Why make litigants rush to SC for early hearings, CJI asks HCs
Source: The Hindu, 2 November 2026
Summary
- CJI Surya Kant, in an address at the Kerala High Court (the photo caption places him with SC judge S.V.N. Bhatti at the inauguration of the High Court's platinum jubilee celebrations), flagged a "growing tendency" of litigants moving the Supreme Court for urgent listing or early hearing of matters pending in High Courts.
- He said the Supreme Court respects High Court autonomy, including control over their own rosters. He framed his questions as shared responsibility, not criticism of High Courts. He asked whether urgent matters can be better identified, listing made more transparent and predictable, technology used to prioritise cases where delay causes irreversible prejudice, and access to timely justice freed from the need to travel to Delhi.
- He added that timely and effective functioning reinforces public confidence in the independence of courts.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 32: Right to Constitutional Remedies (SC writ power; itself a fundamental right). Art. 226: High Courts' power to issue writs, wider in scope than Art. 32.
- Five writs: habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, quo warranto.
- L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997): the power of judicial review through writ jurisdiction of the High Courts and the SC is part of the basic structure.
- Art. 32 is described as the "heart and soul" of the Constitution (Ambedkar). Art. 32(4): the right cannot be suspended except as provided by the Constitution.
- Art. 226 power is discretionary and is available for fundamental rights and "any other purpose".
Data and details
- Pending in High Courts across the country: 65,54,788 cases.
- Pending in the Supreme Court: 97,201 cases, "dangerously close" to an unprecedented one-lakh mark.
- SC strength rose from 34 to 38 judges (including the CJI), yet pendency has continued to rise.
- The 25 High Courts have 292 vacancies against a sanctioned strength of 1,122 as on 6 October 2026. That is about 26% vacancy (derived from these figures).
- Quotes: the CJI said judicial independence and efficiency are "braided together" and are not competing virtues. He added that the difference between justice and injustice lies in whether the court intervenes when intervention is most needed, not in the final judgment.
- The CJI said the High Courts' powers under Art. 226 exceed the Supreme Court's powers under Art. 32. He also said the SC has "consistently respected" High Court autonomy, including control over rosters.
- Timely and effective functioning reinforces public confidence in the independence of courts (CJI).
- The CJI's four questions: can urgent matters be identified more effectively, can listing procedures be more transparent and predictable, can technology prioritise cases where delay may cause irreversible prejudice, and can timely justice be free of the need to travel to the national capital.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Constitution creates two parallel writ routes. Art. 32 lets a person go directly to the Supreme Court for fundamental rights, and Art. 32 is itself a fundamental right. Art. 226 lets High Courts issue writs for fundamental rights and "any other purpose". Because litigants can invoke the SC directly, urgent matters from High Courts can end up being brought to Delhi. This adds to the SC's own backlog and makes access depend on location. The CJI's point, as reported, is that the High Courts have the wider writ power under Art. 226 and should be able to handle urgent matters themselves.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Structure, organisation and functioning of the Judiciary; GS2 – Governance: judicial reforms, pendency; Constitution Arts. 32, 226.
Background primer
Article 32 (Supreme Court) vs Article 226 (High Courts)
- What it is:
- The SC can issue writs (habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, quo warranto) for enforcement of fundamental rights. High Courts can issue writs to any person or authority, including government, for fundamental rights "and for any other purpose".
- Why it matters:
- Dr B.R. Ambedkar described Art. 32 as the "heart and soul of the Constitution". In L. Chandra Kumar (1997) the SC held that judicial review by the High Courts and the SC under Arts. 226 and 32 forms part of the basic structure.
Mains dimensions
- Pendency is structural: About 65.5 lakh High Court cases and 97,201 SC cases show the system is overloaded. Raising the SC from 34 to 38 judges did not stop the rise, which suggests the problem is not only the number of judges at the top.
- Vacancies: 292 vacancies out of 1,122 sanctioned (about 26%) in the High Courts show a vacancy problem alongside the pendency.
- Access and equity: Litigants who must travel to Delhi for urgent listing face cost and distance barriers. Timely justice should not depend on the ability to reach the national capital.
- Federal judicial structure: The SC taking up urgent High Court matters cuts against High Court autonomy (including roster control) and the Art. 226 design. The CJI's call is for High Courts to build credible internal urgency mechanisms.
- Independence and efficiency: The CJI links the two as "braided together". Timely functioning builds public confidence in court independence.
- Way forward: Transparent, predictable listing rules. Technology-assisted triage of urgent or irreversible-harm cases. Filling vacancies. Better case management and e-courts. Consistent application of the principle that litigants should approach the High Court first where an effective remedy exists.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 10 marks:** "Judicial independence and efficiency are not competing virtues. In the light of rising pendency in the Supreme Court and High Courts, discuss the role of Articles 32 and 226 and suggest reforms for timely access to justice."
Related topics
- Judicial pendency, e-Courts, National Judicial Data Grid and appointment of judges (Collegium, vacancies)
- Public Interest Litigation and writ jurisprudence
- Basic structure doctrine and judicial review
- Original, appellate and advisory jurisdiction of the Supreme Court
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 2 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs