ECI has no proof that SIR was ‘unanimous’ decision: Rahul
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 17 November 2026
Summary
- Rahul Gandhi told the Supreme Court on Monday that the ECI has produced no primary record showing that all three Election Commission members approved the special intensive revision (SIR). The ECI's counter-affidavit of October 26 had claimed the decision was "unanimous".
- He and other INDIA bloc leaders have also filed an application of "interrogatories" addressed to CEC Gyanesh Kumar and others involved in the SIR.
- Separately, Congress leader Ali Mehdi moved the Supreme Court alleging that "ghost" Form 7 deletion applications are being filed in AC-69 Mustafabad during the ongoing Delhi SIR. The petition says voters marked as dead or shifted are alive and living at their recorded addresses.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections and preparation of electoral rolls vests in the ECI.
- Article 326: A citizen aged 18 or above on the qualifying date and not otherwise disqualified is entitled to be registered as an elector.
- Section 21(3), RP Act 1950: special revision of the roll for reasons recorded. Section 16 disqualifies non-citizens from enrolment. Section 19 covers citizens aged 18+ who are ordinarily resident in the constituency.
- Section 22, RP Act 1950: the Electoral Registration Officer must be satisfied after proper verification before an entry is corrected or deleted.
- Rule 13(2), Registration of Electors Rules, 1960: objection or deletion application must be in Form 7 and made by a person whose own name is on the roll.
- Form 7 requires identification of the applicant, identification of the elector objected to, the specific ground for deletion and a declaration of truth.
- CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: Act No. 49 of 2023, enacted 28-12-2023, in force 2-02-2024. Section 18(2): unanimity as far as possible, otherwise majority.
- Other ECs can be removed only on the CEC's recommendation.
Data and details
- ECI counter-affidavit dated October 26 claimed SIR was a "unanimous" decision.
- Rahul Gandhi's submission: no minutes of meeting, file notings, recorded approvals, agenda, deliberations or other primary material showing participation and approval of all three members came with the affidavit.
- The "interrogatories" ask for the number and details of each SIR file. They also ask for each occasion between February 19, 2025 and October 26, 2026 on which ECs Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi expressed dissent or reservation on SIR, ECINET, Form 6 or the filing of appeals.
- The ECI affidavit denied any difference of opinion between the CEC and the ECs on SIR.
- Gandhi questioned why the affidavit was filed by the ECI as an institution when Gyanesh Kumar, Sandhu and Joshi were separately made respondents.
- Mustafabad petition (Ali Mehdi, through advocate Shariq Ahmed; filed Monday): AC-69, Delhi SIR. A "substantial" number of ghost Form 7s seek deletion on grounds of death, absence and permanent shifting.
- The persons named as filing the Form 7s deny filing or signing them. The petition alleges "phantom objectors".
- 37 applications examined by authorities were found false or fabricated.
- The petition says roll integrity is compromised when an eligible elector is removed on a fact that never existed or an objection nobody made. Counsel submitted that both the objector and the ground for deletion are in serious doubt in Mustafabad.
- Claims are backed by multiple reports in The Hindu.
Static–dynamic linkage
The Election Commission is a constitutional body under Article 324. It controls the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Two questions follow from the news.
- Process: how does a multi-member Commission take decisions? Statute says business is done unanimously as far as possible, and by majority where members differ. The dispute is about the evidence of collective decision-making, not about the power to order SIR.
- Integrity of the roll: the roll is corrected through formal, evidence-based steps (Form 7, ERO satisfaction, a hearing). The Mustafabad plea says these safeguards fail if objections are fabricated.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (Election Commission); Representation of the People Act, 1950; electoral reforms; free and fair elections.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- an autonomous constitutional authority that administers elections to the Lok Sabha, Rajya Sabha, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- constitutional body under Article 324 (set up 25 January 1950). Originally a single-member body, it has been a multi-member body since 1993.
- Why it matters:
- Dr. B.R. Ambedkar argued that the election machinery should be out of the government's control.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of Electoral Rolls
- What it is:
- An intensive revision of the rolls through house-to-house enumeration and verification by Booth Level Officers (BLOs). It differs from summary revisions, which carry the rolls forward without the same degree of verification.
Form 7 / deletion from the electoral roll
- What it is:
- the form for objecting to inclusion of a name or seeking deletion of an entry. It can be filed only by a person whose name is already in that roll.
Additional context
- In Anoop Baranwal (2023) the Supreme Court laid down an interim appointment mechanism of PM, LoP and CJI until Parliament legislated. The 2023 Act replaced the CJI with a Union Cabinet Minister nominated by the PM. The Court noted in May 2026 that this gives the executive a 2:1 majority on the panel.
- On 23 September 2026 a two-judge bench split on the need for a larger bench. It placed the petitions challenging the 2023 Act before the CJI to constitute a Constitution Bench (Article 145(3)).
- In the SIR ruling, the Court ordered the ECI to refer persons deleted on citizenship grounds to the competent authority within four weeks. Voting rights are to be restored if they are found to be citizens.
Mains dimensions
- Institutional independence and collegiality: the demand for minutes, file notings and dissent records tests whether the multi-member Commission works collegially or through the CEC alone. Section 18(2) allows decisions by majority, so "unanimous" is a factual claim that needs a record. The ECI filing one affidavit while all three members are respondents sharpens the question of who answers for the decision.
- Transparency vs institutional privilege: the interrogatories seek details of internal dissent over a specific period. This raises the balance between accountability and the confidentiality of internal deliberation.
- Constitutional power vs procedural fairness: the Supreme Court has accepted the ECI's power to order SIR under Article 324 and Section 21(3). The live issues are therefore how the power is exercised and what evidence supports it.
- Exclusion vs inclusion errors: the Mustafabad petition frames the danger as wrongful deletion of eligible electors, which cuts against franchise under Article 326. Ghost Form 7s turn a protective objection mechanism into a tool for disenfranchisement.
- Safeguards on paper vs in practice: the law requires ERO satisfaction after verification, an objector who is himself an elector, and a declaration of truth. The 37 false applications suggest verification of the objector's identity is the weak link.
- Way forward: disclose decision records in a proportionate way, authenticate Form 7 applicants, publish deletion lists with reasons, and give prompt hearings and restoration to deleted voters.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The credibility of a mass electoral roll revision depends as much on the institutional independence and transparency of the Election Commission as on its constitutional power. Discuss in the light of the controversies over the Special Intensive Revision."
Related topics
- Anoop Baranwal (2023) and the 2023 CEC/EC Act; removal of CEC and ECs
- Articles 324–329 and the RP Acts, 1950 and 1951
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960; Forms 6, 7, 8
- Mohinder Singh Gill (1977) on Article 324
- Citizenship Act and the question of who decides citizenship
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 17 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs