BrainParrot

SC distances itself from tweaks to Form 6

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 6 October 2026

Summary

  • A three-judge Supreme Court Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant issued notice on two petitions seeking suspension of CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The petitions allege bias, administrative unilateralism and procedural overreach during the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
  • The Bench said orally that it had not made any modifications to Form 6. This shifted scrutiny onto the Election Commission (EC).
  • The Court refused to suspend the CEC at the interim stage. It said it would first examine the records and hear the EC.
  • The Opposition (Congress, CPI, RJD) demanded the CEC's removal. The BJP defended the process, and civil-society figures filed a "people's impeachment" chargesheet.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Election Commission, electoral rolls, judicial review

Key facts for Prelims

  • Form 6 is a statutory form in the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, used by first-time voters or those shifting constituencies; Form 6A is for overseas electors.
  • Removal of the CEC: Art. 324(5) (same manner and grounds as an SC judge: proved misbehaviour or incapacity). Other ECs can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation.
  • The Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: Section 16 bars courts from entertaining civil or criminal proceedings against a person who "is or was" CEC/EC (as read out in court). Petitioner's counsel also cited Section 18 of the 2023 Act.
  • The SIR changes at issue: a supplementary declaration on linkage to the previous SIR rolls was added to Form 6, and a reply was made a prerequisite for submission.
  • The Bench: CJI Surya Kant with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana (per the Court-related reports).
  • Appellate tribunals for SIR exclusions exist in West Bengal (see the linked Bengal note); the Court tagged the two petitions together.
  • "INDIA bloc" expansion: Indian National Developmental, Inclusive Alliance.

Data and details

  • Two petitions: one by Rakesh Singh (argued by Vikas Singh), the other by Shailendra Mani Tripathi (argued by Menaka Guruswamy). Both seek the CEC's suspension.
  • Vikas Singh sought suspension or divestment of authority, and said the "country will burn". In the alternative, he asked that the Commission decide unanimously while the case is pending. He argued that Section 18 of the 2023 Act and the Constitution give the CEC no individual title: he chairs the Commission and is not the Commission itself. He added that the statute has "exalted" the CEC above a Supreme Court judge.
  • Justice Bagchi: who will conduct elections if the CEC is suspended? Petitions must be filed with the working of the Constitution in mind. The Court cannot "put the cart before the horse" and presume all EC orders were unilateral.
  • CJI Kant: the Court will act on authenticated information and examine records, and wants the EC's response first.
  • Guruswamy: 30% of the electorate in Delhi and 25% in West Bengal were deleted in the SIR. Lakhs of appeals are pending before appellate tribunals in Bengal. Voters have already been excluded from one election cycle, with another about to start. Form 6 got two new conditions in Delhi, circulated to the field, although under the Schedule Form 6 cannot be modified.
  • The new Form 6 conditions: applicants must declare whether they, their parents or their grandparents were on the previous SIR rolls; a reply is mandatory.
  • The Court tagged both petitions and may list the case "next week" to hear the Commission.
  • Rahul Gandhi shared the EC's 26 September statement. It said the Form 6 declaration for SIR "has been upheld" by the SC, and that the Rules 1960 forms apply outside the SIR period. He called the change illegal and unilateral.
  • EC's X rebuttal: the 24 June 2025 Bihar SIR order was issued with unanimous approval and upheld in the SC's 27 May judgment. The 26 September press note said the SIR declaration was upheld.
  • Kharge: three "non-negotiable" demands: the CEC's resignation, annulling the SIR, and elections on ballot papers. INDIA bloc and Congress workers are on the streets.
  • Jairam Ramesh cited three grounds: the "ad-hoc, illegal and slip-shod" manner of the SIR; criticism from sitting and retired SC judges; and the vast, indiscriminate deletions without due process. He accused the CEC of betraying the Constitution at the behest of the PM and Home Minister.
  • CPI's D. Raja: the CEC invoked the SC's name to justify the changes and ignored objections of the other ECs. He asked who changed Form 6 and who authorised the SC reference.
  • BJP's Sambit Patra: the CJI did not call Form 6 illegal and the SC had upheld the declaration. A notice is a normal democratic and judicial process. He made a Rafale comparison, saying Rahul had to file an affidavit and apologise. He called the reported dissent notes of the two other ECs a "healthy sign" and said no atmosphere of fear exists.
  • Tejashwi Yadav (RJD): the CEC is a BJP "puppet". He cited mass removal of names and living voters being marked dead, and alleged ₹10,000 transfers to women up to polling day in breach of the Model Code, with ₹50,000 crore "siphoned" from the Bihar treasury. He also claimed the CEC cut retention of voting records from a year to 45 days. These are allegations, not findings. An Aakrosh March in Bihar was planned for Wednesday, district sit-ins on Thursday, and a demonstration at Lok Bhavan, Patna.
  • Civil-society "chargesheet": a 14-member delegation (including Najeeb Jung and G.K. Pillai) alleged six instances of "proved misbehaviour" under Art. 324(5). The charges include undermining the EC's collective functioning, unauthorised Form 6 changes, centralising roll functions via ECINET, and presiding over an SIR leading to large-scale disenfranchisement. The delegation was blocked by barricades and emailed the notice. Activist Anjali Bhardwaj said the CEC must resign.
  • Congress campaign "Vote bachao, desh bachao": outreach to 13.3 crore people struck off the rolls, with booth-level agents as "vote rakshaks". Block-level marches run 10–20 October ending at SDM offices. A Parliament-to-EC march is planned for Tuesday and an INDIA bloc rally at Ram Leela Maidan on 1 November. Six "Delhi Chalo" rallies on 25 November end on Constitution Day, 26 November. The party will reach out to the DMK and AAP, as the article describes them.
  • Not in the record: no interim relief or suspension was ordered, and the Court did not call Form 6 illegal. The BJP also stressed this.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The EC's powers over electoral rolls come from the Constitution (Art. 324), but the forms and procedure of registration come from law and delegated legislation. This is the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, made under the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
  • The article stresses that a statutory form can only be changed through the lawful rule-making route, not by unilateral administrative action. The legal question is therefore whether a body with plenary supervisory powers can add conditions to a statutory form by executive order or software change.
  • The second question is institutional. The CEC is the chair of a multi-member body, and the debate is whether he can act unilaterally. Related issues are immunity after leaving office and removal only through the Art. 324(5) route.
  • This is the "constitutional body vs. rule of law" theme. Its yardsticks are the Anoop Baranwal line of cases, the 2023 appointment law, and the limits on "ECI independence".

Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission, Art. 324); Representation of the People Act/Rules; Parliament's role in electoral law; judicial review and separation of powers; GS2 — Governance: transparency and accountability of regulators.

Background primer

Election Commission of India (Art. 324)

What it is:
A permanent constitutional body. Art. 324 gives it superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
Founded:
Established with the Constitution; functions from 25 January 1950 (textbook fact).
Members:
A Chief Election Commissioner and such other Election Commissioners as the President fixes (Art. 324(2)). Under the 2023 Act, appointment is by the President on the recommendation of a selection committee of the PM, a Union Minister and the Leader of Opposition. This replaced the SC-mandated panel (PM, LoP, CJI), which critics say lets the executive dominate selection. Tenure is 6 years or till age 65, whichever is earlier. Decision-making rule (unanimity/majority) under the 2023 Act: not confirmed from a trusted source in this run.
Mandate:
Preparing and revising electoral rolls and conducting elections (Parliament, State Legislatures, President, Vice-President).
Why it matters:
Insulate the conduct of elections from executive influence through security of tenure and service conditions.

Removal/immunity framework of the CEC

Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 and Form 6

What it is:
Subordinate legislation under the RP Act, 1950 that governs how electoral rolls are prepared and revised. It was made by the Central Government after consulting the Election Commission. It came into force on 1 January 1961.
Why it matters:
A uniform, statutory, citizen-facing application so that enrolment conditions are set by law, not by administrative discretion.

Additional context

  • The Court indicated that it cannot pass an ex-parte order on the basis of newspaper reports. If the records show that decisions were taken without the required unanimity or majority, those decisions could be reconsidered.
  • The Bench sought records to ascertain who made the Form 6 changes. One petition alleges the changes were introduced through the EC's software without following the prescribed statutory procedure.
  • Later development (after this batch): In a counter-affidavit (reported 26 Oct 2026), the EC said the three SIR orders of June 2025, October 2025 and May 2026 had the unanimous concurrence of all members. It also told the Court that Form 6 has not been amended by the SIR orders.

Mains dimensions

  • Rule of law and delegated legislation: If a statutory form needs lawful rule-making, adding conditions through an executive circular or software invites an ultra vires challenge. The Court's remark that it did not approve the changes undercuts the claim of judicial endorsement.
  • Collegiality of the multi-member EC: Petitioners claim unilateralism, while the BJP (via Sambit Patra) calls communication and reported dissent notes among the CEC and ECs a "healthy sign". The EC's later affidavit likewise says internal queries are routine in a multi-member body. The Court stated it would first look at the records on the unanimity point.
  • Accountability vs. independence: Immunity under Section 16 and the Art. 324(5) removal threshold protect the EC's independence. Bagchi's comparison with judges shows the "was" immunity may be wider than that of judges.
  • Disenfranchisement vs. roll purity: Large deletions (30% in Delhi, 25% in Bengal, as argued) set against the right to vote. The Form 6 linkage conditions can burden first-time voters. The mass appeal backlog (see the Bengal note) turns a procedural issue into a rights issue.
  • Institutional trust and polarisation: The "vote chori" campaign, the people's impeachment and the BJP's counter-narrative show politicised trust in the EC. Remedies include transparency of orders, a published rationale for deletions, and parliamentary-style accountability.
  • Judicial approach: The Court avoided an ex-parte suspension ("who will conduct elections?") while keeping the door open for corrective orders. This is a mix of restraint and supervision.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of the Election Commission rests on constitutional security of tenure, yet its credibility depends on lawful and collegial decision-making. In light of the recent controversy over the Special Intensive Revision and changes to Form 6, critically examine."

Related topics

  • Art. 324–329, RP Act 1950 (Sec. 21) and RP Act 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
  • Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2023) and the 2023 CEC/EC Act; Jaya Thakur challenge
  • Removal of judges (Art. 124(4); Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968)
  • Delegated legislation and ultra vires review; Model Code of Conduct
  • West Bengal SIR appellate tribunals (see the linked Bengal tribunal note)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 6 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs