BrainParrot

T.N. rescinds G.O. exempting Public Dept. from RTI Act

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 September 2026

Summary

  • On Sunday, the Tamil Nadu government withdrew a Government Order that had exempted the Public (Law and Order) Department from the RTI Act, 2005. It was withdrawn after backlash from political parties and activists.
  • The G.O. was dated 21 September and issued by the Human Resources Management Department under Section 24(4) of the RTI Act. It was then notified in the Government Gazette.
  • Its stated ground was that the Department is an "intelligence and security organisation".
  • Minister for Energy Resources and Law C.T.R. Nirmal Kumar announced the withdrawal on X.
  • Earlier that day in Madurai he had defended the order. He said only certain provisions, including details of communal clashes, were kept out of the RTI ambit because of their sensitivity.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity & Governance: transparency, RTI, State–citizen accountability; also law and order and human rights

Key facts for Prelims

  • Section 24(1) RTI Act, 2005 is the Central exemption for the organisations in the Second Schedule. Section 24(2) lets the Centre amend the Schedule. Section 24(4) is the State equivalent, and under Section 24(5) every State notification must be laid before the State Legislature.
  • Proviso to Section 24: information on corruption and human-rights violations is not excluded.
  • The Second Schedule covers organisations established by the Central Government, such as the IB, RAW, the Directorate of Enforcement and the NCB.
  • Section 8(1)(a) exempts information that would prejudice India's sovereignty, integrity, security, strategic, scientific or economic interests, or relations with a foreign state.
  • COFEPOSA and the National Security Act (NSA) are preventive-detention laws. The department's detention work covers representations and habeas corpus petitions.
  • The G.O. was issued by the Human Resources Management Department, not by the Home or Public department.

Data and details

  • G.O. dated 21 September 2026; withdrawn on Sunday (27 September 2026), roughly six days after issue.
  • The Public (Law and Order) Department deals with:
  • communal and caste clashes;
  • appointment of Commissions of Inquiry on law and order and the follow-up of their recommendations;
  • all COFEPOSA and NSA detention matters, including representations by detenus and habeas corpus petitions in the High Court and Supreme Court;
  • monthly law and order review meetings and special meetings under the Chief Secretary's instructions.
  • It also handles:
  • inquiry reports on police firing, custody deaths, police torture and deaths of remand prisoners;
  • NHRC references on matters handled by the law and order wing;
  • monthly reports on law and order and communal incidents to the Government of India;
  • replies to Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha questions on law and order;
  • agitations by students, agricultural labourers and political parties;
  • requests to withdraw cases registered on political grounds or arising from communal, caste, political or student agitations;
  • sanction for prosecution for defamatory articles, news items and speeches.
  • Opponents named in the article:
  • T.T.V. Dhinakaran (AMMK founder);
  • G. Sundarrajan (environmental activist, Poovulagin Nanbargal);
  • Jayaram Venkatesan (Arappor Iyakkam convener).
  • Minister's defence: only certain provisions, including details of communal clashes, were kept out. The report itself describes the G.O. as a department-wide exemption.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The RTI Act creates a statutory right to information from public authorities. It is a tool of accountability, and the Supreme Court has read it as flowing from the fundamental right to free speech and expression (Article 19(1)(a)).
  • Exemptions are of two kinds:
    • Section 8: subject-matter exemptions applied case by case.
    • Section 24: whole organisations excluded, but only if they are intelligence and security organisations.
  • Section 24(4) lets a State exempt such organisations established by it.
  • Even exempt organisations must give information on corruption and human-rights violations.
  • The test is therefore functional. A department that handles policy, inquiries and detention representations is not obviously an "intelligence and security organisation".

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: RTI Act, 2005; transparency and accountability in governance; Section 24 exemptions | GS2 – Governance: citizen–State relations and the executive's discretion | GS2 – Polity: human rights bodies (NHRC) and preventive detention

Background primer

Right to Information Act, 2005

What it is:
A law providing for timely disclosure of information from Central and State public authorities, to empower citizens and promote accountability and transparency.
Founded:
enacted in 2005 to turn the right to know into an enforceable statutory right.
Members:
it applies to public authorities. The term covers bodies set up under the Constitution or by law, and bodies owned, controlled or substantially financed by government. It extends to Parliament, State Legislatures and constitutional authorities such as the Election Commission and the CAG.
Mandate:
access to information, with Section 8 exemptions and the Section 24 carve-out.
Why it matters:
Exemptions are not absolute. Withholding must be balanced against disclosure in the public interest.

Section 24 and the Second Schedule

What it is:
Section 24(1) says the Act does not apply to the intelligence and security organisations in the Second Schedule, which are established by the Central Government.
Why it matters:
protect genuinely sensitive intelligence and security work.

Additional context

  • Precedent of exemption-by-notification. In 2023 the Centre, through DoPT, used Section 24(2) to exempt CERT-In. CERT-In joined 26 other intelligence and security organisations already exempted.
  • How the CIC has read the exemption.
    • The CIC has said the exemption covers technical, technological or operational matters, not establishment-related matters.
    • For exempt bodies such as the CISF, information on corruption or human-rights violations must still be provided.
  • Criticism of the provision. An exam-prep source notes that agencies have treated the exemption as blanket cover, and undefined terms invite abuse.
  • Background not confirmed from a trusted source: whether the Tamil Nadu G.O. text is available.

Mains dimensions

  • Functional mismatch. The department's own portfolio is policy and accountability work: custody deaths, police firing, NHRC references, detention petitions and replies to Parliament. It is not clearly an intelligence or security organisation within Section 24's meaning.
  • Shielding accountability material. Exempting the department would shut out RTI queries on custody deaths, police torture and police firing. These are exactly the human-rights issues the Section 24 proviso protects, and critics would say the exemption defeats the proviso's purpose.
  • Executive route versus legislative route.
  • The order was issued through a notification route (Section 24(4)). It did not come through a debated amendment.
  • A Central notification under Section 24(2) must be laid before Parliament, and a State notification under Section 24(4) before the State Legislature (Section 24(5)).
  • Laying before the legislature is the statutory check. Here, public pressure from parties and activists reversed the order within days.
  • Speed of reversal as a lesson. Public pressure from parties and civil society groups led to withdrawal within about six days. This illustrates civil society as a check on executive discretion.
  • Mixed messaging. The minister's partial defence ("certain provisions") sat alongside a reported department-wide exemption. Clarity of State justification is part of transparent governance.
  • Balance. Genuine sensitivities, such as communal-clash intelligence, may justify targeted Section 8 exemptions case by case, without a blanket organisational exemption.
  • Way forward.
  • Define "intelligence and security organisation" narrowly.
  • Require reasoned, published notifications.
  • Make the Section 24(5) laying of State notifications before the Legislature a substantive review, with reasons published.
  • Strengthen proactive disclosure under Section 4.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Exemptions from the RTI Act, whether by Section 8 or by Section 24 notification, must be tested against the public-interest principle. Examine in the light of recent State action on exempting a law and order department."

Related topics

  • RTI Act, 2005: Section 4 proactive disclosure, Section 8 exemptions and the role of the Information Commissions
  • Article 19(1)(a) and the right to know; Article 22 and preventive detention (NSA, COFEPOSA)
  • NHRC and the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993; custodial violence
  • Federalism: the Constitutional scheme of "Police" and "Public Order" as State subjects

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs