BrainParrot
PolityGS2

Parliamentary System

India runs the British "Westminster" model of government, adapted to a written, federal, republican constitution. This topic compares it with presidential and semi-presidential systems, its British parent and major world constitutions. The President, PM, Council of Ministers and Parliament have their own topics; see also Salient Features and Basic Structure.

Based on: NCERT and standard textbooks; reviewed by the BrainParrot team. How we make our notes

In this note
  1. 1. 1. Parliamentary and presidential government: the basic idea
  2. 2. 2. Features of the parliamentary system in India
  3. 3. 3. Features of the presidential system
  4. 4. 4. Merits and demerits of both systems
  5. 5. 5. Why India chose the parliamentary system
  6. 6. 6. Indian vs British parliamentary system
  7. 7. 7. Semi-presidential systems
  8. 8. 8. Should India switch to a presidential system? (neutral debate)
  9. 9. 9. World constitutions at a glance
  10. 10. For Mains: Analysis
  11. 11. Quick Revision
  12. 12. Common Exam Traps

1. Parliamentary and presidential government: the basic idea

The dividing line: is the executive answerable to the legislature?

Modern democracies are mostly representative (indirect); direct democracy (referendum, initiative, recall) survives mainly in Switzerland. The test that separates the two main kinds is the relationship between the executive and the legislature.

  • In a parliamentary system, the executive is responsible to the legislature for its policies and acts. It is drawn from the legislature and stays in office only while it keeps the confidence of the lower House.
  • In a presidential system, the executive is not responsible to the legislature. It is constitutionally independent of the legislature with respect to its term of office, which is fixed.
NameAlso calledExamples
ParliamentaryCabinet government, responsible government, Westminster modelBritain, Japan, Canada, India, Germany, Italy
PresidentialNon-responsible, non-parliamentary or fixed-executive systemUSA, Brazil and most of Latin America

Jennings called it the "cabinet system" because the Cabinet is the nucleus of power; "responsible" because the Cabinet lasts only while it keeps Parliament's confidence; "Westminster" after the seat of the British Parliament.

Constitutional basis in India

The Constitution provides for a parliamentary form of government both at the Centre and in the states.

  • Centre: Articles 74 and 75. Article 74 creates a Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister to aid and advise the President; Article 75 provides for the appointment of the Prime Minister by the President and of other ministers by the President on the Prime Minister's advice, their tenure during the President's pleasure and their collective responsibility to the Lok Sabha.
  • States: Articles 163 and 164, the same scheme with the Governor, the Chief Minister and the Legislative Assembly.

"First among equals" or "Prime Ministerial government"?

The British PM was once called "primus inter pares" (first among equals); as the office grew, R.H. Crossman and J.P. Mackintosh spoke of "Prime Ministerial government", a label also applied to India when one party has a clear majority.

Three types of executive

Having an officer called "President" does not make a system presidential. India, Germany and Italy all have Presidents, yet all are parliamentary.

TypeHead of stateHead of governmentExamples
ParliamentaryA nominal President or monarch with mainly ceremonial powersPrime Minister (Chancellor in Germany), who with the Cabinet wields real powerUK, Japan (Emperor), Canada (monarch), Germany, Italy, India
PresidentialPresidentThe same PresidentUSA, Brazil, most of Latin America
Semi-presidentialA President with significant day-to-day powersA Prime Minister responsible to the legislature; President and PM may belong to different partiesFrance, Russia, Sri Lanka

Russia and Sri Lanka: classify with care. Some lists call both "presidential", because the directly elected President dominates the executive (in Sri Lanka the President also heads the Cabinet). They are classed here as semi-presidential because each also has a government answerable to the legislature: Sri Lanka's Cabinet is "collectively responsible and answerable to Parliament" (Art 42); Russia's State Duma "may express no-confidence" in the Government (Art 117).

Political and permanent executive. Ministers form the political executive (policy); civil servants form the permanent executive (administration). Ministers control the bureaucracy, and through them the legislature does. The bureaucracy is meant to be politically neutral, recruited on merit by the Union and State Public Service Commissions.

2. Features of the parliamentary system in India
3. Features of the presidential system
4. Merits and demerits of both systems
5. Why India chose the parliamentary system
6. Indian vs British parliamentary system
7. Semi-presidential systems
8. Should India switch to a presidential system? (neutral debate)
9. World constitutions at a glance
For Mains: Analysis
Quick Revision
Common Exam Traps
Unlock the full note, MCQs and flashcards

Sign up free to read every section of this note, test yourself with topic-matched MCQs, and revise with spaced-repetition flashcards.

Get started free