A poverty line that falls short
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 17 November 2026
Summary
- The op-ed argues that India's poverty has clearly fallen over the past decade, but estimates range from about 5% to over 26%. The reason is the choice of poverty line and method, not the data alone.
- It traces the history of poverty-line committees and the data gap after the unpublished 2017-18 survey. It also discusses the rise of multidimensional poverty measures.
- It calls for a new official poverty line, and uses World Bank figures to show that low extreme poverty masks wider insecurity and inequality.
Key facts for Prelims
- Committee sequence: Alagh Task Force (1979, calorie norms) → Lakdawala (State-specific lines and price indices) → Tendulkar (2009, wider consumption basket including health and education) → Rangarajan (higher lines).
- Tendulkar Committee: moved away from the direct calorie method, with a uniform all-India basket and Mixed Reference Period data.
- Rangarajan Committee: separate rural and urban baskets, higher lines.
- MPI measures deprivation in health, education and living standards (sanitation, drinking water, housing). NITI Aayog's national MPI is NFHS-based and uses 12 indicators.
- The global MPI is produced by UNDP and OPHI.
- World Bank international lines (2021 PPP): $3 (extreme poverty), $4.20 (lower-middle-income), $8.30 (upper-middle-income).
- HCES 2022-23 is the first full consumption survey since 2011-12. The 2017-18 consumption survey was never published.
Data and details
- Same country, same year, different yardsticks. At the World Bank's $3 line, 2.6% of Indians were poor in 2022-23. At $4.20, the figure is about 16.1%. Estimates overall range from about 5% to more than 26%.
- SBI Research (2025): inflation-adjusted Tendulkar line gives 7.2% (rural) and 4.6% (urban) for 2022-23. Lines are about ₹1,632 (rural) and ₹1,944 (urban) per person per month.
- Rangarajan and Dev (2014): inflation-adjusted Rangarajan line gives 10.8%.
- Sethu, Surya and Ruthu (2024): rebuilding the Rangarajan method from the latest survey gives 26.4%. Their thresholds are ₹2,515 (rural) and ₹3,639 (urban).
- The "same year" gap is mostly due to line levels ("higher lines, higher poverty") and partly to method: inflating an old line versus rebuilding from the new survey's spending patterns.
- For the World Bank, the $3 figure sits near the low domestic estimates and the $4.20 figure near the high ones.
- Tendulkar put poverty at 21.9% in 2011-12; critics found its thresholds too low. Rangarajan put it at 29.5% for the same year.
- Data gap: the 2017-18 survey was never published and the next full one came in 2022-23. India debated poverty for over a decade without an official consumption-based anchor.
- NITI Aayog MPI: 24.85% (2015-16) → 14.96% (2019-21). The 11.28% for 2022-23 is a projection, not a fresh survey.
- Comparators: World Bank MPI 15.5%; OPHI 16.4% for 2019-21.
- 80% of Indians lived below the $8.3-a-day upper-middle-income line in 2023, even though per capita income per day is more than three times that threshold.
- 30% of Indians still lack access to basic sanitation.
Static–dynamic linkage
- A poverty line is a threshold of consumption expenditure, and the poverty ratio is the share of the population below it. Change the line or the price index and the headcount changes, even for the same year.
- India's measurement has evolved from calorie norms (Alagh, Lakdawala) to a broader consumption basket (Tendulkar) to higher lines (Rangarajan). Each shift moved the numbers.
- Consumption-based lines and multidimensional indices (MPI) capture different things: money-metric deprivation versus health, education and living-standard deprivation. Targeting of welfare schemes and credibility of progress claims depend on the benchmark chosen.
- International lines (World Bank, in PPP dollars) allow cross-country comparison, but they are not built from India's own basic-needs basket.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Economy: inclusive growth, poverty and development measurement; GS1 – Society: poverty and developmental issues; GS2 – welfare schemes and targeting; Prelims – Economy: poverty estimation committees, MPI.
Background primer
Poverty line / poverty estimation committees in India
- What it is:
- A minimum expenditure needed to meet basic socially acceptable needs; the poverty ratio is the share of the population below that line.
- Why it matters:
- A poverty line should track progress against deprivation. Choosing it involves trade-offs between "extreme" and realistic decent-living thresholds.
Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI)
- What it is:
- Measures deprivation across health, education and living standards (sanitation, drinking water, housing), not just consumption.
- Founded:
- The global MPI was launched in 2010 by UNDP and OPHI (Oxford Poverty & Human Development Initiative).
- Mandate:
- To complement consumption-based poverty lines and inform targeted interventions.
World Bank international poverty lines
- What it is:
- $3 per person per day for extreme poverty (low-income countries), $4.20 for lower-middle-income countries, and $8.30 for upper-middle-income countries, all on 2021 PPPs.
- Why it matters:
- A common yardstick for cross-country comparison, but not a basket derived from India's own cost of meeting basic needs (the article's point).
Additional context
- A World Bank Poverty & Equity Brief puts the share below the $4.20/day lower-middle-income line at 57.7% in 2011, falling to 16.1% by 2023, which it says lifted an estimated 496 million people out of poverty. It supplies a 2011 baseline for the article's 16.1% figure.
- NITI Aayog's NFHS-based multidimensional poverty fell from 29.17% (2013-14) to 11.28% (2022-23), which it presents as roughly 24.82 crore people escaping poverty over nine years. The article notes the 11.28% is a projection from earlier trends, not from a fresh survey.
Mains dimensions
- Measurement is political: The same economy yields roughly 5% or over 26% poor depending on the line. A low "extreme poverty" number can coexist with major economic insecurity (the $4.20 line gives about 16.1%).
- Methodological split: The article contrasts "update an old line for inflation" (SBI, Rangarajan and Dev) with "rebuild the line from new consumption data" (Sethu et al.). It also notes that the World Bank's PPP lines are not tied to an Indian basic-needs basket.
- Data gap: The unpublished 2017-18 survey meant a decade-plus without an official consumption anchor. Researchers worked with "assorted lines, price indexes and reconstructed estimates". HCES 2022-23 offers a chance to settle this.
- Beyond consumption: MPI captures health, education and living standards. But the 11.28% figure is a projection, so even the multidimensional headline lacks fresh survey backing.
- Inequality behind the average: 80% below $8.3/day while per capita income is over three times that level points to skewed distribution. 30% without basic sanitation is a service-delivery failure.
- Why it matters for policy: Credible benchmarks are needed to target welfare, evaluate schemes, and decide when an economy aspiring to high-income status has delivered "decent living" to its people.
- Way forward: An official new poverty line built on HCES 2022-23, regular and published consumption surveys, and reporting monetary and multidimensional poverty side by side.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "India's poverty estimates vary widely, from about 5% to over 26%, depending on the poverty line used. Discuss the evolution of poverty measurement in India, the reasons for this divergence, and the case for a new official poverty line alongside multidimensional measures."
Related topics
- Planning Commission/NITI Aayog role in poverty estimation; Tendulkar vs Rangarajan debate
- HCES/NSSO consumption surveys; MPCE; Mixed Reference Period vs Modified Mixed Reference Period
- National MPI (NITI Aayog) and Global MPI (UNDP–OPHI); NFHS
- Inequality indicators (Gini, income distribution); SDG 1 (No Poverty) and SDG 6 (sanitation)
- PPP and international poverty lines (World Bank)
Topics: GS3Economy
All current affairs of 17 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs