BrainParrot

Minister in a panel to select CEC sends wrong signal: SC

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 24 September 2026

Summary

  • A two-judge Supreme Court Bench delivered a split verdict on whether the challenge to the 2023 Act on appointing the CEC and ECs should go to a Constitution Bench. Justice Dipankar Datta saw no need for a reference. Justice Satish Chandra Sharma, the puisne judge, favoured one.
  • In a separate opinion, Justice Datta said that replacing the CJI with a Union Cabinet Minister on the PM-led panel is prima facie an effective veto for the Union government. He said it fails the "perception test".
  • In the same opinion he defended the Collegium system and attacked the Union government's handling of judicial appointments.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Judiciary, constitutional bodies, separation of powers, executive–judiciary relations

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324(2): appointment of CEC/ECs by the President, subject to Parliament's law.
  • Article 145(3): a Constitution Bench of at least five judges decides a "substantial question of law" involving interpretation of the Constitution.
  • Article 75(3): the Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha. Justice Datta used this to argue that a Cabinet Minister will not defy the PM.
  • Anoop Baranwal (2023) interim panel: PM + LoP + CJI. The 2023 Act panel: PM + LoP + Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM.
  • Under the Act, the Search Committee is headed by the Law Minister.
  • Free and fair elections and an independent ECI are part of the Basic Structure.
  • Collegium: Articles 124(2) and 217; Judges Cases of 1981, 1993, 1998; NJAC struck down in 2015. The SC collegium is the CJI and four senior-most judges.
  • Puisne judge: a judge other than the Chief Justice of the court.

Data and details

  • Justice Datta's opinion: the Cabinet Minister's presence is an effective veto in favour of the Union government. The Leader of Opposition's role is "ornamental". He said that "it is not enough" for the EC to be independent and that it must also appear independent.
  • Cricket analogy: an umpire chosen by one side's captain carries suspicion even when decisions are correct.
  • Justice Sharma held that several questions of substantial importance require a Constitution Bench under Article 145(3).
  • Collegium remarks (Datta): "judges appoint judges" is a myth spread by vested interests through motivated narratives, drawing on controversial decisions "in this century". The appointment process involves detailed consultation, the executive at Centre and State levels, intelligence and other agencies. Every appointment bears the President's imprimatur.
  • Executive conduct (Datta): "piecemeal approvals"; names gather dust for years; transfer recommendations are often not acted upon. He said the judiciary is already relegated to "second fiddle" and that the demand to induct an "outsider" at selection stage is a feeble attempt to deflect attention from the executive's own dereliction.

Static–dynamic linkage

Article 324(2) says appointments to the ECI are made by the President "subject to any law made by Parliament". For seven decades there was no such law. Appointments were made on the executive's advice, until the Supreme Court's interim panel in Anoop Baranwal (2023) put the CJI on it. Parliament then legislated, and replaced the CJI with a Cabinet Minister. The legal tension is whether Parliament may legislate away a safeguard the Court devised for a constitutional vacuum, and whether the resulting panel is neutral or only appears so. Justice Datta links this to judicial appointments by noting that the executive criticises the Collegium while demanding a say in the CEC panel from which the judiciary was removed.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Appointment to constitutional posts; Judiciary (Collegium, judicial independence); separation of powers; Basic Structure; Constitution Bench (Art. 145(3)); Council of Ministers' collective responsibility (Art. 75(3)).

Background primer

Anoop Baranwal v. Union of India (2 March 2023)

What it is:
A unanimous ruling by a five-judge Constitution Bench that a committee must choose the CEC and ECs.
Why it matters:
Independence of the ECI is part of the basic structure, hence the need for an interim arrangement.

CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023, Section 7 (Selection Committee)

What it is:
The law that replaced the interim Baranwal panel.

Collegium system

What it is:
A system, not found in the Constitution, in which judges appoint judges; it is an invention of the Supreme Court.

Additional context

  • Reports of the same verdict describe a 1:1 split, with the challenge referred to the CJI for consideration of an appropriate Constitution Bench.

  • PRS had earlier pointed out that if the Lok Sabha is dissolved and the Leader of Opposition post is vacant, the Selection Committee would consist only of ruling-party members.

  • Reports (The Indian Express, 24 Sept 2026) said two Election Commissioners had objected to decisions of CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The ECI said its decisions, including the SIR, were taken unanimously by the full Commission (AIR, 23 Sept 2026). This puts the Commission's independence and the way it is appointed in focus.

Mains dimensions

  • Perception vs actual independence: The judge's test of seeming independent is not only about proven bias. A panel where the executive has two of three members gives a veto in practice, because the Cabinet Minister shares collective responsibility with the PM.
  • Parliament vs Court: Can Parliament modify a remedy the Court created for a vacuum, or is that a legislative overruling? Article 324(2) expressly lets Parliament legislate on these appointments. Challengers say the Act removes a safeguard Baranwal treated as essential. This is the core question for a Constitution Bench.
  • Consistency across appointments: The CJI (or a nominee) sits on the CBI Director's selection panel but not on the CEC's, so the logic of excluding the judiciary here is unclear. Meanwhile, the executive's critique of the Collegium is answered by Justice Datta with its own record of delay and piecemeal approval.
  • Executive–judiciary friction: Justice Datta says names gather dust for years and approvals come piecemeal, which erodes the Collegium's primacy in practice. Reform options: a Memorandum of Procedure with time limits, transparency in the Collegium process, and a statutory body that guarantees judicial primacy without exclusivity.
  • Impact on the live ECI controversy: Around the same time, reports of two ECs' objections to the CEC's decisions (which the ECI denies were dissent on decisions) raised the question of whether a Commission picked by a government-dominated panel can be trusted. The Court's "perception test" bears directly on this.
  • Way forward: A Constitution Bench ruling; a broader panel (CJI or a neutral member, Speaker, Law Minister); a mandatory vacancy-proof LoP; a published selection record.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The independence of constitutional bodies depends on the method of appointment of their members. Discuss with reference to the replacement of the CJI by a Union Cabinet Minister in the selection panel for the Election Commission and the debate over the Collegium system."

Related topics

  • Article 324, Basic Structure doctrine; Article 142; Article 143; Article 145(3)
  • Collegium, NJAC (99th Amendment); Memorandum of Procedure
  • CBI Director selection panel (Lokpal/DSPE framework); selection of other statutory heads
  • The Election Commission rift and the SIR dispute

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 24 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs