BrainParrot

No road, school or hospital, yet people continue to live in this village inside ...

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 15 November 2026

Summary

  • Around 30 families of Paradeshappana Mutt live inside the Bhadra Wildlife Sanctuary (a Project Tiger area) in Karnataka, near Sirivase in Chikkamagaluru taluk.
  • They have no road, public transport, school, hospital or electricity. Homes are lit only through solar panels donated by private companies in recent years.
  • A senior Forest Department official says the law does not let the department provide roads, electricity or other facilities there, since the area falls under the tiger reserve.
  • The residents are yet to be rehabilitated. The Chikkamagaluru Deputy Commissioner says he will soon convene a meeting with Forest officials.

UPSC relevance: GS3 Environment: Project Tiger, conservation vs forest-dweller rights / GS2 Governance: access to basic services

Key facts for Prelims

  • Project Tiger began in 1973. It is a Centrally Sponsored Scheme.
  • The NTCA is a statutory body created through the 2006 amendment to the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972.
  • Section 38V of the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 deals with the Tiger Conservation Plan and core/critical tiger habitat and buffer areas. Section 38V(5) provides for voluntary relocation.
  • "Critical wildlife habitat" is defined in the FRA, 2006; "critical tiger habitat" is a WPA concept.
  • The NTCA Guidelines, 2012, issued under Section 38O(1)(c) of the WPA, carry the voluntary village rehabilitation package.
  • Voluntary relocation requires informed consent of the Gram Sabha and the affected families. The package is ₹15 lakh per family (raised from ₹10 lakh in 2021).
  • Bhadra Wildlife Sanctuary / Tiger Reserve is in Karnataka (Chikkamagaluru and Shivamogga districts). The article says the sanctuary was notified in 1998.
  • Adi Karnataka is a Scheduled Caste in Karnataka (per the article).

Data and details

  • About 30 families live at Paradeshappana Mutt, near Sirivase in Chikkamagaluru taluk. The Forest Department's management plan counts 20 families there as yet to be rehabilitated.
  • The nearest village for supplies is Bogase, reached on foot or by two-wheeler. Even a bag of salt means a trip there.
  • Electricity is limited to solar panels donated by private companies in recent years.
  • The sanctuary was notified in 1998. It is part of Project Tiger and covers 12 villages identified for rehabilitation.
  • The Forest Department's management plan records that 418 families have been relocated to two centres: M.C. Halli (Tarikere taluk) and Kelagur (Chikkamagaluru taluk).
  • 20 families at Paradeshappana Mutt and 46 more in three other villages are yet to be rehabilitated (66 families in four villages).
  • Livelihood: Yashodamma (about 60) and her son each earn about ₹600 a day working in agricultural fields. She stays on to care for her husband, who has cancer. With no hospital nearby, every medical need means a long journey.
  • A resident in his 70s, Rudraiah, says his parents and their parents were born and buried there: "from time immemorial".
  • Another resident, Mr. Kalaiah, says the place was only recently considered part of the sanctuary. Records call them "forest dwellers".
  • A senior Forest official says the department's hands are tied because the law does not allow roads, electricity or facilities in a tiger reserve.
  • Chikkamagaluru Deputy Commissioner Bhanwar Singh Meena has said he will soon convene a meeting with Forest Department officers.
  • Notable absences: the article does not say whether these families have been offered relocation or have refused it. It does not say whether the village lies in the core/critical habitat or the buffer. It does not say whether FRA claims have been made.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • The legal bind. Under the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, the core or critical tiger habitat is meant to be kept inviolate for tiger conservation. The Forest Department's position is that it cannot extend roads, power or other facilities in such an area. Residents then face a rights-versus-conservation conflict.
  • The intended way out is voluntary relocation. It requires informed consent and a compensation package. If relocation stalls (funding, consent, land), residents remain in limbo: not developed, not rehabilitated.
  • Constitutional hook. This tests Article 21 (life with dignity, access to health and education), the Directive Principle on environment (Article 48A) and the Fundamental Duty in Article 51A(g).

Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: conservation, protected areas, Project Tiger | GS2 – Polity & Governance: forest rights, welfare schemes for vulnerable groups, Gram Sabha consent | GS1/GS2 – Society & Social Justice: Scheduled Castes and forest-dwelling communities

Background primer

Project Tiger and the National Tiger Conservation Authority (NTCA)

What it is:
A conservation programme focused on the tiger in India since 1973. It is run as a Centrally Sponsored Scheme and funds tiger reserves for non-recurring items (such as protection infrastructure, eco-development and village relocation) as well as recurring activities.
Founded:
1973 (Project Tiger). The NTCA became a statutory body through the 2006 amendment to the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972, following the Tiger Task Force (2005, "Joining the Dots").
Members:
Tiger reserves are managed by State Forest Departments, with Field Directors and Chief Wildlife Wardens, under NTCA guidelines. The Field Director submits a Village Relocation Proposal to the NTCA for funding, through the Chief Wildlife Warden.
Mandate:
Ensure tiger conservation through the core–buffer strategy. NTCA guidelines say a viable tiger population needs a minimum inviolate area of about 800–1,200 sq km (about 20 breeding tigresses). Reducing human presence in the core is a key conservation tool.
Why it matters:
Tigers need undisturbed breeding and prey habitat. Keeping the core inviolate reduces disturbance.

Core/critical tiger habitat and voluntary relocation (Section 38V, Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972)

What it is:
Section 38V provides for the Tiger Conservation Plan and the notification of the core/critical tiger habitat and the buffer area of a tiger reserve. The core is to be established as inviolate through voluntary relocation on mutually agreed terms (Section 38V(5)).

Forest Rights Act, 2006 (FRA)

What it is:
Section 4(1) recognises and vests forest rights in Scheduled Tribes and other traditional forest dwellers.
Why it matters:
To correct the "historical injustice" done to forest-dwelling communities by earlier forest settlement.

Bhadra Tiger Reserve

What it is:
A reserve in the Western Ghats region of Karnataka (Chikkamagaluru and Shivamogga districts). It has four hill ranges: Hebbegiri, Gangegiri, Mullayanagiri and Bababudangiri.

Additional context

  • Scale of the national backlog. NTCA meeting minutes (also reproduced in its Annual Report 2020-21) record that about 46,000 families still lived inside tiger reserves. Voluntary relocation was to proceed in phases as funds became available, with roughly ₹6,000 crore estimated as needed.
  • Spending record. ₹577.64 crore was spent on the voluntary village relocation programme between 2014-15 and 2020-21.
  • NCST representations. The National Commission for Scheduled Tribes has forwarded several representations on voluntary village relocation from tiger reserves to the NTCA. In response, the NTCA has reiterated that relocation must be completely voluntary, with informed consent of the Gram Sabha obtained first.

Mains dimensions

  • Conservation vs rights.
  • Tiger conservation needs undisturbed habitat. Residents describe the area as ancestral land that "only in recent years" has been treated as part of the sanctuary.
  • Families with long residence have a claim to basic dignity.
  • Governance gap, not just a legal one.
  • The Forest Department says it is barred from providing facilities.
  • The article does not mention any role for education, health, power or public works departments.
  • The Deputy Commissioner's planned meeting is the first step towards district-level coordination.
  • Voluntary relocation under NTCA guidelines is meant to involve the District Collector and converge other sectors on the community's needs.
  • Slow relocation.
  • 418 families have been moved, but 66 remain across four villages after the sanctuary's 1998 notification.
  • This suggests stalled implementation, perhaps linked to funding, consent or land, though the article does not give reasons.
  • Nationally, the NTCA has acknowledged a large backlog subject to funds (see 2b).
  • Vulnerable population. The majority are Scheduled Caste. At least some depend on daily agricultural wages (about ₹600 a day for Yashodamma and her son), and one family has a cancer patient with no nearby hospital. This raises Article 21 and social-justice concerns beyond the conservation question.
  • Stop-gap philanthropy. Private companies' solar panels light the village. This shows the limits of ad hoc corporate charity in place of rights-based service delivery.
  • Way forward.
  • Have the District Collector, Forest Department and the Gram Sabha settle each family's option: Option I cash or Option II rehabilitation, at the enhanced ₹15 lakh package.
  • Recognise forest rights where claims exist.
  • Provide interim, habitat-compatible services (solar power, mobile health visits, a school linkage) until relocation.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 (Environment) / GS2, 15 marks:** "Voluntary relocation from core tiger habitats is meant to reconcile wildlife conservation with the rights of forest dwellers, yet many families remain in limbo without basic services. Critically examine the legal framework and suggest measures to resolve the dilemma."

Related topics

  • Forest Rights Act, 2006: individual vs community rights, Gram Sabha role, critical wildlife habitat
  • Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972: protected area categories, Sections 38O and 38V
  • Eco-sensitive zones; Tiger Task Force (2005); NTCA guidelines; tiger census
  • Human–wildlife conflict and compensation schemes
  • Article 21 and basic-amenities jurisprudence; Article 48A and 51A(g)
  • National Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy, 2007

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 15 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs