Chavan’s exit has diminished UCC draft panel credibility: MLA
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 24 September 2026
Summary
- Justice R.C. Chavan, a former Bombay High Court judge, resigned from Maharashtra's seven-member UCC drafting committee. He cited reservations over the panel's decision to restrict public feedback on crucial social issues to a binary "Yes/No" format.
- SP MLA Rais Shaikh wrote to CM Devendra Fadnavis alleging that the panel's credibility was undermined. He demanded a minority representative.
- The Congress, through Jairam Ramesh, called the UCC a political instrument rather than legal reform and questioned whether the Constituent Assembly envisaged separate State-level UCCs.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 44 (Part IV, DPSP): State to endeavour to secure a UCC for citizens throughout India. Not justiciable (Art. 37).
- Concurrent List Entry 5, Seventh Schedule: marriage, divorce, adoption, succession and personal law.
- Article 162: a State's executive power extends to matters on which its legislature can legislate.
- Goa: Portuguese Civil Code of 1867. Uttarakhand: first State UCC (in force 27 Jan 2025); Gujarat: second.
- Cases: Shah Bano (1985), Sarla Mudgal (1995), John Vallamattom (2003).
- A State Bill repugnant to a central law on a Concurrent subject needs Presidential assent (Art. 254(2)); Governors may reserve Bills for the President.
Data and details
- Maharashtra panel: seven members, constituted in July, six-month term, no minority-community representative (per SP MLA Rais Shaikh).
- Chavan's objection: public feedback on crucial social issues restricted to a binary "Yes/No" format.
- Rais Shaikh's letter to CM Fadnavis: the draft is a BJP political strategy "with an eye on elections". He alleges an attempt to impose "norms of the majority" and demands a minority representative to "enhance" credibility.
- Congress (Jairam Ramesh, general secretary in charge of communications): UCC used as a political instrument rather than a legal reform. He says the way it is pursued could keep society in "permanent polarisation".
- Ramesh's questions: whether the Constituent Assembly envisaged every State framing its own UCC, and what Chavan's resignation says about the pursuit of "separate UCCs by States".
- The Congress levelled these charges against the Narendra Modi government. They followed Chavan's resignation from the seven-member panel.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Article 44 asks the State to "endeavour" to secure a UCC. It is a non-justiciable Directive Principle (Art. 37).
- Personal-law subjects sit on the Concurrent List, so both Parliament and States can legislate. State laws must still satisfy Fundamental Rights, and a State law repugnant to a central law needs Presidential assent (Art. 254(2)).
- The debate is whether piecemeal State UCCs deliver "uniformity" and whether the drafting process is inclusive.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: DPSP (Art. 44), Seventh Schedule (Concurrent List Entry 5), Centre-State relations, secularism and minority rights (Arts. 25–30); GS2 – Governance: transparency in consultation
Background primer
Uniform Civil Code (Article 44)
- What it is:
- A single law for all religious communities in personal matters such as marriage, divorce, inheritance and adoption.
- Why it matters:
- Gender justice and legal uniformity, balanced against religious freedom and plurality (Constituent Assembly debates saw both views).
State-level UCCs
Additional context
- Maharashtra CM Fadnavis announced a seven-member committee headed by retired Supreme Court Justice Ranjana Desai to draft the UCC.
- It is to report within six months. The government intends to table the UCC Bill in the winter session in Nagpur.
- Members include former Bombay High Court judges R.C. Chavan and S.G. Mehare, Ramesh Patange (former Chief Secretary and Advocate General) and Suvarna Rawal.
- Justice Desai previously chaired the expert committees formed by the Uttarakhand and Gujarat governments.
- Chavan resigned on 19 September 2026, after the committee's second online meeting.
- His reasons included differences over the committee's functioning and the participation of an officer from outside Maharashtra, and meetings ending without substantive discussion of agenda items.
- He also said a questionnaire finalised by the chairperson had already been circulated.
Mains dimensions
- Legislative competence: Concurrent List Entry 5 allows State laws, but the Article 44 vision of "uniform" law "throughout the territory of India" invites the question of whether a patchwork of State codes serves uniformity. Ramesh raises exactly this point.
- Process legitimacy: Resignation of a senior jurist over the quality of consultation (Yes/No format), plus the absence of a minority representative, goes to procedural fairness. Binary questionnaires are poorly suited to complex family-law choices.
- Politics vs reform: The Congress and SP allege electoral motives; supporters of the move invoke the Article 44 Directive Principle. The CM has said the Bill is to come in the winter session after the report, which brings the timeline close to political calendars.
- Rights balance: Gender justice and equality (Arts. 14, 15) must be weighed against freedom of religion and cultural rights (Arts. 25, 29). Tribal exemptions (as in Uttarakhand) show the concern for diversity.
- Federal implications: Multiple State UCCs could create inter-State conflicts of law in marriage and inheritance. Legislative reservation for the President under Art. 254(2) becomes relevant.
- Way forward: Broad-based consultation with all communities, open-ended public input, a representative panel, and consideration of the Law Commission's views.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine the constitutional and federal issues involved in States enacting their own Uniform Civil Codes. Does the State-level approach advance or undermine the idea of uniformity under Article 44?"
Related topics
- DPSPs vs Fundamental Rights; Article 25–30 and secularism
- Shah Bano case, Sarla Mudgal, Triple Talaq (Shayara Bano) judgment
- Seventh Schedule; Art. 254 and Presidential assent; Governor's reservation powers
- Law Commission of India on family law reform; Goa civil code; Uttarakhand UCC Act
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 24 September 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs