A split verdict, faltering remedies and people’s power
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 15 October 2026
Summary
- On 23 September 2026 a two-judge SC Bench delivered a split verdict on a challenge to the 2023 law governing appointment of the CEC and Election Commissioners (ECs).
- Justice Dipankar Datta held that the Anoop Baranwal (2023) Constitution Bench had already settled the constitutional position, so the 2023 Act must be tested against that judgment.
- Justice Satish Chandra Sharma held that the case should go to a larger Constitution Bench.
- The two judges also passed a common order asking for an expeditious Constitution Bench hearing.
- The author argues that this prolongs the life of a law that is "on its face" unconstitutional. He also raises a possible conflict of interest involving Justice Sharma, and says people's movements are the larger remedy.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324: the ECI's superintendence, direction and control of elections. Art. 324(2): appointment of the CEC and ECs is subject to a law made by Parliament.
- Art. 145(3): a Constitution Bench needs at least five judges for substantial questions of law on interpreting the Constitution.
- Statute in question: the Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023. It repeals the 1991 Act and replaced the CJI in the selection panel with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM.
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023): a Constitution Bench set the interim PM + LoP + CJI committee.
- Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra (2002) is the case that introduced curative petitions. The article cites it for the view that non-disclosure by a judge of a connection with the subject-matter or parties can vitiate a judgment.
- Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct; the Restatement of Values of Judicial Life, adopted by the SC in May 1997.
Data and details
- Date of split verdict: 23 September 2026. Bench: two judges (Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma).
- Committee arithmetic, in the article's words: the PM and the Cabinet Minister he picks form two-thirds of the Committee, so the Opposition leader's presence is "merely ornamental".
- Statutory immunity: the author says the Act gives the CEC/ECs lifelong immunity for acts and words while in office.
- Ambedkar's speech of 28 October 1951, quoted by Justice Datta:
- It warned of government servants influencing elections for the party feeding them.
- It cited Dr. Shyama Prasad Mukherjee's charge, made at the inaugural session of the Bhartiya Jan Sangh, that government servants were helping Congress.
- It said that if parliamentary democracy failed, the result would be rebellion, anarchy and Communism.
- Conflict-of-interest allegation: Justice Sharma's son has served as an empanelled standing counsel for the ECI before the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The article says the judge did not disclose this at any point. Petitions have been filed seeking recall and nullification of his referral order.
- Opposition parties and others, including the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), question the 2023 law and the Commission's decisions. Protests are mounting across the country, with calls for CEC Gyanesh Kumar's resignation.
- Historical examples cited of political and moral remedies beyond the courts:
- TADA was allowed to lapse.
- POTA was repealed by the Centre, though both had earlier received Court endorsement.
- The Emergency (1975-77) was upheld in ADM Jabalpur (1976), but voters later removed Mrs. Gandhi's regime.
- The farm laws were repealed by Parliament in 2021 after massive protests.
- Notably absent: the Bench did not decide the validity of the Act. The author says the Court "failed to take up the issue in time" and calls the referral an "institutional confession" of that failure.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI. Art. 324(2) makes the appointment of the CEC and ECs "subject to" a law made by Parliament.
- For seven decades there was no such law, so the executive appointed them. In Baranwal the Court filled the gap with an interim committee, and Parliament then legislated in 2023.
- The constitutional question is whether a statute can dilute a Constitution Bench's safeguard for institutional independence. Baranwal held that selecting "impartial umpires" through an executive-dominated committee is a vice.
- The case also shows how procedural choices at the SC (reference to a larger Bench, delay, recusal and disclosure) affect constitutional accountability.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); separation of powers; Supreme Court (Constitution Bench, Art. 145(3)); judicial conduct and ethics
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI) and the CEC/EC appointment framework
- What it is:
- a constitutional body under Art. 324 that superintends and conducts elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- set up on 25 January 1950 (textbook fact). Art. 324(2) empowers Parliament to legislate on ECI appointments, but for over seven decades no such law existed and appointments followed the advice of the Union executive.
Additional context
- The pleas challenge Section 7 of the 2023 Act. Petitioners say the committee gives the executive a two-to-one majority and undermines ECI independence.
- One judge said the issue must be authoritatively decided by a Constitution Bench under Art. 145(3), which requires a minimum of five judges for substantial questions of constitutional law.
- The two judges agreed to place the papers before the CJI to constitute a Constitution Bench. The petitions include those filed by the Association for Democratic Reforms and Jaya Thakur.
- In 2024 the SC declined to stay the 2023 Act in Dr. Jaya Thakur v. Union of India, so the existing ECI structure continued.
- The Goswami Committee (1990) is among the bodies that have suggested measures to secure ECI independence, and the Law Commission's 255th Report (2015) was relied on by petitioners seeking a more independent appointment system.
- The Act allows the Selection Committee to function despite vacancies.
Mains dimensions
- Institutional independence: Executive predominance in the selection committee (PM + his nominee against one LoP) defeats the Baranwal principle of a neutral body choosing neutral umpires. The author's remedy is to repeal the Act and enact a fresh law in which a neutral body selects the CEC and ECs.
- Separation of powers: Can Parliament neutralise a Constitution Bench's interim directions by a statute that merely changes the committee composition?
- Judicial delay as a constitutional problem: The statute survives for longer while elections go on under a Commission whose legitimacy is contested. Refusing a stay in 2024 and referring the case in 2026 both prolong this.
- Judicial propriety: The alleged non-disclosure of a family link to ECI counsel invites the Bangalore Principles, the 1997 Restatement and the Hurra logic. This is a GS4-style integrity issue as well as a polity one.
- Beyond the courts: TADA/POTA, the Emergency and the farm laws show that sustained political and popular pressure can complete what litigation cannot. The author links this to the SIR controversy, saying it should also be revisited. Note that this is an advocate-author's view.
- Counter-view to weigh: Justice Sharma's reference is a legitimate use of Art. 145(3) for a major constitutional question. An accused-of-bias narrative should not pre-judge a bench not yet constituted.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The 2023 law on appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners has been questioned for diluting the *Anoop Baranwal* safeguard. Examine the constitutional issues involved and suggest reforms to secure the independence of the Election Commission."
Related topics
- Art. 324-329 (electoral machinery); the ECI's role in the revision of electoral rolls (SIR)
- Basic structure and free and fair elections (Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain)
- Constitution Benches, references and curative petitions
- Independence of other statutory selection panels (CVC, CBI Director)
- Judicial accountability and recusal norms
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 15 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs