BrainParrot

Why even a strong El Niño does not guarantee a poor Indian monsoon

GS1Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 2 November 2026

Summary

  • A "ferocious" El Niño is developing in 2026 and is expected to peak in December. The southwest monsoon ended about 13% below the long-term average.
  • The article asks why a comparably strong El Niño in 1997 still produced near-normal rain. It cites the Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD), where the warmest El Niño water sat, and other atmospheric factors.
  • It also looks at how IMD's forecasting has changed since then. IMD's 2026 forecast of 92% ±5 compared with an actual 87.4%.

UPSC relevance: GS1 – Geography (climatology); GS3 – Environment/agriculture

Key facts for Prelims

  • ENSO: the El Niño phase involves warm water shifting east across the Pacific. The cycle recurs every 2–7 years.
  • IOD positive phase: the western Indian Ocean is warmer and the eastern cooler. It is beneficial for the Indian monsoon.
  • IOD timing: it tends to tip around June and is most pronounced September–November, so its effect comes later in the monsoon. It tends to go positive when an El Niño occurs.
  • IMD's "deficient" category: rainfall at least 10% below the long-term average (as the article defines it).
  • Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO): a wave of clouds and rain that passes around the tropics every 30–60 days.
  • NOAA's Oceanic Niño Index measures Pacific SST anomalies.
  • The monsoon delivers about three-quarters of India's annual rain.

Data and details

  • 1997: IMD predicted a deficit of 8% below average, but rainfall was nearly normal by the end of September.
  • ONI at monsoon time: 1.64°C (1997), 1.59°C (2015) and 1.98°C (2026).
  • Outcomes: 1997 had normal rain and 2015 about 13% below normal.
  • 2026: the monsoon ended nearly 13% below the long-term average of 87 cm. East and Northeast India had their driest season since records began in 1901.
  • NOAA records: seven monsoons since 1950 met a moderate or strong El Niño. In five of them, including 2026, rain was at least 10% below the long-term average. 2023 was an exception, with "below average" rainfall. Only 1997 had average rainfall.
  • 2023: August rain was 36% below normal, the driest August since 1901. IMD partly blamed the MJO, which sat over Africa and the Americas that month. The IOD tipped in India's favour in late August and early September.
  • Forecast vs actual: 2023 forecast 96% ±5 points, actual 94.7%. 2026 forecast 92% ±5 points, actual 87.4%.
  • 2026 forecast misses: IMD said "below normal" in April but the season was "deficient". Only one of its four regional forecasts (the south peninsula) came true.
  • IOD disagreement: in April, IMD cited models showing a positive IOD late in the season. In early September, the WMO still expected a positive IOD for September–November. IMD's own model predicted neutral from late May, and its records show the IOD stayed neutral all season.
  • Research cited:
  • 2024 study (IIT-Delhi, IIT-Kharagpur, NIT-Rourkela with US researchers): a change in the belt of winds around Antarctica sent westerlies across the southern Indian Ocean, stopping the 2015 see-saw from tipping.
  • 2006 study in Science: when El Niño's warmest water is in the mid-Pacific, sinking air is likelier to settle on India. In 1997 the warmest water lay further east near South America.
  • July study in Nature Communications: other July–August factors mattered in 1997, namely a high-altitude high-pressure system over the Iranian plateau and extra Arabian Sea moisture. It also said 1983 and 1997 made El Niño's influence look weaker than it was.
  • Exposure: about 40% of farmland is unirrigated and depends on the monsoon, per the agriculture ministry's latest figures. IMD's May forecast warned of "pressure on drinking water resources".

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The Indian monsoon is a coupled ocean-atmosphere system, so no single driver determines it. El Niño suppresses rain by shifting the Walker circulation. Part of the rising Pacific air sinks over India, which becomes warmer and drier.
  • The positive IOD, the location of El Niño's warm water, the Madden-Julian Oscillation (MJO) and mid-latitude features can each amplify or offset that effect.
  • Forecasting is therefore probabilistic. This matters for sowing decisions, food stocks and reservoir releases.

Syllabus mapping: GS1 – Geography: climatology, Walker circulation, El Niño/La Niña, Indian monsoon mechanism; GS3 – Agriculture and Environment: monsoon variability, drought and food prices.

Background primer

El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO)

What it is:
a recurring Pacific climate cycle. Trade winds along the equator weaken and warm water moves east towards South America, taking the rain clouds with it.

Indian Ocean Dipole (IOD)

What it is:
a see-saw of sea-surface temperature between the western Indian Ocean (near Africa) and the eastern (near Indonesia).

India Meteorological Department (IMD)

Additional context

  • IMD said that by June 2026 sea-surface temperatures in the central tropical Pacific had crossed the El Niño threshold. It expected a neutral IOD to continue to the end of the monsoon season. A neutral IOD means it is unlikely to significantly amplify or offset El Niño's effects this year.
  • IMD's own FAQ states that a positive IOD can partially offset El Niño's drying influence. IMD therefore considers both ENSO and IOD when preparing seasonal monsoon forecasts.

Mains dimensions

  • Beyond the ENSO headline: El Niño raises the odds of a poor monsoon but does not determine it. 1997 and 2015 had similar ONI values (1.64°C and 1.59°C) yet opposite outcomes. The IOD, warm-pool location, MJO and mid-latitude circulation modulate the result.
  • Forecasting progress and limits: 2023 and 2026 totals fell within the ±5-point error margin. Even so, the April category was wrong in 2026 (below normal vs deficient), only one of four regional forecasts was right, and IOD forecasts diverged between IMD and the WMO.
  • Agrarian impact: about 40% of farmland is unirrigated. A weak monsoon cuts farm incomes and raises food prices. Dams and food stocks are managed on these forecasts.
  • Regional extremes: East and Northeast India had their driest season since 1901. This shows the need for district-level and sub-seasonal advisories.
  • Way forward: better coupled ocean-atmosphere models, more Indian Ocean observation, communication of uncertainty to farmers, and contingency planning for crops, water and prices.

Possible Mains question

**GS1/GS3, 15 marks:** "El Niño years do not always produce deficient Indian monsoons. Explain the role of the Indian Ocean Dipole and other factors in modulating the El Niño–monsoon relationship, and discuss the implications for monsoon forecasting and agriculture."

Related topics

  • Walker circulation; El Niño Modoki; La Niña; Southern Oscillation Index
  • Monsoon mechanism: ITCZ, jet streams, Mascarene High, monsoon break
  • Mission Mausam; IMD forecast categories (long-period average, deficient, below normal)
  • Drought management: MSP and buffer stock; Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchayee Yojana (PMKSY) and irrigation coverage

Topics: GS1Geography

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 2 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs