19,000 Bengal voters to miss bypolls over backlog in tribunals
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 6 October 2026
Summary
- Around 19,000 voters in West Bengal's Nandigram and Rejinagar constituencies, where bypolls were due on Tuesday (6 October), are among 38.31 lakh whose appeals before the SIR Appellate Tribunals are pending, so they stay off the rolls.
- The tribunals have cleared only about 3% of appeals. Three of the 19 tribunals are vacant after retired judges quit, and the EC's proposal to expand to 42 tribunals is stuck.
- Booth Level Officers in the State asked the Chief Electoral Officer for security during the EC's door-to-door re-enrolment drive. The EC also replaced the Nandigram police station's inspector-in-charge before the bypoll after Opposition complaints.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 326 guarantees adult suffrage for Lok Sabha and Assembly elections. The right to be registered and to vote is given effect through the RP Act, 1950. Electoral rolls are prepared by Electoral Registration Officers under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
- Supplementary electoral rolls update the roll after revisions; Form 6 is used for inclusion.
- Booth Level Officers (BLOs) are field officials who verify and update the roll door to door; the Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) heads election administration in a State.
- By-election: held to fill a vacancy in a legislature; the EC conducts it under Art. 324.
- The SC's 10 March 2026 order directed a separate appellate body for SIR exclusions in West Bengal.
- ECINET is the EC's digital platform; SIR appeals can be filed online through it or physically at the offices of District Magistrates, SDMs or SDOs.
Data and details
- About 19,000 voters in Nandigram and Rejinagar are among 38.31 lakh disenfranchised pending appeals.
- Rejinagar: 12,452 appeals, 4 included. Nandigram: 6,443 appeals, 89 included. No one excluded so far in either place.
- Cleared so far: 1.26 lakh of 38.31 lakh appeals, about 3%.
- Calcutta High Court observed in July that, at current speed, clearing would take 21 years.
- 19 tribunals set up by the EC in March, but only 16 functional. Justices T.S. Sivagnanam, Ranjit Bag and Indrajit Chatterjee quit citing functional issues; their positions are vacant.
- EC's proposal to raise tribunals from 19 to 42 has not moved. The SC was to hear it on Monday but it was not listed.
- The EC's door-to-door Form 6 re-enrolment drive (announced last week) will not apply to those with pending appeals.
- Origin: roughly 60 lakh "doubtful and pending" cases adjudicated by judicial officers (drawn from a list sent by the Calcutta High Court at the SC's direction). The SC on 10 March directed a separate appellate body.
- EC directed on 2 October that BLOs visit houses across the country to enrol new voters and re-enrol deleted eligible voters.
- Votekarmi O BLO Aikya Mancha wrote to CEO Neelam Meena for security in "sensitive" areas, especially eight districts or parts: North 24 Parganas, South 24 Parganas, Howrah, Malda, Murshidabad, Uttar Dinajpur, parts of Hooghly and Kolkata. The BLOs say they had no role in mass deletions yet could be targets of anger. The association says then CM Mamata Banerjee's role in taking them to court pulled them into adjudication and the tribunal.
- Over 91 lakh names were deleted in West Bengal's SIR; around 27 lakh later appealed (the article's figure; the 38.31 lakh above is the tribunal backlog figure as given in the lead report).
- On Monday the EC replaced Nandigram's inspector-in-charge (Ajay Kumar Mishra, replaced by Debashis Sarkar) after Opposition parties alleged closeness to the BJP. A major State police reshuffle preceded the poll to ensure a "transparent election process".
- Nandigram's significance: the 2007–08 anti-land-grab agitation (Mamata Banerjee's rise); Suvendu Adhikari defeated her there in 2021.
- Not available: the article does not say that anyone has been excluded in the two bypoll constituencies, nor when the vacant tribunal posts will be filled.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Under the RP Act 1950, a person is entitled to be registered in the roll if qualified (adult citizen, ordinarily resident). The Registration of Electors Rules provide claims, objections and appeals. Normally an appeal lies from a registration officer's decision to an officer designated by the EC.
- The SIR in West Bengal changed this scheme. Because judicial officers adjudicated "logical discrepancy" cases, the SC ordered a separate appellate body of retired judges. The right of appeal is only as meaningful as the speed and capacity of the forum, so a 21-year projected clearance time means a de facto denial of vote.
- The theme is "access to justice and election integrity": an ad hoc remedy created by judicial direction that cannot meet its own caseload.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Electoral rolls and right to vote (Art. 326, RP Act 1950); quasi-judicial bodies and tribunals; role of Election Commission, free and fair elections; GS2 — Governance: grievance redressal and capacity of institutions.
Background primer
SIR Appellate Tribunals (West Bengal)
- What it is:
- Temporary appellate bodies for appeals against orders of designated judicial officers deciding SIR claims and objections (inclusion or exclusion in the roll).
- Founded:
- On 10 March 2026 the Supreme Court directed the Chief Justice of the Calcutta High Court to constitute special appellate tribunals. The EC notified the appellate mechanism on 20 March 2026. The trigger: judicial officers deployed in the SIR had by then handled 10.16 lakh objections and claims. The Court also said officers' decisions cannot be examined by administrative officers of the EC.
- Members:
- Led by a retired Chief Justice and may include other retired judges, including judges from High Courts in other States. Of the 19 tribunals, one was headed by former Chief Justice T.S. Sivagnanam and the others by former High Court judges. The EC must comply with their decisions and bear all costs.
- Mandate:
- Appeals can be filed after supplementary rolls are published, online via ECINET or at the offices of the District Magistrates, SDMs or SDOs. The tribunals cease to exist once all appeals are disposed of.
- Why it matters:
- Providing an independent remedy so that exclusion decisions are reviewed by judicial authority and not by the EC's own administrative officers.
Statutory appeal under the Registration of Electors Rules
Additional context
- Voting rights of appellants: The SC ordered that persons whose appeals are allowed before 21 or 27 April must be allowed to vote in the first or second phase, but mere pendency of appeal gives no right to vote. The Electoral Registration Officer must update the rolls, including through supplementary lists, once a tribunal allows an appeal.
- Scale earlier in the year: More than 34 lakh appeals had been filed in West Bengal as of 11 April. The SC said it would not press tribunal members to decide within a fixed time, as it could affect fair judgment.
- "Logical discrepancy": Justice Bagchi observed that this category was unique to the West Bengal SIR.
Mains dimensions
- Remedy without capacity: A 21-year clearance estimate, 3% disposal, 16 of 19 tribunals functioning, and stalled expansion make the appeals system a bottleneck. A right without an effective remedy is a de facto denial.
- Electoral integrity: Pending appeals mean voters miss successive elections (here, the Nandigram and Rejinagar bypolls). Judicial intervention was cautious: the SC did not give voting rights to pending appellants, balancing roll purity against inclusion.
- Judicial overreach vs. enabler: The tribunals emerged from the Court's supervision of SIR. The Court acted as "enabler" but the EC controls the administrative follow-up (funding, notifying, expansion). Accountability is thus diffused.
- Field administration risk: BLO safety, politicised policing (the Nandigram inspector swap) and perceptions of partisanship strain the neutrality of the machinery.
- Way forward: Fill vacancies, increase benches (19 to 42), use ECINET to batch similar cases, set time-bound targets (the Court avoided strict deadlines), publish reasons for deletion, and consider rolling provisional voting rights with safeguards.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 10 marks:** "Appeal mechanisms in electoral roll revision are only as good as the capacity of the forums that hear them. Discuss with reference to the SIR appellate tribunals in West Bengal."
Related topics
- Arts. 324 and 326; RP Act 1950 (rolls) and RP Act 1951 (conduct, disqualification)
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 (claims, objections, appeals)
- Tribunals in India (Art. 323A/B) and pendency issues
- By-elections and Model Code of Conduct; role of BLOs, EROs and CEOs
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 6 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs