Stop illegal detentions, orders SC as crackdown continues in Delhi
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 12 October 2026
Summary
- On 10 Oct 2026 Delhi was placed under a near-total clampdown to stop youth-led protests (called by the Cockroach Janta Party, CJP, and student/youth bodies) demanding the resignation of CEC Gyanesh Kumar over alleged electoral irregularities and the SIR of rolls. Mass detentions followed. Senior lawyers likened the situation to the 1975 Emergency.
- On Sunday, 11 Oct, a Special Bench of Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana held an "extraordinary" hearing. It directed the Union government and Delhi Police to stop illegal detentions, allow free movement of people and traffic, and let Metro and rail run, all "subject to law and public order".
- Protests, detentions, allegations of police excess, and political fallout continued on 11 Oct in Delhi and Mumbai.
Key facts for Prelims
- BNSS Section 163 replaced CrPC Section 144; orders are issued by Executive Magistrates (replacement and magistrate power).
- Art. 19(1)(b) is the assembly right; Art. 19(3) supplies its restriction grounds (assembly right and its restriction grounds).
- Judgments cited in the articles:
- Himat Lal K. Shah v. Commissioner of Police, Ahmedabad (Constitution Bench, 1972 per the article): no arbitrary police powers or blanket bans on meetings; only reasonable restrictions for public order.
- Anita Thakur v. Govt of J&K (2016): peaceful demonstration to air grievances is a fundamental right.
- Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. UoI (2018).
- Ramlila Maidan case (2012).
- Jantar Mantar is the designated protest site in New Delhi (per the articles).
- Section 163 BNSS order standard: ordinarily valid up to two months.
- Mahatma Gandhi's 18 March 1922 statement came in a sedition trial before Ahmedabad Sessions Judge C.N. Broomfield. He was tried for three articles in Young India, and he and editor Shankarlal Banker pleaded guilty and got six months. Gandhi held that non-violence implies voluntary submission to the penalty for non-cooperation.
- The Supreme Court acted via a Special Bench and issued notices on a contempt petition. It issued notices to the Union Home Secretary Govind Mohan, Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and DMRC chairperson D. Thara.
- Ethics angle: the Delhi Police rejected the allegation about Dipke's grandmother's funeral and said it offered travel help (see 3b).
Data and details
- Scale: Delhi Police registered 20 FIRs over the CJP-called protest. More than 7,000 people were detained, and over 30,000 police personnel were deployed to stop protesters reaching Jantar Mantar. Lawyers described "thousands" swept up.
- There was no official Delhi Police figure for Sunday's (11 Oct) detentions.
- SC order specifics:
- Review barricades on public roads.
- Keep Internet connectivity undisturbed.
- Lift Section 163 orders in and around the Supreme Court and other courts.
- No detentions except by law outside the four-km prohibitory zone in central Delhi (which includes Jantar Mantar).
- Journalists and lawyers to be allowed to perform professional duties.
- The board announcing the prohibitory order outside the Court was ordered removed immediately.
- The Court did not comment on the legality of the prohibitory orders.
- Contempt petition (by advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi): alleged violation of the 9 Oct order, which barred any "outright prohibition" on Metro trains and public transport on Saturday.
- Submissions: Shadan Farasat (dragged into a police van, held for hours) said the city was "one step away from a police state". Menaka Guruswamy asked how many were detained on 10 Oct, asked whether Art. 19 had been suspended, and noted police officers without name tags. Gopal Sankaranarayanan said the Emergency "reached our doorsteps".
- Sunday, 11 Oct, on the ground:
- Around a dozen journalists detained, despite the SC's directives. At least seven, including from the Hindustan Times, were detained near Ramakrishna Ashram Marg Metro station.
- Three journalists of The Indian Express (Hindi) were released after about 45 minutes at Chhatrasal Stadium, nearly 12 km away.
- Peek TV's Vedanta Agarwal and Sara Khan were allegedly dragged.
- Journalist Shyam Meera Singh was manhandled.
- A police official attributed the journalist detentions to "confusion" from proximity to protesters. Police said protesters were "unwilling to cooperate", so force was needed to lift them.
- Rajya Sabha MP John Brittas (CPI-M) and AISA president Neha Bora were detained. Brittas was injured and admitted to RML Hospital.
- About 60–70 protesters marched from Rajiv Chowk Gate 1 to Palika Bazaar Gate 6 shouting "vote chor, gaddi chhod". Around 350 people from RWPI, Disha, Naujawan Bharat Sabha and Stree Mukti League rallied from Connaught Place and were picked up near Pind Balluchi square.
- SFI women activists were detained after 6 p.m. during a "Tiranga Yatra".
- KYS protested outside the Supreme Court and on boats on the Yamuna, calling it the "new Jantar Mantar".
- Student detainees were held in buses with cage-like structures, which is uncommon for student protesters in Delhi.
- Security arrangements were relaxed after the SC hearing but expected to return Monday for the Congress march to the SC. Mobile Internet was restored. Footfall in Connaught Place stayed low despite the festive season.
- Allegations:
- DYFI (president A.A. Rahim) will move the SC over "illegal detention" and "custodial torture". It alleged detainees were taken to a location without CCTV, segregated by gender and assaulted. It also alleged no arrest memos, no informing of family, no production before a magistrate and no medical examination.
- CPI(M) general secretary M.A. Baby said police turned Delhi into a "war zone". SFI president Adarsh M. Saji and DYFI's Jaick C. Thomas were allegedly assaulted inside police vehicles.
- CJP leaders Ashutosh Ranka and Saurav Das said they were "kidnapped" from a flight on Saturday, denied lawyers, and feared their seized phones could be hacked or evidence planted.
- CJP leaders Abhijeet Dipke, Das and Ranka were released by a Special Executive Magistrate's order on a "no breach of peace for a year" condition. Dipke said he signed no bond forbidding protest. They gave Delhi Police 24 hours to give a Jantar Mantar date.
- Dipke's grandmother died. Police (DCP Neha Yadav) released a 1.45-minute video of officers offering travel help. Dipke said he was pressed to sign arrest papers at 3.30 a.m. while denied his phone and lawyers.
- Vigilante assault: four men attacked a male protester and a woman in central Delhi, caught on video. Police arrested all four on Sunday morning (Raman Saini, 50; Vivekanand alias Vivek, 32; Kapil Kumar, 27; Ravinder Singh alias Govind, 35). Hindu Raksha Dal president Pinky Chaudhary claimed them as members and vowed to protect them. Police were criticised for walking the attackers away rather than restraining them.
- Bangla Sahib: DSGMC (president Harmeet Singh Kalka) complained to the New Delhi DCP against AAP leaders, including Arvind Kejriwal. It alleged political protest inside the gurdwara premises and "distorted" videos.
- Mumbai: Several people were detained near Shivaji Park, Dadar, with entry blocked at Gate No. 6 and other entrances. Student leader Rohit Dhale said he was taken from his Parel residence. Manya Yadav (name changed), 24, was detained around 5.50 p.m. and released around 7 p.m. Protester Shafqat Khan alleged excessive force. Meera Shah of Mulund said she joined because of the Delhi police action.
- Editorial claims (opinion, not established fact):
- The Hindu ("Rights and wrongs") says no one was held accountable for the July 2026 police excesses on youth protesters, and that the Court's "piecemeal orders" have had little restraining effect.
- M.A. Baby's piece says Section 163 orders were imposed across New Delhi district on 2 Oct 2026 and that, since the 20 July NEET protests, barricading at Jantar Mantar has increased. He says applications must reportedly be filed 10 days in advance. He recalls Boat Club as the older protest site, and says that since COVID-19 almost no rally permissions have been granted. Delhi's old rally routes ran Mandi House to Jantar Mantar and Ramlila Maidan to Parliament Street.
- The same piece cites Bengaluru (Town Hall to Freedom Park; Karnataka HC 2022 confinement; park closed Dec 2025 for "redevelopment"), Hyderabad (Dharna Chowk), and the early-2024 farmers' march (barricades, barbed wire, tear gas, trenches). It also cites the Mahapadav of Nov 2023.
- The same piece claims the 2023 Act on appointing Election Commissioners removed the Chief Justice of India from the selection panel and gave the executive control. It says the Act gives Election Commissioners lifelong protection from civil and criminal prosecution. It also claims SIR risks deleting short-term migrants, illiterate voters and married women from the rolls (editorial claims, not established fact).
Static–dynamic linkage
- Art. 19(1)(b) guarantees the right to assemble peaceably and without arms. The State can restrict it only by "reasonable restrictions" in the interests of public order or the sovereignty and integrity of India (Art. 19(3)). It cannot impose arbitrary or blanket bans.
- The Court's repeated "subject to law and public order" rider is the proportionality balance: protect liberty, but leave room for regulation.
- Preventive tools (prohibitory orders, preventive detention) must still pass Art. 14/19/21 tests. Detentions must follow procedure (arrest memos, informing family, producing the detainee before a magistrate, medical examination), as DYFI alleged was not done.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 Polity: fundamental rights (Art. 19(1)(a), 19(1)(b), 19(3), 21, 22); role of the judiciary; executive/police powers; GS2 Governance: accountability of law enforcement.
Background primer
Section 163, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023
- What it is:
- It replaces Section 144 CrPC, 1973, and lets Executive Magistrates (DM/SDM) issue written orders to prevent urgent threats to public order and safety.
- Why it matters:
- pre-emptive power to prevent riots and breaches of peace. Judicial guardrails are Babulal Parate (1961), Ramlila Maidan (2012) and MKSS (2018) (necessity, proportionality, safeguards against arbitrary restriction).
Right to peaceful assembly and protest (Art. 19(1)(b))
- What it is:
- Art. 19(1)(b) gives the right to assemble peacefully and without arms, the constitutional basis of peaceful demonstrations. Art. 19(3) permits restrictions in the interests of sovereignty and integrity of India or public order.
- Why it matters:
- dissent is part of democracy, but regulation (time, place, manner) must balance the rights of protesters, residents and commuters.
Preventive detention / pre-emptive detention in protests
Additional context
- Later reporting (Drishti IAS) says Delhi Police de-notified Jantar Mantar as a designated protest site after an MHA committee's recommendation, naming Ramlila Ground, Burari Ground and CBD Ground (East Delhi) as alternatives. This is a post-12 Oct development and not in today's articles.
- Drishti's analysis of this episode flags that Section 163 use must be proportionate and evidence-based to protect the right to protest under Art. 19.
Mains dimensions
- Constitutional balance: The Court's "subject to law and public order" rider upholds Art. 19/21 (free movement, access to courts, Internet) while preserving reasonable restrictions. It stopped short of ruling on the legality of Section 163 orders. This leaves the core question (blanket versus targeted orders) for later hearings.
- Access to justice: Prohibitory orders around the Supreme Court and other courts blocked litigants from reaching lawyers. The Court ordered those orders lifted and the notice board removed.
- Police accountability: Allegations include officers without name tags, vans without CCTV, no arrest memos, no medical exams, and cage-like buses. The July 2026 episode reportedly led to no accountability. The DKBasu/ procedural-safeguard framework and independent oversight are the relevant reform areas.
- Press freedom: About a dozen journalists were detained despite the Court's directions, and the police explanation was "confusion". This tests the Art. 19(1)(a) press-freedom dimension and the Court's earlier direction to let journalists work.
- Federal/national pattern: Protest spaces have been shifted, confined and restricted from Delhi to Bengaluru and Hyderabad (editorial claim), with repeated Section 163 use and Internet shutdowns. The Jantar Mantar "designated site" model from MKSS (2018) is hollowed out if the site is permanently barricaded.
- Non-state violence: The vigilante assault and the Bangla Sahib counter-complaint show how protests get entangled with religious sentiment and private violence. The state must apply even-handed law and order.
- Historical-moral frame: Gandhi's 1922 statement (disaffection is permissible short of incitement to violence; accept penalty) and the Court's post-1950 case law link civil disobedience to constitutional protest.
- Way forward: specific, time-bound and reasoned Section 163 orders; published protest-regulation guidelines; designated sites that actually remain accessible; independent inquiry into custodial allegations; judicial review of blanket bans.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The right to peaceful assembly is not absolute, yet blanket prohibitory orders and mass preventive detentions strike at its core. In light of recent judicial pronouncements, discuss how courts and the executive should balance public order with the right to protest in a democracy."
Related topics
- Art. 19(1)(a)-(b), 19(2)-(3); reasonable restrictions and proportionality
- Art. 21 and Art. 22 (preventive detention, arrest safeguards), D.K. Basu guidelines
- BNSS vs CrPC: key changes; unlawful assembly under BNS
- Freedom of the press; Internet shutdowns (Anuradha Bhasin)
- Police reforms; custodial violence
- SIR, ECI and CEC removal (see the companion note on the Election Commission: The need to preserve the shine of Indian elections)
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 12 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs