BrainParrot

Form 26 and the statutory mandate

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 28 September 2026

Summary

  • On June 12, the Supreme Court dismissed Congress leader Meenakshi Natarajan's petition against the Returning Officer's rejection of her Rajya Sabha nomination from Madhya Pradesh. The RO held she had suppressed material information by not disclosing a pending criminal complaint in her Form 26 affidavit.
  • The author argues the case raises two larger questions: whether delegated legislation (Form 26) can enlarge a statutory disclosure duty, and whether Art. 329(b) (the Ponnuswami doctrine) should leave courts powerless against patently arbitrary RO decisions.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: electoral law, candidate disclosure, judicial review in election matters

Key facts for Prelims

  • Section 33-A, RP Act, 1951 (inserted 2002 after Union of India v. ADR, 2002): disclosure of pending cases with offences punishable with 2+ years where charges are framed, and convictions with a sentence of 1+ years.
  • Form 26 is the affidavit prescribed under Rule 4A of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961. Candidates file it with the nomination paper.
  • Art. 329(b): bars courts from questioning an election except by an election petition. Section 80 RP Act mirrors it. Section 100 lists the grounds to set aside an election.
  • N.P. Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer (1952): Constitution Bench; "election" means notification to declaration of results.
  • Art. 32: right to constitutional remedies, which Ambedkar called the "heart and soul" of the Constitution (as the article notes). Art. 226 gives High Courts the writ power.
  • Section 33-B (blanket bar on additional disclosure) was struck down. Section 125A penalises false information in the affidavit.

Data and details

  • June 12: the Supreme Court dismissed Natarajan's petition against the RO's rejection of her Rajya Sabha nomination from Madhya Pradesh.
  • The RO's ground: non-disclosure in Form 26 of a pending criminal complaint, treated as suppression of material information.
  • The complaint, instituted in 2025, alleges she failed to take appropriate action against a party leader accused of misconduct.
  • Natarajan has been given liberty to challenge the rejection through an election petition under Section 100.
  • Form 26's 2018 change: Paragraph 5 requires disclosure of all pending criminal cases. Section 33-A covers only cases involving offences punishable with 2+ years where charges have been framed.
  • The author says the SC relied on Ponnuswami to hold that Art. 329(b) bars judicial intervention once the election process has begun.
  • The author's two asks: revisit Ponnuswami; and clarify whether constitutional courts should be powerless against patent arbitrariness during the electoral process.

Static–dynamic linkage

Candidate disclosure rests on the voter's right to know (Art. 19(1)(a), as developed by the Court). The statute (Section 33-A) fixes the minimum disclosure on criminal antecedents. Rule 4A and Form 26 only prescribe the manner of disclosing it. A rule cannot go beyond its parent Act, so the 2018 expansion of Form 26 (all pending cases) is open to a vires challenge. Separately, Art. 329(b) channels election disputes into an election petition after the poll, which keeps elections on schedule but can leave an arbitrary rejection without a mid-process remedy.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Representation of the People Act, 1951; Conduct of Election Rules, 1961; Art. 329(b); Arts 32 and 226; separation of delegated and substantive law.

Background primer

Form 26 affidavit and Section 33-A (RP Act, 1951)

What it is:
An affidavit filed at the time of delivering the nomination paper, referred to in Section 33A(2). Per the article, Rule 4A of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961 requires it. Candidates disclose criminal antecedents, assets, liabilities and educational qualifications.

Art. 329(b) and N.P. Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer (1952)

What it is:
Art. 329(b): no election to Parliament or a State Legislature shall be called in question except by an election petition.

Additional context

  • Section 100 and Section 80: Section 80 is drafted almost like Art. 329(b). Section 100 lists grounds on which an election may be set aside, including improper rejection of a nomination paper. This is the remedy Natarajan has been told to use.

  • Mohinder Singh Gill (1978): The Court called Art. 329(b) a blanket ban on litigative challenges to electoral steps taken to carry the election to its declaration. It said ground before the notification and beyond the declaration is not forbidden.

  • Where the Supreme Court has placed Form 26's disclosures: In a 14 August 2025 judgment, the Court noted that Section 33A does not provide for disclosure of assets and educational qualifications. These requirements are found only in the Form 26 affidavit under Rule 4A. It added that disclosure of criminal antecedents deserves scrupulous and stricter treatment. This sits uneasily with, and complicates, the author's purely vires-based argument.

  • Recorded dispute over the 2018 amendment: In a Bombay High Court judgment, counsel's submissions record that Central Government changes of 10 October 2018 required disclosure of all pending cases (and all convictions). These are counsel's submissions, not holdings.

Mains dimensions

  • Delegated legislation vs parent Act: Rule 4A is a procedural tool for Section 33-A and cannot become an independent source of substantive obligations. The 2018 paragraph 5 appears to do exactly that.
  • Counter-view: the Supreme Court has treated Form 26 as the source of some disclosure duties (assets, education), and has stressed strictness on criminal antecedents.
  • Open question: whether broader disclosure is a legitimate extension of the voter's right to know or a vires problem.
  • Consequences of mismatch: A candidate can lose a nomination for omitting something the Act itself does not require. Rejection at scrutiny effectively ends participation, so the stakes of a procedural form are high.
  • Judicial review during elections: Ponnuswami protects the poll schedule, but the author argues it should not shield manifestly arbitrary or jurisdictionless decisions from Arts 32 and 226.
  • Challenge afterwards through an election petition can leave a wrongly excluded candidate without a seat in the contest, and the remedy comes only after the poll.
  • Counter-view: the election petition is a special, statutory remedy designed for speed and finality, and the Court has treated the bar as plenary.
  • Informed voter: Strict disclosure serves the right to know and decriminalisation of politics. Over-broad disclosure of every pending complaint can also stigmatise candidates with unproven or politically motivated cases.
  • Way forward: Align Form 26 with the Act through amendment of Section 33-A or the Form. Provide a time-bound mechanism for nomination-rejection challenges consistent with Art. 329(b).

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Can delegated legislation enlarge a substantive statutory obligation? Discuss in the context of candidate disclosure through Form 26, and examine whether Art. 329(b) should bar judicial review of arbitrary rejections of nominations."

Related topics

  • Union of India v. ADR (2002) and PUCL (2003); right to know under Art. 19(1)(a)
  • Criminalisation of politics; disqualification under Section 8 RP Act
  • Art. 329(b), Mohinder Singh Gill (1978) and Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975)
  • Delegated legislation and rule-making limits
  • Election petitions: Sections 80–100 RP Act (cross-reference: the ECI/SIR note from the same issue)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 28 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs