Elusive peace
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 18 November 2026
Summary
- A lull of about three months in Jammu and Kashmir was broken by violence over six days. On 11 November, a terror attack on a CRPF checkpoint in Akhran, Kulgam, injured three jawans.
- A siege-like anti-terror operation in Kulgam's residential areas, which entered its seventh day on Tuesday, saw the body of a local suspected accomplice of an LeT terrorist found; the operation to track down LeT's Lateef Bhat was still continuing. Two J&K Police Special Police Officers (SPOs) were also found dead in Kishtwar.
- Parties including the ruling National Conference and the PDP criticised prolonged restrictions on civilians. The editorial calls for a political outreach, beginning with restoration of statehood, alongside the security response.
Key facts for Prelims
- J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019: UT of J&K (with legislature) and UT of Ladakh (without); Art. 239A applied to J&K; Assembly cannot legislate on "Police" and "Public Order".
- Special Police Officers (SPOs) are part of the J&K Police.
- CRPF: central paramilitary force under the MHA. Joint operations include the Army's Rashtriya Rifles.
- LeT (Lashkar-e-Taiba): Pakistan-based terror group named in the reports.
- J&K has been a Union Territory since 2019. Assembly elections were held in 2024. Omar Abdullah heads the elected government, with the National Conference (NC) as the ruling party.
- PDP: Peoples Democratic Party, headed by Mehbooba Mufti (former Chief Minister).
Data and details
- A three-month lull was broken by back-to-back incidents over the past six days.
- 11 November: attack on a CRPF checkpoint in Kulgam left three jawans injured.
- 16 November: a local whom police suspected of having joined terror ranks a few days earlier was killed after a six-day siege-like operation in residential areas of Kulgam.
- Two SPOs of J&K Police were found dead with bullet wounds in Kishtwar's forest range a day after being reported missing on 11 November. Police and the Army remain tight-lipped and reports conflict on the circumstances.
- Police say local recruits into terror ranks in Kashmir have come down to single digits (fewer than 10).
- Mehbooba Mufti called the six-day operation collective punishment that breeds alienation and resentment. NC spokesman Imran Nabi Dar said entire villages were kept under prolonged restrictions.
- The Omar Abdullah government has no jurisdiction over the police and is hamstrung.
- Voters' mass participation in the 2024 Assembly elections is cited as the basis for the expectation of statehood restoration.
- The operation entered its seventh day on Tuesday, with frisking of locals, house searches and combing of orchards, especially at the encounter site in the Laroo Bypass area. All entry and exit points were sealed.
- LeT terrorist Lateef Bhat, 22, was believed to be trapped at the site. No exchange of fire was reported on Tuesday till late afternoon.
- The body found was of Umar Nisar Dar, a baker from Kulgam. He was not a listed terrorist, and security agencies suspect he joined Bhat on 11 November for the Akhran checkpoint attack.
- CCTV footage released by security agencies suggests Dar and Bhat were together on 10 and 11 November surveying "potential targets" in Mir Bazar, Akhran, Hablish and Kilam.
- Dar is suspected of being trapped at the Laroo encounter site on Monday.
- Imran Nabi Dar of the NC said agencies have every right to conduct checks but keeping entire villages, including the elderly, under restrictions for days is avoidable.
- Mehbooba Mufti said Akhran Nowpora had virtually been turned into a cantonment and called punishment of an entire population for unidentified militants and possible security lapses unjust.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Under the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019, J&K is a Union Territory with a legislature, but "Public Order" and "Police" remain outside the Assembly's legislative field. The elected government therefore has no control over the police, which is why the editorial says the Omar Abdullah government is hamstrung.
- The editorial makes the classic security-versus-legitimacy argument. Hard security measures can reduce attacks and local recruitment but, if they alienate the local population, they undermine long-term peace. The tools it proposes are political reach-out, restoring statehood and complementary security and political processes.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Internal Security: terrorism and counter-insurgency, role of security forces; GS2 – Polity: Union Territories, Centre-State relations, J&K Reorganisation Act 2019, statehood; GS4 – proportionality and human rights in security operations.
Background primer
Jammu and Kashmir Reorganisation Act, 2019 and the UT framework
- What it is:
- An Act reorganising the former state into the Union Territory of J&K with a legislature and the Union Territory of Ladakh without a legislature.
- Why it matters:
- The Centre's stated aim was integration and security consolidation after the abrogation of Art. 370. Restoration of statehood has been assured by the Centre (including to the Supreme Court) and is now the main democratic demand.
Counter-terror operations in Kashmir (concepts in the news)
Additional context
- Statehood and the Supreme Court: In its December 2023 verdict upholding the abrogation of Art. 370, the Supreme Court directed that J&K Assembly elections be held by 30 September 2024 and that statehood be restored at the earliest. It relied on the Solicitor General's assurance of restoration (Ladakh excluded). The election direction was met in 2024; the source editorial describes statehood as still "much-promised".
- Restoring statehood would require fresh parliamentary legislation amending the J&K Reorganisation Act, 2019 (Arts. 3-4).
Mains dimensions
- Security gains vs. alienation risk: The "iron hand" policy has reduced attacks and local recruitment. The editorial warns that silence on the streets should not be mistaken for peace, and that heavy-handed operations in civilian areas risk fresh psychological scars.
- Proportionality and rights: Prolonged restrictions on entire villages (frisking, house searches, sealing) draw "collective punishment" allegations. Counter-terror operations need to be intelligence-led and minimise civilian burden, which links to Art. 21 and GS4 themes.
- Federal and constitutional gap: Because police and public order sit with the Centre via the LG, the elected government is accountable to voters but lacks control. Statehood restoration would, in the editorial's view, give voters confidence that their 2024 participation matters.
- Changing threat pattern: Hybrid and local recruits, such as a baker not on any list, and hit-and-run checkpoint attacks are harder to pre-empt than organised groups. Both intelligence and community trust matter.
- Unclear incidents: The Kishtwar SPO deaths remain unexplained publicly. The editorial implies that transparency is needed to retain trust.
- Complementarity: The editorial argues that letting J&K's political class establish its writ and giving security agencies room to counter Pakistan-backed terrorism are not contradictory.
- Political reach-out: The Centre should engage all stakeholders, beginning with the much-promised statehood.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "A decline in terror incidents in Jammu and Kashmir should not be mistaken for peace. Examine how security operations and political processes can be made complementary in sustaining normalcy in the Union Territory."
Related topics
- Article 370 abrogation, Art. 3 (reorganisation of States), Supreme Court's December 2023 verdict on Art. 370
- Union Territories: Arts. 239, 239A and 239AA; comparison with Delhi and Puducherry
- Internal security: hybrid militancy, Over Ground Workers, cordon-and-search, role of CRPF/Army/J&K Police; Pakistan-backed terrorism
- Special Police Officers; AFSPA and human rights in security operations
- Community policing and confidence-building measures
Topics: GS3Polity
All current affairs of 18 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs