The need to preserve the shine of Indian elections
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 12 October 2026
Summary
- The author, a former DG of the ECI, argues that the protests around the ECI are a symptom of a wider erosion of trust in Indian elections. Chronic allegations of partisan conduct, a vulnerable voter database, money power, post-poll defections and contested appointments have turned the issue from logistics to credibility. He calls for a collective, cross-party effort to rebuild trust.
- Meanwhile the political track escalated:
- Rahul Gandhi called citizens to a Congress/INDIA bloc march to the Supreme Court on Monday (12 Oct).
- CJI Surya Kant declined a meeting.
- A new Deputy Election Commissioner was appointed amid questions over the ECI's internal work allocation.
- Editorials in the same issue debated the CEC's exit and the wider institutional crisis.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the ECI (Art. 324(1)).
- Art. 324(5): CEC removal like a SC judge (removal standard); other ECs only on the CEC's recommendation (EC removal).
- CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023 (Act 49 of 2023): replaced the Election Commission (Conditions of Service of Election Commissioners and Transaction of Business) Act, 1991 (repeal of the 1991 Act). Tenure of six years or age 65; no re-appointment.
- Selection Committee: PM, LoP in Lok Sabha, Union Cabinet Minister nominated by PM; Search Committee headed by the Law Minister.
- Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2 March 2023): interim committee of the PM, LoP and CJI.
- Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1978): plenary power under Art. 324.
- T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995): upheld the multi-member Commission; the CEC is "first among equals" (Seshan ruling).
- Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975): free and fair elections are part of the basic structure (basic structure ruling).
- Anti-defection law: Tenth Schedule; the editorial says its exceptions encourage bulk transfers of legislators.
- Form 7 is the application to object to the inclusion of a name on the electoral roll / seek its deletion.
- ECI institutions named: Nirvachan Sadan (ECI HQ); India International Institute of Democracy and Election Management (IIIDEM), set up to train election managers.
- First CEC: Sukumar Sen conducted the first elections in independent India (the editorial dates this to 1951).
- Statistical idea (Science page): Type I error = rejecting a true null hypothesis (false positive); Type II error = failing to reject a false null (false negative). Applied to SIR as in the article: wrongly deleting an eligible voter versus wrongly retaining an ineligible one. Suggested remedies: more information to all stakeholders (data from the new Census, opportunities to challenge decisions, independent audits).
Data and details
- 2024 national elections: about 98 crore electors; over a million polling booths.
- Economic Survey 2026: unconditional cash transfers strain States by ₹1.7 lakh crore (cited in the editorial).
- 75 years of elections; the 1993 shift to a three-member Commission is cited as precedent for institutional reform.
- Over 13 crore names excluded from draft rolls in SIR (edit by Mehbooba Mufti, J&K PDP president).
- The editorial notes the SIR began a year ago (ECI order dated 24 June 2025, signed by then-DEC Sanjay Kumar). The 2023 appointment law is "still under study" by the Supreme Court.
- ECI internal friction (news report):
- Prakash Rajpurohit (IAS 2010, Rajasthan cadre) was appointed Deputy Election Commissioner. The Appointments Committee of the Cabinet cleared it late Saturday (10 Oct), per DoPT. His tenure runs up to 8 April 2030.
- He fills the vacancy from the premature repatriation of Sanjay Kumar (DEC Aug 2024 to Aug 2026), who handled Electoral Rolls and IT.
- Election Commissioners S.S. Sandhu and Vivek Joshi wrote to the Cabinet Secretary that IT head Seema Khanna's files not being routed via Sanjay Kumar was a violation. Dr Khanna joined the ECI in 2025 on deputation from the NIC and oversees roll-management systems.
- Her files had been routed via the DEC until she was promoted to Level 15 (Additional Secretary equivalent), above his Level 14 (Joint Secretary). Senior DEC Manish Garg then issued an order that her files go straight to the ECs, but it was never implemented. Files then went via Garg himself as link officer.
- Political track:
- Rahul Gandhi's demands in the memorandum to CJI Surya Kant: halt SIR, sack CEC Gyanesh Kumar, remove EVMs from the electoral process.
- The CJI's office declined a Monday meeting "with reasons". Sources said the matters are sub judice and the Court cannot intervene in the administrative side of governance. Fundamental-rights questions can be raised on the judicial side. The CJI expressed no view on the march.
- The Court has listed petitions on the CEC protest and the 10 Oct clampdown for 12 Oct.
- Mallikarjun Kharge called it an "undeclared emergency". K.C. Venugopal is coordinating INDIA bloc parties.
- Congress had protested in the capital for four days from 6 Oct. It was formally not part of Saturday/Sunday's CJP-led protests, though INDIA bloc leaders such as Mamata Banerjee and Pinarayi Vijayan took part and were detained.
- Karnataka CM D.K. Shivakumar and Congress legislators were due in Delhi on Monday. Asked about the CJP, he said Congress was taking its own course of action.
- Delhi PCC chief Devender Yadav announced a voter-awareness campaign to help voters verify roll entries and file complaints.
- Editorial comparators (opinion):
- Ashok Lavasa dissented on clean chits to Modi and Shah on 2019 Model Code complaints, then left the ECI early for a lead bank position.
- Sandhu and Joshi have reportedly recorded objections under CEC Kumar.
- The editorial recalls T.N. Seshan and the judiciary holding Indira Gandhi accountable. It claims that a CEC exit alone would not fix the system. It says Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan was forced out by public pressure.
- Allegations of selective raids and investigations of Opposition leaders around elections, and of living voters shown as dead being produced before courts without tangible action, are the editorialist's claims.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The Constitution makes the ECI an independent body for conducting elections. Its independence depends on secure tenure (especially for the CEC), a fair appointment process, financial and functional autonomy, and, above all, public trust.
- "Free and fair elections" are part of the basic structure. A credible roll (franchise under Art. 326), neutral conduct of the Model Code, financial regulation and a clean candidate pool are the pillars. The editorial argues each is under stress.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 Polity: Election Commission (Art. 324); Representation of the People Acts 1950/1951; electoral reforms; Tenth Schedule; separation of powers; GS2 Governance: institutional credibility.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- A permanent, independent constitutional body established on 25 Jan 1950 under Art. 324, with superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Why it matters:
- insulate the conduct of elections from executive control. In Mohinder Singh Gill (1978), the Court recognised the ECI's plenary Art. 324 powers to act where the law is silent, so long as no statutory provision is violated.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- A focused, time-bound ECI exercise to update and verify electoral rolls, with fresh house-to-house verification by Booth Level Officers. It differs from Summary Revision (annual, no door-to-door) and Special Revision.
Additional context
- The SC's SIR verdict (27 May 2026) applied a proportionality test (legitimate purpose, non-excessive means, least restrictive option). It held that the ECI may examine citizenship for roll inclusion without conclusively deciding citizenship. It also said the presumption of validity of an existing roll entry is subject to verification and is not absolute.
- Safeguards on deletion: Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 requires notice, inquiry and a hearing before a name is deleted. The Court also directed that persons deleted on citizenship grounds be referred to the competent authority within four weeks, with voting rights restored if they are found to be citizens.
- Independence of the Commission: Unlike the CEC, other ECs lack the same constitutional protection from removal (Art. 324(5)), which critics say creates incentives to align with the government.
Mains dimensions
- From logistics to legitimacy: India's pride in election delivery (98 crore electors, IIIDEM as a training hub) now coexists with a trust deficit. Results were once received with "stoic calm"; now there is aggressive rejection and allegations of partisan conduct.
- Voter-database risk: The edit argues that manipulating rolls through undue enfranchisement or disenfranchisement is a larger-scale threat than old booth capturing. SIR deletions (13 crore from drafts per the Mehbooba edit) feed this. Type I/II framing suggests: audits, public data, and a real right to challenge.
- Money power: Official expenditure reports are the "tip of the iceberg". Cash transfers marketed as welfare cost States ₹1.7 lakh crore, per the Economic Survey 2026. This distorts the level playing field and public finance. The ECI and SC have both voiced concern.
- Post-poll subversion: The Tenth Schedule's exceptions have enabled bulk defections. There is no recall. The Speaker's and ECI's follow-up decisions (recognition, symbols) are also contested.
- Institutional design: The 2023 Act removed the CJI from the selection panel (government majority). Other ECs lack the CEC's removal protection. Internal hierarchy disputes (Khanna/DEC file routing) hint at governance friction in the ECI's IT/roll function.
- Judicial role: The SC upheld the SIR's legal basis on 27 May 2026, but the editorials accuse it of normalising the process, and the CJI declined a meeting on sub judice grounds, which is a separation-of-powers point.
- Way forward (author): an all-party, apolitical sit-down for systemic safeguards; better regulation of political financing and freebies; shielding the process from criminalisation; countering AI-abetted fake narratives; rebuilding trust. Complementary ideas: restoring the CJI to the selection panel, equal protection for all ECs, independent audits, a data-driven SIR with grievance redress.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The credibility of the Election Commission is as important as its constitutional independence. In light of recent controversies over electoral roll revision and the appointment process, examine the reforms needed to restore public trust in India's electoral system."
Related topics
- Art. 324-329; RP Act 1950 (rolls) and RP Act 1951; Anoop Baranwal and the 2023 Act
- Removal procedure under Art. 124(4) and the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968
- Tenth Schedule: defection, Speaker's role, exceptions
- Electoral bonds, political funding, Model Code of Conduct, freebies debate
- EVM/VVPAT issues; Lal Babu Hussein presumption of citizenship
- Right to protest and the 10 Oct Delhi clampdown
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 12 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs