BrainParrot

Shiv Sena row: dissent is not defection, says Shinde faction to SC

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 18 November 2026

Summary

  • Before a Bench of CJI Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, Maharashtra Deputy CM Eknath Shinde and other MLAs argued through senior advocate Dhruv Mehta that dissent is not defection. They said the June 2022 dissenters did not abandon the Shiv Sena but sought to restore its original ideological identity and political alignment.
  • Two connected challenges are being heard. One challenges the Speaker's 2024 decision not to disqualify the Shinde faction's MLAs under the Tenth Schedule. The other challenges the ECI's decision to recognise the Shinde faction as the official Shiv Sena and give it the party symbol. Arguments were inconclusive and resume Wednesday.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Tenth Schedule (anti-defection law), role of the Speaker, ECI and the Symbols Order, judicial review

Key facts for Prelims

  • Tenth Schedule: inserted by the 52nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1985; amended by the 91st Amendment Act, 2003 (deleted the one-third split provision; two-thirds merger retained).
  • Para 2(1)(a): an elected member who wins as a candidate of one party and then joins another is disqualified. Para 2(1)(b): disqualification for voting or abstaining contrary to a party direction.
  • Speaker/Chairman decides defection questions; decision is subject to judicial review (Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu, 1992).
  • Para 5 exempts the Speaker, Chairman and Deputy Chairman from disqualification for giving up party membership on assuming office (and rejoining after).
  • Symbols Order, 1968, Para 15: ECI resolves disputes between rival groups of a recognised party.
  • Subhash Desai (2023): Speaker and ECI may act concurrently; split is no longer a defence; the Speaker must decide the real-faction question independently of the ECI's order.

Data and details

  • Bench: CJI Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana. Counsel for the Shinde faction: Senior advocate Dhruv Mehta.
  • Dissent date: June 2022, against the Uddhav Thackeray-led party leadership.
  • Lead plea: Filed by Sunil Prabhu (Thackeray faction), challenging the Speaker's 2024 decision declining to disqualify the Shinde faction MLAs under the Tenth Schedule.
  • Connected plea: Filed by Mr Thackeray, challenging the ECI's decision recognising the Shinde faction as the official Shiv Sena and allotting it the party symbol.
  • Mehta's submissions: (i) a legislator can oppose the then-leadership's course without ceasing to be a Shiv Sena member; (ii) the disqualification clause can be invoked on confidence or no-confidence votes and matters relating to party programmes; (iii) anti-defection provisions curb defections and horse-trading but do not suppress dissent.
  • Hearing was inconclusive; it resumes on Wednesday.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The Tenth Schedule disqualifies legislators for defection, but it is not meant to punish every disagreement. The argument here is that voting against the party line or opposing the leadership is different from "voluntarily giving up membership".
  • Two separate forums sit side by side: the Speaker (disqualification under the Tenth Schedule) and the ECI (deciding which faction is the party under Para 15 of the Symbols Order). The Supreme Court has said they can proceed concurrently, and that the Speaker must decide the "real faction" question independently of the ECI's order.
  • Core tension: legislature party vs political party. A legislator's loyalty is to the party as defined by its organisation, not only to a majority of MLAs.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Tenth Schedule (anti-defection); Speaker's role as tribunal; ECI's powers under the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968; Judiciary — judicial review.

Background primer

Tenth Schedule (anti-defection law)

What it is:
A Schedule to the Constitution laying down disqualification of MPs and MLAs on grounds of defection. It was inserted by the 52nd Amendment Act, 1985.

Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order, 1968 – Para 15

What it is:
The ECI's order for recognition of parties and allotment of symbols. Para 15 is the provision the ECI uses to decide disputes between rival groups claiming to be the party.

Additional context

  • In Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of Maharashtra (11 May 2023), the Supreme Court held that the Speaker and the ECI can concurrently adjudicate under the Tenth Schedule and Para 15 respectively. It held the "split" defence is no longer available after the deletion of Para 3, and referred the correctness of Nabam Rebia to a seven-judge Bench.
  • The Court held that the political party, not the legislature party, appoints the whip and the leader, and the Speaker must recognise only those duly recognised by the party. It also held that the Speaker cannot rely on the ECI's decision when adjudicating disqualification and must decide independently which faction is the real party. The Court found the Governor's call for a floor test did not follow the law, since he lacked objective material that the government had lost the House's confidence.
  • An editorial explainer on the Speaker's verdict noted that he treated the Shinde faction as the legitimate Shiv Sena on the basis of the party's 1999 constitution, and critics argued that the authority to decide party legitimacy lies with the ECI under Para 15.
  • In September 2023 the Supreme Court directed the Maharashtra Speaker to spell out a timeline for deciding the disqualification petitions, citing its 11 May 2023 direction to decide within a reasonable time.

Mains dimensions

  • Dissent vs defection: Over-broad disqualification can chill legislative dissent and entrench party-leader control. Over-narrow readings can legitimise mass defections. The Court has historically tried to calibrate by tying disqualification to confidence votes and the party's programme (as Mehta argues), but the 2003 deletion of the split clause removed an exit route and closed the "split" defence.
  • Speaker's neutrality: The Speaker is a partisan member and the law sets no timeline for deciding disqualification. The Supreme Court has repeatedly asked Parliament to consider an independent tribunal. It has suggested a permanent tribunal headed by a retired Supreme Court judge or former High Court Chief Justice, which would need a constitutional amendment.
  • Dual forums: Parallel proceedings before the Speaker and the ECI create room for strategic sequencing. The ECI's recognition of a faction can change who controls the party's symbol and funds even as disqualification remains undecided.
  • Federal/political impact: A 2022 defection toppled an elected government. The 2024 Speaker's decision and the ECI's recognition are now before the apex court. The outcome will shape how future intra-party rebellions are treated.
  • Way forward: Time-bound decisions, an independent adjudicator, clearer statutory definition of "voluntarily giving up membership", and a clearer line between organisational and legislature-party control.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "'Dissent is not defection.' Examine this proposition in light of the Tenth Schedule, and discuss whether the Speaker should continue to be the final arbiter in disqualification matters."

Related topics

  • Kihoto Hollohan (1992); Nabam Rebia (2016); Subhash Desai (2023)
  • Role of the Governor in floor tests and government formation
  • Law Commission/Dinesh Goswami Committee recommendations on anti-defection reform
  • ECI's quasi-judicial powers over party recognition and symbols
  • Art. 105/194 (legislative privileges) and Art. 102(2)/191(2) (disqualification)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 18 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs