Divergent positions mark draft text of COP31 in Turkiye
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 17 November 2026
Summary
- Midway through COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, developing countries asked developed countries to "lead" in reaching net zero by 2030 and net-negative emissions by 2045.
- The draft cover text calls on developing countries to "contribute voluntarily" to climate finance. That blurs the developed/developing line at the heart of the UN climate framework.
- Developing countries also want the EU's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) eliminated by end-2027, and some positions say countries should have no obligation under the Presidency's 35%-electrification-by-2035 goal.
Key facts for Prelims
- COP31 is the 31st Conference of the Parties to the UNFCCC, held in Antalya, Türkiye, from 9–20 November 2026. Türkiye hosts; Australia leads negotiations.
- The UNFCCC was adopted in 1992 and entered into force in 1994. The Kyoto Protocol is 1997 and the Paris Agreement is 2015.
- Net zero means carbon emissions matched by carbon prevented or removed, for example through trees and other technologies the article calls "yet-unproven".
- Net-zero targets: India 2070, China 2060, several developed countries 2050.
- LMDC (Like-Minded Developing Countries, which includes India), the Arab Group, the African Group and the LDCs carry developing-country positions. The EU, UK and Japan carry developed-country positions.
- The US has withdrawn from the Paris Agreement.
- CBAM is the EU's carbon border tariff, primarily affecting steel. It covers iron and steel, aluminium, cement, fertilisers, hydrogen and electricity, and its definitive phase began 1 January 2026.
- The UNFCCC framework draws a clear line between developed countries (historically responsible for most accumulated carbon) and developing ones, who are to be assisted with finance and technology.
Data and details
- Developing-country asks: developed countries to "lead" for net zero by 2030 and net-negative emissions by 2045.
- The draft cover text includes language calling on developing countries to "contribute voluntarily" towards climate finance, described as trillions of dollars needed for adaptation to a fossil-fuel-free era and for losses already caused.
- CBAM ask: developed countries should eliminate such measures by the end of 2027.
- The CBAM mechanism: the article describes it as a tariff protecting European manufacturers, mainly in steel, because EU steel uses fewer emissions per unit than cheaper but dirtier developing-country steel.
- A position that countries "be under no obligation" to meet a goal of 35% of energy use from electricity by 2035. This goal was moved by the COP31 Presidency.
- Timing: halfway through the deliberations.
Static–dynamic linkage
- The UNFCCC rests on differentiated responsibility. Developed countries, historically responsible for most accumulated carbon, are expected to lead on cuts and provide finance and technology. Developing countries are to be supported in avoiding emissions as they grow. This is the principle of common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities (CBDR-RC), and the Paris Agreement carries it forward.
- Paris Agreement Article 9(1) says developed country Parties shall provide finance to developing countries. A "voluntary" contribution by developing countries is not the same as an obligation on developed ones.
- Climate negotiations spill into trade. CBAM is a carbon-linked border tariff, so developing countries see it as a unilateral trade barrier that undermines the differentiation principle.
- Net zero means emissions are balanced by removals or prevention. Countries have pledged different target years: many developed countries 2050, China 2060, India 2070.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: climate change, international conventions and protocols (UNFCCC, Paris Agreement); GS2 – IR: bilateral/multilateral groupings; Prelims – Environment: COP, net zero, CBAM.
Background primer
UNFCCC and the COP
- What it is:
- A multilateral treaty adopted in 1992, shortly after the IPCC's first assessment report in 1990, to stabilise greenhouse gas concentrations at a level preventing dangerous human interference with the climate system.
- Founded:
- It entered into force in 1994 and is the basis for Kyoto Protocol (1997) and Paris Agreement (2015). The first COP was held in Berlin in 1995.
- Members:
- Near-universal membership of states (plus the EU) as Parties to the Convention. The COP host normally rotates among the five UN regional groups (Africa, Asia-Pacific, Eastern Europe, Latin America and Caribbean, Western European and Others).
- Mandate:
- The COP is the governing body of the UNFCCC; Parties meet to review implementation and negotiate climate decisions.
- Why it matters:
- Collective action on a global-commons problem, with differentiated duties (see Section 2).
COP31, Antalya
Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM)
- What it is:
- The EU's instrument to put a carbon price on imports of carbon-intensive goods.
- Why it matters:
- To apply an equivalent cost to foreign producers and prevent "carbon leakage" (relocation to weaker-regulated countries).
Additional context
- The UN says 2026 has seen catastrophic floods, heatwaves and droughts, with scientists confirming the world is on track to exceed the Paris Agreement's 1.5°C threshold.
- Finance backdrop: At COP29 countries agreed a goal of at least $300 billion annually for developing countries by 2035, within a broader ambition of mobilising at least $1.3 trillion annually by 2035.
- The 35% goal in the article matches a Presidency ambition: COP31 presidencies identified 2035 ambitions including electricity at 35% of final energy demand, halving growth of global waste, and cutting building-sector energy intensity by 25%.
- India and CBAM: India's Finance Minister has called CBAM unilateral, arbitrary and a trade barrier. Iron and steel are about 90% of India's CBAM-exposed exports to the EU. India has no nationwide carbon tax, so Indian producers face the full CBAM charge.
- Process: The Leaders' Summit was scheduled for 11–12 November in the first week. The Pre-COP was held on 5–8 October 2026 in Fiji, with a leaders' component in Tuvalu, hosted by Australia with Fiji, Tuvalu and Pacific partners.
Mains dimensions
- Differentiation under strain: Draft language asking developing countries to give "voluntary" finance blurs the developed/developing line that structures the UNFCCC. India and other LMDC members see this as an erosion of CBDR-RC.
- Target-date asymmetry: Developing countries ask developed ones to hit net zero by 2030 and net-negative by 2045, against developed countries' own 2050 pledges. India (2070) and China (2060) have later dates, so the demand shifts the burden of "lead" toward the historically responsible.
- Finance and technology gap: Finance needs run to trillions of dollars, covering both adaptation and loss and damage. Developed-country weakness is visible in the US withdrawal from the Paris Agreement.
- Trade–climate linkage: The demand to end CBAM by 2027 shows climate measures being treated as trade barriers. Steel (cheaper but "dirtier" in developing countries) is the flashpoint, and India is directly exposed.
- Sectoral targets and voluntariness: The Presidency's 35%-electricity-by-2035 goal faces calls for "no obligation". This shows the tension between ambition and national circumstances (energy security, coal dependence).
- Coalitions: LMDC, Arab Group, African Group and LDCs act as a bloc, with the EU, UK and Japan on the other side. India's strategy involves coalition bargaining and its own later net-zero year.
- Way forward for India: Insist on CBDR-RC and predictable public finance. Push for a CBAM carve-out or negotiated relief, for example through the India–EU trade talks. Develop domestic carbon-pricing and low-carbon steel capacity.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Climate negotiations at COP meetings increasingly feature disputes over finance, differentiated responsibilities and unilateral trade measures like CBAM. Examine India's stand and suggest a strategy to protect its developmental interests while contributing to global climate goals."
Related topics
- CBDR-RC; Paris Agreement Articles 4 (NDCs) and 9 (finance); NCQG (new collective quantified goal)
- India's NDCs and net-zero 2070 pledge; Panchamrit
- Loss and Damage Fund; just transition; Global Stocktake
- EU ETS and CBAM; WTO compatibility of border carbon taxes; carbon markets (India's CCTS)
- LMDC, BASIC and other negotiating groupings
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 17 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs