BrainParrot

Backlash against mega data centres gains momentum, AI’s hidden cost

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 September 2026

Summary

  • Residents near planned hyperscale data centres are protesting worldwide, from Thane (Amazon), Melbourne, Ireland and Italy to Visakhapatnam (Google). Their complaints are heavy water and power use, noise, heat, land use and doubtful local benefit.
  • India is competing for AI-era investment and has no notified national policy. The Environment Ministry says such projects need no environmental clearance "per se".
  • Companies promise closed-loop or air cooling, clean energy and jobs, while critics flag water-source ambiguity and inflated job claims.

UPSC relevance: GS3 (Environment; Economy: infrastructure; S&T: IT/AI) / GS2 (Governance)

Key facts for Prelims

  • Hyperscalers: Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud.
  • Data centres need no EC "per se" under the EIA Notification, 2006, per the MoEFCC's reply to a parliamentary question in August. Local players say clearance is needed because of generator use.
  • The Draft National Data Centre Policy (2020) proposed single-clearance windows, economic zones, a renewable-energy focus and domestic manufacturing. It has not been notified.
  • Karnataka has approved a Sustainable Data Centre Policy.
  • CGWB's categories: Safe, Semi-Critical, Critical, Over-Exploited. Visakhapatnam is described as "overexploited" in CGWB's 2025 report (as cited in the article).
  • Polavaram project (Godavari, Andhra Pradesh): water is to be diverted for the Vizag data centre.
  • Lombardy (Italy) uses regional siting laws with energy thresholds: centres of 5 MW or less are "edge" data centres permissible within urban areas, while a 10 MW centre needs a territorial agreement including compensatory measures. Ireland requires data centre companies to generate their own power, 80% on-site renewable.
  • India's target: 500 GW green energy capacity by 2030.
  • The CEEW (Council on Energy, Environment and Water) is a policy think-tank whose figures the article uses repeatedly.

Data and details

  • Water:
  • A typical 100 MW hyperscaler data centre consumes nearly 2 million litres/day for on-site cooling (CEEW). This equals supplying about 15,000 urban residents (government estimates).
  • 1 tmc ≈ 28.3 billion litres.
  • Nara Lokesh told the Assembly (19 Aug) that the targeted 6.5 GW Vizag ecosystem needs 3 tmc/year, to be met by Godavari water via Polavaram. CM Chandrababu Naidu had cited 3.5 tmc on 12 Aug. The Human Rights Forum flags this discrepancy.
  • Vizag district officers did not respond. Project documents are available there, but the available water source is unclear.
  • Thane: Meena's society (Kalpataru, Balkum) had no water for five days last week.
  • Power:
  • Conventional data centre: 5–15 kW. AI data centre with GPUs: 40–60 kWh, and 100+ kWh for cutting-edge training. The latter is enough for 1,000 fridges for an hour.
  • Data centres took about 1.5% of global electricity in 2024. Demand is projected to double to 945 TWh by 2030 (CEEW).
  • Average rack density is expected to rise from 36 kW (2023) to 50 kW (2027) (CtrlS).
  • Capacity:
  • As of January 2026, India hosts about 271 data centres across 23 million sq m in six metro cities.
  • Installed capacity was 1.5 GW by mid-2025 and is projected at 4.5–6.5 GW by 2030, far below the roughly 500 GW of the U.S. and China.
  • Google's next India facility is a 1 GW AI data centre in Visakhapatnam.
  • Karnataka's policy targets 1 GW by 2031, with a ₹1,300.45 crore revised budget, to create 10–12% of India's AI-ready capacity.
  • Money and jobs:
  • Between 2019 and 2025, committed investment was about $95 billion (CEEW).
  • Foreign funding fell from $600–900 million/month in H1 2026 to about $100 million (Tracxn). Kranthi Bathini attributes this to fear of protest-driven delays. In September EQT announced about $30 billion.
  • Piyush Goyal: over $200 billion tax revenue expected, feeding the $30-trillion-by-2047 goal.
  • An industry source argues a light-touch approach is needed to maintain investor enthusiasm. Local players call the dissent "misguided" and "harmful", and worry that India will lose big-ticket projects. Data-sovereignty concerns have pushed hyperscalers into long-term contracts to set up local data centres.
  • Jitendra Singh projected nearly one lakh engineering jobs. Google's EIA report cites only 1,200 jobs, against a reported 1.8 lakh.
  • Company responses:
  • AWS Thane: closed-loop chemical coolant (not water), and a dedicated industrial substation on the high-voltage grid.
  • Google Vizag: a 3–5 year plan covering subsea cable landings, power utility infrastructure, clean energy and a logistics centre. Also independent environment audits, air-cooled systems, sound-damping fans, and "83% less overhead energy than industry average". Google's Alexander Smith also promises recruitment for day-one staffing, plus a long-term local talent pipeline and supplier ecosystem, and says Google is investing in clean energy generation in Andhra Pradesh and across India.
  • Aon's Sarin points to real-time energy management systems, digital twins and predictive maintenance. He says the challenge is less technological feasibility than scaling these economically while balancing performance, sustainability and resilience.
  • Sources and quotes:
  • Rahul Dhar's CtrlS blog post warns that most enterprise data centres weren't built for AI loads.
  • Arpitha Kodiveri asks how sites are being chosen. Jacqui Glover (Melbourne): cloud is "made of concrete, steel and relentless noise".
  • Sanchit Vir Gogia warns of "a poor national bargain" if public costs aren't matched by public benefit.
  • Other:
  • Environmental contamination risks come from water-treatment chemicals, fuel storage, and lead and mercury in e-equipment (Aon's Sushant Sarin). Land clearing is another concern.
  • WakeUp Thanekar has written to authorities seeking the development plan, zoning classification, control regulations and permissions.
  • ESDS flagged local protests as a risk in its draft red herring prospectus.
  • Notably absent: no notified national data centre policy, no clarity on Vizag's water source, and no response from Vizag district officers.

Static–dynamic linkage

The underlying static issue is the trade-off between infrastructure-led growth and sustainability, and who bears the externalities.

  • Water is a State subject, while energy and the EIA regime are shared or central. So siting decisions for data centres sit across multiple jurisdictions.
  • Environmental regulation works through a project-category EIA system, not by technology type. A data centre therefore falls through the cracks unless it meets a threshold.
  • The article's core question is whether India can build AI infrastructure without passing the costs on to host communities.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: EIA, conservation, pollution; GS3 – Economy: infrastructure, investment models, industrial policy; GS3 – S&T: IT, AI; GS2 – Governance: transparency, accountability, Centre-State relations.

Background primer

Data centre / hyperscaler

What it is:
a facility housing racks of servers and storage. Hyperscalers are the very large cloud operators (AWS, Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud). AI data centres use GPUs, which need far more power and cooling than conventional ones.

Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006

What it is:
the framework requiring prior environmental clearance (EC) for listed projects. It was issued under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 (static fact).
Mandate:
screening, scoping, public consultation and appraisal. Category A projects go to the Centre, and Category B to State authorities (SEIAAs) (static fact).

Central Ground Water Board (CGWB)

What it is:
the National Apex Agency responsible for scientific inputs for management, exploration, monitoring, assessment, augmentation and regulation of ground water. It works under the Ministry of Jal Shakti. Founding date: not confirmed from a trusted source.

Additional context

  • Regulatory position on EC (PIB, 6 Aug 2026).
    • AI data centres do not, per se, require Environmental Clearance under the EIA Notification, 2006.
    • However, those proposed as part of a building and construction project with built-up area over 20,000 sq m (item 8(a)), or a township and area development project of 50 ha and/or 1,50,000 sq m built-up (item 8(b)), do need prior EC.
    • EC for such building projects is granted by the State Environment Impact Assessment Authority.
    • Water and air discharges are regulated under the Water Act, 1974 and the Air Act, 1981, with compliance monitored by State Pollution Control Boards.
  • Policy status. The Data Centre Policy 2020 text (hosted on NITI for States) proposes rationalised clearances and time-bound single-window clearance by State governments.
  • Later development (after the article's date). NITI Aayog and Deloitte India released a "Data Centre Evaluation Framework to Help States Plan for Sustainable Growth" on 14 October 2026.
    • It proposes that States link approvals to verified electricity, water and infrastructure availability.
    • It sets out five pillars: power and energy; water and cooling; siting and environmental sustainability; economic and strategic value; and policy, governance and implementation.
    • It recommends seasonal water-availability assessments covering 20 to 30 years.
    • For centres needing over 20 MW, it recommends automated demand-response readiness and State Load Dispatch Centre integration.

Mains dimensions

  • Resource stress. The article's evidence on water and power is local and hard. Examples are Thane's days-long water cuts, Vizag's overexploited groundwater, and the gap between 3 tmc and 3.5 tmc water figures for the same project. This is a classic case of a high-value industry placed in a water-stressed region.
  • Regulatory gap. There is no EC "per se", the 2020 draft policy is unnotified, and frameworks are fragmented across cybersecurity, infrastructure and land. Compare with Lombardy's MW-based siting thresholds and Ireland's 80% on-site renewable rule. CEEW describes a widening gap between investment-led expansion and performance-based sustainability regulation.
  • Federalism. Water and land are State subjects. State policies (Karnataka's) fill the gap, and the 500 GW green-energy target leans on State policies as a "crutch".
  • Transparency and participation. Residents are asking for zoning and permission details, and Vizag has documents but no water source. It is a question of the public's right to information and environmental democracy.
  • Economic claims vs evidence. Revenue ($200 bn), investment ($95 bn) and jobs (1 lakh versus the EIA's 1,200) conflict. The questions are whether subsidies to hyperscalers deliver domestic benefit, and whether data-sovereignty-driven contracts are at risk from protests (the funding dip).
  • Way forward. Notify the national policy with performance-based norms (water-use ceilings, renewable share, disclosure). Do water-availability assessments before siting, and use closed-loop or air cooling. Add local-benefit and compensatory conditions, and verify job and tax claims.

Possible Mains question

**GS3, 15 marks:** "India's push to become an AI and data centre hub is meeting local resistance over water, power and land. Examine the environmental and governance challenges and suggest a regulatory framework that balances investment and sustainability."

Related topics

  • EIA Notification 2006, SEIAA, National Green Tribunal
  • Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and Air Act, 1981
  • Groundwater governance: CGWB, CGWA, State List entry on water
  • IndiaAI Mission, data localisation and data sovereignty, Digital Personal Data Protection Act
  • India's renewable energy target (500 GW by 2030), grid and power demand
  • Polavaram project and Godavari water allocation
  • Article 21 and the right to a healthy environment, sustainable development

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs