Green India Mission launched in 2014 a complete failure, says House panel
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 20 November 2026
Summary
- Parliament's Public Accounts Committee (PAC) criticised the Environment Ministry's "failure" to implement the Green India Mission (GIM), citing a CAG audit report.
- It found that only 5.3% of the area approved for greening had been covered years after the 2018 deadline. The mission's revision in 2021 still had no revised guidelines.
- PAC chairman K.C. Venugopal called the mission a total failure. The audit findings cited show lapses in funding, governance, monitoring and measurement.
Key facts for Prelims
- Green India Mission: one of eight NAPCC missions, under MoEFCC. It was launched in February 2014 and aims at forest and tree cover and ecosystem restoration.
- PAC: 22 members (15 LS + 7 RS), Opposition chair by convention since 1967, appointed by the Speaker. Its basis is the CAG audit report, and it deals with Appropriation and Finance Accounts.
- CAG: Article 148 (office), Article 151 (reports to President/Governor).
- Joint Forest Management Committees (JFMCs): the implementing mechanism for eco-restoration under GIM.
- IISc: conducted the study for the CAG (per the article).
- K.C. Venugopal (Congress) heads the PAC.
- The Aravalli green wall was listed as a priority under the mission (per PAC).
Data and details
- Target: bring 2.8 million hectares under green cover by 2018.
- Achievement: only 5.3% of the area approved by the government had been brought under green cover, seven years after the 2018 deadline.
- The mission was revised in 2021, but revised guidelines have not yet been issued. The PAC asked the government to fix a timeframe for implementation.
- Venugopal: "Nothing has happened under this mission in the last 10 years. It is a total failure." The Ministry could not answer many of the panel's questions.
- The mission failed to work on the Aravalli green wall, a listed priority, while the PAC expressed concern about pollution, especially in Delhi.
- IISc study for CAG: no change at 70% of the sites checked, and only about 10% of the mapped area showed tree cover.
- Saplings were planted inside forests and in a standing paddy field, while scrublands, ravines and old mines were left out.
- Funds: ₹2,400 crore approved for four years, but only ₹1,149 crore received in 10 years (about 48% of the approved sum, by own calculation).
- Governance: the Governing Council, chaired by the Minister, met only twice in 10 years instead of annually.
- No annual report was prepared.
- No social audit was held in 14 of 16 States.
- Carbon captured by the mission was never measured.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Environment: GIM is a climate-linked afforestation and ecosystem-restoration programme. It ties to India's NDC carbon-sink pledge and to land-degradation goals.
- Governance: The PAC examines CAG audit reports, so this case shows how the audit–legislature chain works. CAG audits, the PAC scrutinises the executive, and a Ministry must answer and report action taken.
- Mission-mode design: Missions need money, institutions (a Governing Council), monitoring (annual reports, social audits) and outcome measurement. The CAG findings show lapses on every one.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, climate change mitigation/adaptation, forest cover; GS2 – Parliament: financial committees, accountability of the executive
Background primer
Green India Mission (National Mission for a Green India)
- What it is:
- One of the eight Missions under the National Action Plan on Climate Change (NAPCC). It aims to protect, restore and enhance India's forest cover and respond to climate change through eco-restoration in forest and non-forest areas, using Joint Forest Management Committees.
- Founded:
- Launched in February 2014 to safeguard biological resources and livelihoods against adverse climate change and to recognise the role of forestry in ecological sustainability and food, water and livelihood security. Activities started in FY 2015-16.
- Members:
- it is run by the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change. Its sub-missions are enhancing quality of forest cover, ecosystem restoration and increase in forest cover, urban and peri-urban tree cover, agro-forestry and social forestry, and restoration of wetlands.
- Mandate:
- Increase forest and tree cover by 5 million ha and improve the quality of existing cover on another 5 million ha in 10 years. It also aims to raise forest-based livelihood income of about 3 million households. The 2.8 million ha target cited in the news is the 12th Plan-period phase (1.4 + 1.4 mha) of this 10 million ha goal.
- Why it matters:
- A holistic view of greening that goes beyond tree planting, focused on biodiversity, water and biomass, with carbon sequestration as a co-benefit.
Public Accounts Committee (PAC)
- What it is:
- The parliamentary committee that ensures executive accountability by scrutinising government expenditure and financial management.
- Founded:
- Established in 1921 following the Montagu–Chelmsford Reforms. It became a full parliamentary committee after the Constitution came into force in 1950.
- Members:
- 22 members (15 from Lok Sabha, 7 from Rajya Sabha), elected annually by proportional representation through the single transferable vote. Ministers are not eligible. By convention since 1967, the Chairman comes from the Opposition, and is appointed by the Lok Sabha Speaker.
- Mandate:
- It examines the Appropriation Accounts, Finance Accounts and reports of the CAG. It also evaluates the efficiency, economy and propriety of spending, not only legality.
Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG)
- What it is:
- Head of the Indian Audit and Accounts Department under Article 148 of the Constitution.
Additional context
- Revised GIM roadmap (2025): MoEFCC released a revised GIM plan for 2021–2030 on 17 June 2025 (World Day to Combat Desertification and Drought). It focuses on key areas such as the Aravalli ranges, Western Ghats, Himalayas and mangroves. It includes collaboration with the Aravalli Green Wall project to combat desertification. The PAC's remark about the missing Aravalli green wall should be read against this.
- Climate target link: India aims to create an additional carbon sink of 2.5 to 3 billion tonnes of CO2 through increased forest cover by 2030. The CAG finding that GIM never measured captured carbon is relevant to this target.
Mains dimensions
- Implementation failure: Only 5.3% of the approved area was covered, so the problem is delivery, not design. The causes include a funding shortfall (₹1,149 crore of ₹2,400 crore), a dormant Governing Council (two meetings in 10 years against an annual requirement) and no revised guidelines after 2021.
- Quality of greening: Planting in existing forests and a paddy field while leaving out scrublands, ravines and old mines means the intended degraded land was not restored. IISc found no change at 70% of the sites checked. This shows the gap between sapling counts and ecological outcomes.
- Monitoring and accountability: The absence of annual reports, social audits (none in 14 of 16 States) and any carbon measurement means the mission cannot show it delivers climate benefits. Its stated purpose was carbon-sink creation.
- Link to India's climate commitments: Unmeasured carbon sequestration weakens the credibility of NDC and carbon-sink claims. Meanwhile pollution in Delhi and the missing Aravalli green wall show real costs.
- Institutional role of the PAC: The episode shows the audit–PAC–Ministry accountability loop at work, but PAC findings are advisory and depend on follow-up through Action Taken Reports.
- Way forward: Fix a time-bound action plan and issue the revised guidelines. Ensure assured funding, and run independent third-party and satellite monitoring. Hold social audits through gram sabhas and JFMCs, and measure carbon outcomes.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "The CAG and the Public Accounts Committee have found serious lapses in the implementation of the Green India Mission. Examine the reasons for the gap between the design and delivery of environmental missions in India and suggest reforms."
Related topics
- National Action Plan on Climate Change and its eight missions
- CAMPA, Compensatory Afforestation, National Afforestation Programme
- India's NDC and carbon sink target; Forest Survey of India (ISFR)
- Parliamentary financial committees (Estimates, PUC) and the role of the CAG
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 20 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs