Incomplete remedies
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 20 November 2026
Summary
- After the Special Summary Revision (SSR) in States that had already gone through the Special Intensive Revision (SIR), the ECI added about 74 lakh names back to the rolls. It has extended SSR to Phase 3 States/UTs and opened a fresh re-entry window for electors deleted in the seven States/UTs where SIR is still running.
- The editorial argues these remedies are only partial. The SIR's core structure, including the "last SIR" matching, document demands and "logical discrepancy" checks, is untouched. It asks the Supreme Court to push the ECI back to the 2002-03 door-to-door model.
- Three related reports show the problem on the ground:
- Bengaluru: deleted voters reappearing on the final roll with their old EPIC numbers.
- The Supreme Court urging deleted voters to use every ECI window before 30 November.
- Alleged fabricated Form 7 deletion applications in Delhi's Mustafabad constituency.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: ECI's superintendence, direction and control of rolls and elections. Article 326: adult suffrage (18+). Articles 327/328: legislative power of Parliament/State legislatures over elections.
- Section 21, RP Act 1950: preparation and revision of electoral rolls, including special revision. Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: Form 6 (new enrolment), Form 7 (objection/deletion), Form 8 (correction/shifting of residence). The ECI's Manual on Electoral Rolls requires a new EPIC number when a person ceases to be enrolled and applies again via Form 6.
- Rule 21(1) of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 is the provision ERO uses to process the returning-elector forms and restore old EPIC numbers.
- ASDD = Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate. EPIC = Electors' Photo Identity Card.
- ERO (SDM-level) → DM (first appeal) → CEO of the State (second appeal).
- New safeguard in SSR Phase 3: personal notice before any deletion other than death, and personal cross-verification by the ERO wherever deletions exceed 2% of a polling station's electors. SSR requires no proof of citizenship or mapping to older rolls.
Data and details
- Net addition after SSR: about 74 lakh names, in 13 States. Electorate in those States fell from 49.61 crore to 45.22 crore after SIR and is now 45.96 crore.
- Draft deletions in Phase 3 averaged 17% and reached 32.8% in Delhi.
- Reach of the new remedies: about 4.5 crore of the 13.37 crore struck off the draft rolls. They do not cover electors who moved out of their State.
- Bihar and West Bengal, which have already voted on SIR rolls, offer deleted electors only Form 6 re-entry via SSR, as new voters with fresh EPIC numbers. This leaves no record that they were ever on the roll.
- Seven States/UTs (including Delhi and Maharashtra) still have SIR under way. There, electors who did not return forms can now do so with an explanation. Those who moved within the State can use the enumeration form with proof of the new address.
- Editorial's key charges: the structure of the SIR remains intact. Electors must still give details from "the last SIR", and those whose details are unavailable or mismatched face document demands that amount to a citizenship test. The legality of the "logical discrepancy" checks remains unaddressed.
- Benchmark cited: the 2002-03 special revision enumerated shifted persons door to door at their new addresses.
- Supreme Court, 28 October: it called forcing deleted electors to re-enrol via Form 6 an "error". It suggested enumeration forms or Form 8 (used by registered voters to update details such as change of residence).
- ECI's 14 November assurance:
- ASDD voters may submit enumeration forms stating their current ordinary residence.
- Those who did not shift need only give reasons for not filing earlier.
- Within-State shifters need not file Form 8.
- Those who already filed Form 6 will not face criminal prosecution.
- Hearing of 19 November (Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant, with Justice Joymalya Bagchi):
- Special enumeration closes on 30 November. The Court will take stock on 2 December and may extend the deadline.
- The ECI must submit a tabular count of applications for inclusion, deletion and correction.
- Justice Bagchi's advice to voters was to use the window and see how far the ECI accommodates them.
- Petitioners are activists Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri (advocates Prashant Bhushan, Cheryl D'Souza, Neha Rathi). They said ASDD voters in Delhi were compelled to file Form 6 as "fresh applicants", a misrepresentation they say is a criminal offence attracting imprisonment.
- Bhushan: distribution and collection of enumeration forms starts only on 19 November, and 12 days is inadequate for 47 lakh ASDD voters. He alleged hardly any ground implementation of the 28 October suggestions.
- Bengaluru (The Hindu investigation):
- At least 1,635 persons listed under ASDD for deletion are in the final roll with their old EPIC numbers, across 28 Assembly constituencies and all four ASDD categories.
- Many appear in constituencies different from the original ones. Example: Patil Girinath, enrolled in Rajarajeshwari Nagar and marked dead, now appears as a voter in Anekal.
- If these had truly been deleted and re-enrolled through Form 6, they would have got new EPIC numbers. The roll therefore retains entries the SIR was meant to weed out.
- Mustafabad (Delhi) "ghost Form 7s":
- The Court directed authorities to verify the allegations and take remedial measures. It urged Congress leader Ali Mehdi (advocate Shariq Ahmed) to approach the jurisdictional magistrate if police refuse an FIR.
- Voters proposed for deletion as dead, absent or permanently shifted were found alive and at their recorded addresses. The persons named as applicants deny filing or signing the forms.
- Of 37 applications examined by authorities, 36 were found false or fabricated. The Hindu physically traced 28 electors against whom deletion applications had been filed.
- The petition argued that a roll's integrity is compromised equally by retaining an ineligible name and by removing an eligible elector on a non-existent fact or an objection never made.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The ECI has plenary power to supervise and control preparation of electoral rolls (Article 324). Article 326 grounds the right to be enrolled in universal adult suffrage: a citizen aged 18+, ordinarily resident, not disqualified by law.
- The tension is between the roll's "purity" (removing dead, shifted, duplicate and ineligible entries) and "inclusion" (no eligible citizen left out). Procedure matters: notice, hearing, burden of proof and who decides citizenship.
- Courts police this balance. Natural justice and the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 limit how far Article 324 discretion can go.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act; Elections and electoral reforms; Judiciary's role in electoral governance
Background primer
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- a time-bound, house-to-house verification by Booth Level Officers (BLOs) to update and correct electoral rolls. It is run before major elections. Electors fill an enumeration form, and those not matched to the "last SIR" roll face notices and document checks.
Election Commission of India
- What it is:
- the constitutional body (Article 324) that superintends, directs and controls preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- constituted on 25 January 1950 (observed as National Voters' Day).
- Why it matters:
- an independent umpire for free and fair elections.
Additional context
- The ECI's own SIR deck says Phase I was completed in Bihar and Phase II was due to start in 12 States/UTs. Its indicative documents for establishing eligibility include the birth certificate, passport, matriculation certificate and forest rights certificate.
- ECI guidance already instructs that Form 7 applications be scrutinised carefully so they are not used to delete genuine electors. After final publication of rolls, ECI instructions allow deletion only on the basis of a Form 7 or the elector's own deletion request. This is directly relevant to the Mustafabad "ghost Form 7" allegations.
- The ECI has clarified that a Form 6 filed in these circumstances is not by itself a false declaration. It also said no action under Section 31 of the RP Act, 1950 is to be initiated by an ERO merely because the elector was on an earlier roll. This protection applies only if the elector is not already enrolled in another constituency and the declaration is otherwise lawful. It responds to the petitioners' "criminal offence" argument.
Mains dimensions
- Inclusion vs purity: The remedies are procedural patches. Forms are restored under existing Rule 21(1), yet 4.5 crore of 13.37 crore struck-off names are covered, and out-of-State movers and concluded-SIR States are left out. Return via Form 6 as a "new voter" erases the franchise history. The Bengaluru evidence of old EPICs surviving shows the record-keeping is internally inconsistent.
- Burden of proof and citizenship: The SSR promises no proof of citizenship. The "last SIR" matching and document fallback effectively shift the burden onto the elector. Citizenship determination is not an ERO's electoral-roll function and sits uneasily with Article 326's presumption of inclusion.
- Misuse of deletion machinery: Ghost Form 7s (36 of 37 fabricated in Mustafabad) show how an objection mechanism can be weaponised. The safeguards (scrutiny of Form 7, personal notice, 2% cross-verification trigger) need audit and penal follow-through.
- Judicial oversight and timelines: The Supreme Court is acting as a continuing mandamus overseer (28 October observation, 14 November assurance, 2 December review). A 12-day window against 47 lakh ASDD voters raises the question whether procedural fairness is real or notional.
- Federal and political stakes: Bihar and West Bengal have already voted on SIR rolls. This raises questions on the legitimacy of outcomes and on the ECI's accountability and neutrality, which Article 324 independence presumes.
- Way forward: The editorial's proposed fix is to return to the 2002-03 model of door-to-door enumeration at new addresses. Others: restore the old EPIC and record for everyone deleted, legal clarity on "logical discrepancy" flags, transparent ASDD lists, and independent audits of deletions.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has been described as a test of the balance between the purity of rolls and universal adult suffrage. Examine the Election Commission's powers and the safeguards required, with reference to recent Supreme Court interventions."
Related topics
- Article 324 (ECI's powers and independence); Articles 325-326 (single electoral roll, adult suffrage)
- Representation of the People Act, 1950 (rolls, qualifications, Sections 16, 19, 21, 31) vs RP Act, 1951 (conduct of elections)
- Citizenship Act, 1955 and the 1987/2003 amendments (relevant to the documentary "citizenship test" debate)
- Electoral reforms: EPIC–Aadhaar linkage (Form 6B), ECINET, role of BLOs and Booth Level Agents
- Judicial review of ECI action; natural justice in administrative decisions
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 20 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs