editorial.
- Brazil's SBCE is a cap-and-trade system created by a 2024 law. China's emissions trading system (ETS) now includes steel, cement and aluminium.
- Authorised Economic Operator (AEO) programmes are mutual-recognition schemes in customs, which the editorial cites as a model.
Data and details
- The 18th BRICS Summit was held in New Delhi on 12 September. The Rio summit acknowledged the MoU in 2025, and New Delhi reiterated it. The commitment is limited to capacity-building and experience-sharing, with no trading framework, targets or timeline.
- Eight BRICS members reportedly operate voluntary carbon markets. Brazil, China, India and Indonesia host over a third of the carbon credit projects registered worldwide.
- India's CCTS has notified emission-intensity targets for 490 entities across nine sectors and has opened an offset mechanism.
- China's ETS added steel, cement and aluminium through its 2024-25 allocation plan.
- None of these markets is linked to another.
- Design differences:
- China and India allocate by output-based intensity benchmarks. Brazil is building an absolute cap.
- China admits only China Certified Emission Reduction credits.
- India admits only projects begun after 1 January 2025, and they must be exclusive.
- Brazil will accept credits only under methodologies accredited by a body not yet constituted.
- In Brazil the securities regulator oversees the market. In India certificates trade on power exchanges under CERC rules. So the same tonne is a different legal instrument in each country.
- BRICS' own 2025 Principles for Fair, Inclusive and Transparent Carbon Accounting call for peer comparison under similar conditions, granular default values and interoperable systems. The Delhi Declaration does not carry these forward, though it commits members to interoperable standards for low-emission hydrogen and welcomes cooperation among national standards bodies.
- The Declaration calls CBAM unilateral, punitive and discriminatory.
- UK recognition of India's CCTS came in August 2026. Relief depends on a form completed by an ISO 14065-accredited verifier. London decided unilaterally, so each exporting country negotiates alone.
- The EU's CBAM entered its definitive phase in January 2026, and the UK's follows in January 2027. Both cover steel, aluminium, cement, fertilizer and hydrogen, and credit a carbon price paid at origin only with verified evidence.
- Proposals:
- A BRICS rulebook with three parts: common monitoring rules consistent with ISO 14064 for border-exposed sectors, mutual recognition of verifiers accredited by national accreditation bodies, and harmonised registry data fields.
- A pilot with two or three members mutually recognising methodologies, and counting a capped volume of authorised units from a partner registry within the domestic offset limit.
- The NDB could host a shared registry data facility or a purchasing facility for pilot units.
- A dialogue on aligning carbon markets with adaptation could direct a share of intra-BRICS transfer proceeds to adaptation, as the Article 6.4 mechanism does.
- Frictions: corresponding adjustments (host cannot count the mitigation towards its own NDC), cross-border settlement (capital account rules, legal classification of the unit, for the BRICS Payment Task Force) and double issuance (registries must exchange serial numbers and retirement data).
- Divergent interests: China's scale would make it the price-setter, sanctions complicate settlement, and several members compete in steel and aluminium exports. The author says full linkage is neither likely nor desirable for now.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Carbon markets put a price on emissions. They are either compliance systems (a government sets a cap or intensity target) or voluntary offset markets.
- Without common rules, one tonne of abatement has a different legal status and acceptance in each jurisdiction. This raises costs and blocks linkage.
- Border carbon measures such as CBAM turn that fragmentation into a trade problem. A credible, verified accounting standard is what lets exporters prove carbon already paid at home.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: climate change mitigation, carbon markets, Paris Agreement (Article 6). GS3 – Economy: trade and environment (CBAM). GS2 – IR: groupings and agreements involving India (BRICS).
Background primer
Indian Carbon Credit Trading Scheme (CCTS)
- What it is:
- India's national market-based mechanism to price greenhouse gas emissions and issue tradable Carbon Credit Certificates.
Article 6 of the Paris Agreement
- What it is:
- A provision that lets countries cooperate voluntarily to achieve their NDCs.
EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM)
- What it is:
- An EU tool that equalises the carbon price paid by European manufacturers with that on imports, to prevent carbon leakage.
New Development Bank (NDB)
- What it is:
- A multilateral development bank set up by the BRICS countries to mobilise resources for infrastructure and sustainable development projects in BRICS and other emerging economies.
- Founded:
- Agreed at the 2014 BRICS summit in Fortaleza (Brazil) and operational from 2015. It is headquartered in Shanghai.
- Members:
- Founded by Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa. Further membership details are not confirmed from a trusted source.
- Why it matters:
- To provide an alternative source of development finance for emerging economies. The editorial suggests it could host a shared registry data facility or a purchasing facility for pilot units.
Additional context
- Default values: Under the EU CBAM, firms that cannot provide verified, installation-level emissions data face higher default values. This hits smaller exporters hardest, and it matches the editorial's warning about punitive defaults.
- UK recognition of CCTS: The UK recognised India's CCTS as a qualifying carbon-pricing mechanism under its CBAM. Importers can claim relief equal to the effective carbon price already paid under the CCTS.
- India-EU: ForumIAS notes that the India–EU FTA provides no exemption from CBAM. An annex (Annex 14-A) allows technical dialogue on CBAM implementation and carbon-price recognition.
- CCTS institutions: Grid Controller of India Limited functions as the registry for the carbon market.
Mains dimensions
- Fragmentation is the core problem: Different design (intensity vs cap), eligibility rules and legal status of units block linkage. The Declaration's weak mandate (capacity-building only) leaves it unresolved.
- MRV as the first deliverable: It is low-cost, preserves regulatory autonomy and strengthens domestic compliance markets. It also builds on BRICS's own 2025 accounting principles.
- CBAM as the external driver:
- The Declaration calls CBAM unilateral, punitive and discriminatory.
- The author argues opposition has more weight when backed by a verifiable accounting standard.
- The UK's recognition of India's CCTS shows the alternative: bilateral, unilateral-on-their-terms deals.
- Article 6.2 pilot: It tests corresponding adjustment, settlement and registry issues, and turns each friction into a drafting question with an owner. India already has Japan's JCM as a template.
- Institutions: The NDB (registry or purchasing facility) and an adaptation dialogue give members with limited mitigation potential a stake.
- Limits: Divergent interests (China's price-setting scale, sanctions, steel/aluminium competition) mean ambition must stay modest.
- India's leadership: India's BRICS presidency can set the agenda in its last quarter, while protecting domestic policy space.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Fragmented carbon markets and the EU's CBAM pose challenges for emerging economies. Discuss how a BRICS carbon-market rulebook could help India and its partners, and the obstacles it faces."
Related topics
- Paris Agreement: NDCs, Article 6, CBDR-RC
- India's Energy Conservation (Amendment) Act, 2022; Green Credit Programme
- Carbon pricing: ETS vs carbon tax; cap-and-trade vs baseline-and-credit
- CBAM, WTO compatibility and India-EU trade talks
- New Development Bank; BRICS groupings
- Greenwashing, additionality and MRV in carbon markets
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 5 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs