India’s China+1 lessons lie within its own States
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 15 October 2026
Summary
- Drawing on 50 interviews with industry executives, policymakers and experts for a 2026 East Asian Institute study, the authors argue that global firms choose a State, not "India".
- They say India's China+1 debate should study Tamil Nadu and Karnataka before looking at Vietnam, Mexico or Poland.
- Central schemes (PLI, ECMS, Press Note 3 easing) help, but the factory still has to come up in a particular State. The State's land, power, approvals, workers and suppliers decide whether it does.
Key facts for Prelims
- Press Note 3 (2020), issued by DPIIT on 17 April 2020, mandates the Government route for FDI from land-border countries or from beneficial owners there.
- The March 2026 easing allows non-controlling beneficial ownership up to 10% via the automatic route, and sets a 60-day timeline for specified manufacturing sectors.
- PLI was launched in 2020. The PLI for Large Scale Electronics Manufacturing (LSEM) ended on 31 March 2026. The Cabinet approved the Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme (₹62,500 crore) as its successor.
- ECMS targets electronic components, sub-assemblies and capital goods. It is run by MeitY.
- FDI includes equity in unlisted Indian companies and holdings of 10% or more in listed ones, per DPIIT.
- DPIIT's state-wise FDI equity data is based on the State of the receiving company's head office, not where the money is spent.
- Land is a State subject (Entry 18, List II). Electricity is in the Concurrent List.
Data and details
- Research base: 50 interviews. EAI Special Report, "India, China, and the 'China+1' Strategies of Global Firms" (September 2026). A Global Policy 2026 paper by P.S. Srinivas, Frank N. Pieke and Alfred Schipke.
- Tamil Nadu:
- Foxconn employs tens of thousands at Sriperumbudur near Chennai. Tata Electronics has expanded at Hosur.
- In January 2026 the Centre approved Tamil Nadu projects under ECMS. These include mobile-phone enclosure units by Yuzhan Technology (a Foxconn-linked firm) and Tata Electronics. These are commitments, not finished factories.
- The industrial base took four or five decades to build. Tamil Nadu invested in technical education, an automobile and components industry around Chennai, and suppliers and skills.
- Policy continuity was tested after the change of government in May 2026.
- Constraints are land, power and labour. It relies on migrant workers from northern and central States. It is trying to move to capital-intensive and innovation-led exports.
- Karnataka:
- Bengaluru began with software and engineering talent, not an automobile base.
- Foxconn's 300-acre Devanahalli campus has about 80% women workers (reportedly) and aims at about 50,000 jobs.
- Tata Electronics took over Wistron's iPhone plant at Narsapura (deal agreed late 2023) and has grown rapidly since.
- Central support:
- A manufacturer's illustration: "If the duty is 20 per cent and I get a PLI of 6 per cent, competitors cannot compete with me."
- The PLI for large-scale electronics ended on 31 March 2026. The Cabinet approved a successor on 15 July.
- In January the Centre cleared 22 ECMS proposals worth ₹41,863 crore, expected to create 33,791 direct jobs across eight States. The Centre calls this "geographically balanced industrial growth".
- In March, the Cabinet approved easing Press Note 3, which had introduced curbs in 2020.
- FDI equity inflows by State, October 2019 to March 2026 (DPIIT):
- Maharashtra 31%
- Karnataka 21%
- Gujarat 15%
- Delhi 13%
- Tamil Nadu is fifth, at about 6%
- DPIIT books FDI against the State of the receiving company's head office. So the data say little about where factories are being built.
- Components and value addition:
- "Very few components are manufactured in India", with "huge reliance on China for major parts and supply chains".
- One firm set a billion-dollar India-sourcing target but managed about 600 million after two or three years.
- "Value addition... is a four-to-five-year process."
- Trade gap: electronics exports were about $48 billion in 2025-26 against imports of about $116 billion. One executive described the exports as "assembled products with 20 per cent inputs in India".
- Divide: growth is "largely happening in the southern and western parts, not in the most populous States such as Bihar, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand".
- A veteran investor told the authors to look at specific States, not India. National debates cite Vietnam's industrial parks, Mexico's nearshoring and Poland's supply chains.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Industrial policy runs on two tracks. The Centre sets trade, tariff, FDI and incentive policy, such as PLI, ECMS and FDI rules. States control the factors of production on the ground.
- In the Seventh Schedule, land is a State subject (Entry 18, List II). Industries are in List II (Entry 24), subject to Union control over specified industries (Entries 7 and 52, List I). Electricity (Entry 38) and labour welfare (Entry 24) are in the Concurrent List.
- This explains why ecosystems built over decades, with technical education, suppliers and administrative experience, matter more than headline subsidies. It also explains regional concentration of manufacturing, and why India's China+1 gains are not evenly spread.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: Industrial policy, investment models, manufacturing, infrastructure. GS2 – Federalism: Centre–State roles in industrial development. GS1 – Regional disparities in industrial location.
Background primer
China+1 strategy
- What it is:
- A global trend of companies diversifying manufacturing and supply chains by setting up operations beyond China.
- Founded:
- It emerged from firms' concern over supply-chain risk and geopolitical tension. A precise start date is not applicable.
- Members:
- Not a body. The article cites Vietnam (industrial parks), Mexico (nearshoring) and Poland (supply chains) as models India is usually told to study.
- Mandate:
- Reduce risks from over-dependence on a single country, particularly geopolitical tensions and disruptions.
- Why it matters:
- Resilient, diversified supply chains.
Production Linked Incentive (PLI) scheme
- What it is:
- A scheme offering financial incentives to eligible companies based on incremental sales.
- Founded:
- First launched in April 2020, starting with mobile manufacturing and specified electronic components, among others. It later expanded to 14 sectors.
- Mandate:
- For large-scale electronics, incentives of 4%–6% on incremental sales for eligible target segments.
- Why it matters:
- Offset cost disabilities and build scale, exports and domestic production.
Electronics Components Manufacturing Scheme (ECMS)
- What it is:
- A scheme to deepen the supply chain and develop a robust electronics component ecosystem.
- Founded:
- Approved by the Union Cabinet with funding of ₹22,919 crore. It aimed at ₹59,350 crore of investment and ₹4,56,500 crore of production.
- Mandate:
- Attract investment in PCBs, passive and electro-mechanical components, sub-assemblies, camera modules, optical transceivers and capital goods.
- Why it matters:
- Move from assembly to components and materials, reducing import dependence.
Press Note 3 (2020), FDI from land-border countries
- What it is:
- A DPIIT FDI-policy amendment. It requires an entity of a country sharing a land border with India, or with a beneficial owner there, to invest only via the Government route.
- Founded:
- Press Note 3 (2020) dated 17 April 2020, to curb opportunistic takeovers during COVID-19. It was enforced through the FEMA (Non-Debt Instruments) Amendment Rules, 2020.
- Mandate:
- Prior government approval. A subsequent change of beneficial ownership into such a jurisdiction also needs approval.
- Why it matters:
- Protect Indian firms from opportunistic takeovers, and scrutinise capital from neighbours (in practice, mainly China).
DPIIT (Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade)
- What it is:
- A department of the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. It issues FDI policy and publishes FDI data.
- Mandate:
- State-wise FDI equity data has been maintained from October 2019. This is the series the article uses.
Additional context
- PLI-LSEM's end and successor: On 15 July 2026 the Cabinet approved the Mobile Phone Manufacturing Scheme (MPMS) with an outlay of ₹62,500 crore. It runs for five years, FY 2026-27 to FY 2030-31. The tenure of PLI-LSEM ended on 31 March 2026. Incentives range from 2.25% to 5%, with extra support for local sourcing, Indian brands, design and R&D. About 60,000 direct jobs are expected.
- PLI-LSEM's record: The incentive outlay was ₹34,139 crore, with ₹19,091 crore disbursed as of March 2026. Major component and EMS companies in the smartphone ecosystem grew from 10 to 40+. India is the second largest mobile manufacturer by volume and has moved from net importer to net exporter of mobiles.
- ECMS progress: By August 2026, 106 applications across 15 States and 30 products had been approved. They cover ₹69,548 crore of expected investment and 74,628 direct jobs. 38 plants had begun manufacturing and 16 more were at advanced stages. Budget 2026-27 raised the scheme outlay to ₹40,000 crore.
- Semiconductor push: The Cabinet approved Semicon 2.0 on 15 July 2026 with an outlay of ₹1,27,500 crore.
- Press Note 3 easing (March 2026): Investments where land-border-country entities hold non-controlling beneficial ownership of up to 10% are permitted via the automatic route, subject to sectoral caps and compliance. The Cabinet also set a 60-day timeline for proposals in capital goods, electronic capital goods, electronic components, polysilicon and ingot-wafer manufacturing. Majority ownership and control must remain with resident Indians. Strategic sectors such as semiconductors remain restricted.
- Why the easing matters: China accounted for only about 0.32% (US$2.51 billion) of India's cumulative FDI inflows from April 2000 to December 2025. The Commerce Ministry reported 29 FDI investments worth ₹4,895.65 crore under the revised framework (non-controlling land-border-country ownership of up to 10%) up to 20 August 2026.
Mains dimensions
- State, not nation, is the unit of investor choice: Firms pick a State, and with it land, power, approvals, workers and suppliers. Centre-level incentives (PLI, ECMS, the Press Note 3 easing) only matter if a State can deliver these.
- Ecosystems take decades: Tamil Nadu's base took four or five decades. Karnataka's grew from software and engineering talent. No industrial-park announcement or subsidy round "conjures" this. Spreading subsidies thinly will not replicate either model.
- Policy continuity: Investors say commitments must survive political turnover. Tamil Nadu's change of government in May 2026 is a test case.
- Data caveat: DPIIT's head-office-based FDI data hides the real geography of factories, so Tamil Nadu's fifth rank (about 6%) understates its manufacturing role.
- Assembly trap: Exports of about $48 billion against imports of about $116 billion, and about 20% Indian inputs, show thin backward linkages. The firm that sourced about 600 million of a billion-dollar target shows how slow localisation is. ECMS is the policy answer.
- Regional inequality: Growth is concentrated in the south and west. Populous States such as Bihar, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand are left behind. Centre's "geographically balanced" ECMS spread (eight States for the January tranche) is a corrective, but capacity must be built.
- Way forward: Study what States did to prepare land, train workers, clear approvals and retain investors. Separate the replicable from what rests on decades of accumulated capacity. Pair central incentives with State-level capacity and component localisation.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Global firms choose States, not countries, when relocating production. In light of the experience of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, examine the role of State-level capabilities in realising India's China+1 opportunity and the limits of central incentives."
Related topics
- Make in India, Atmanirbhar Bharat and the PLI schemes across sectors
- Global value chains and backward linkages
- FDI policy: automatic vs Government route, Press Note 3, DPIIT
- Semicon India Programme and the India Semiconductor Mission
- Cooperative and competitive federalism: Seventh Schedule (land, industries, electricity)
- Regional imbalance in industrial development and inter-State migration
Topics: GS3Economy
All current affairs of 15 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs