BrainParrot

The struggle for justice is indivisible

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 7 November 2026

Summary

  • The author, a CPI(M) leader, reports on thousands of Adivasi and Dalit families in Madhya Pradesh's Panna and Chhatarpur districts facing displacement because of the Majhgaya dam, the Runjh dam and the Ken-Betwa river-linking project. She alleges violations of R&R law and the Forest Rights Act (FRA), and police repression.
  • Divya Ahirwar, an elected SC-reserved ward councillor jailed since 27 September on a charge the author calls fabricated, has now got bail from the MP High Court. Jai Kisan Sangathan founder Amit Bhatnagar also faced arrest after a long hunger strike.
  • The article links these struggles to the 2 October 2026 Jantar Mantar protest against an alleged assault on voting rights (Art. 326). It argues that both involve the stripping of citizens' rights and that "the struggle for justice is indivisible".

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: constitutional rights, FRA, R&R law; GS3 — Environment: Ken-Betwa, Panna Tiger Reserve; GS2 — Governance and judiciary

Key facts for Prelims

  • FRA 2006, Section 4(5): no eviction of forest dwellers till recognition and verification of rights is complete. Gram Sabha initiates the claims process.
  • RFCTLARR Act, 2013, Section 38: possession of land only after compensation and R&R is paid; R&R for irrigation projects completed six months before submergence.
  • Niyamgiri case (Odisha, Dongria Kondh): the SC upheld the Gram Sabha's role in protecting ancestral Adivasi land from being taken over without its consent (the article cites the case).
  • Wildlife (Protection) Act: provides for voluntary relocation from core tiger-reserve areas (per the article).
  • Ken-Betwa: first project under National Perspective Plan for river interlinking; Ken and Betwa are Yamuna tributaries; Daudhan dam is within Panna Tiger Reserve; Bundelkhand.
  • Article 21: right to life and livelihood. Article 326: elections to the Lok Sabha and Assemblies on the basis of adult suffrage.
  • Chita andolan (funeral-pyre protest) is a protest form used by affected villagers.

Data and details

  • Majhgaya and Runjh dams: medium irrigation projects of the MP government, started over a decade ago and now nearing completion. Hundreds of households, mostly Adivasi, still await fair compensation.
  • Banharikala village: Majhgaya backwaters flooded homes and fields and submerged standing crops. Residents sold cattle and goats at distress prices. The package was initially ₹5 lakh per family and was raised to ₹12.5 lakh as late as December 2025 after sustained protests.
  • Alleged violations:
  • R&R was not completed six months before submergence, despite Section 38(1).
  • An incomplete survey led to underestimated compensation for land, houses and trees.
  • The government refuses to revise the 2018 cut-off date, though implementation came eight years later. Those who were minors in 2018 are now adults but are denied separate entitlements.
  • Scores of families have received nothing. Children have dropped out of school and families are in debt.
  • Protest and repression: the Chita andolan, with slogan "Nyay do ya maar do". The state sent police battalions and cut off electricity. Divya Ahirwar was allegedly dragged and beaten by dozens of police, most of them men, and nearly stripped.
  • Divya Ahirwar: 24-year-old ward councillor, jailed since 27 September on an attempted-murder charge the author calls fabricated; granted bail by the MP High Court at Jabalpur. Amit Bhatnagar (Jai Kisan Sangathan) held a hunger strike lasting several weeks and also faced arrest.
  • Ken-Betwa (article's figures):
  • A 96.7 m (about 317 ft) dam near Daudhan on the Ken; the stated objective is water for Bundelkhand and neighbouring UP.
  • The 2019 Central Empowered Committee (constituted by the SC) questioned whether the Ken has enough water, noted that 6,000 of the 9,000 hectares required are forest land (including a substantial part of the Panna Tiger Reserve), and warned about felling an estimated 2.3 million trees.
  • The case has remained "virtually frozen" in the SC since 2019 while the project moves ahead.
  • The tender went to Hyderabad-based NCC, listed as a BJP electoral-bond donor.
  • Around 8,000 Adivasi families across 22 villages are directly affected. Not a single village has had FRA rights recognised; community forest rights are ignored and gram sabha consent is not obtained. Four villages lie in the core tiger reserve.
  • Displacement from three villages has begun. Resettlement plots are 20 ft × 50 ft stony land with no infrastructure, water or nearby school. Families hold two-inch paper slips with plot numbers and an illegible signature (said to be the Tehsildar's) instead of titles. Within a few months, 10 families got notices to move again because a canal needs the land.
  • The author's national pattern: Simjhali (Odisha), the Santhal Parganas coal belt, Chhatarpur and Panna. Dr. Ambedkar's observation that a Constitution is only as good as those who implement it. The Jantar Mantar protest of 2 October 2026 (against disenfranchisement, Art. 326). Voters labelled "ghuspetias". Justice demanded for Divya, and for Randal Sequeira and Laxmi Naik. Team: CPI(M) and Adivasi Adhikar Rashtriya Manch.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • A development project can take land only within a legal framework. The RFCTLARR Act, 2013 requires R&R to be completed before displacement, and the FRA requires recognition of forest rights and gram sabha involvement before eviction from forest land.
  • Where these statutory safeguards are skipped, the dispute becomes a question of Article 21 (life, livelihood, dignity) and of the rule of law in project implementation.
  • The Ken-Betwa project is also a test case for India's river-interlinking programme in a protected area, and for how courts handle environmental cases that stay pending while projects move on (a "fait accompli").
  • The author's analogy (Art. 326 voting rights and Art. 21 life rights) frames both as questions of citizenship, a rhetorical position the notes should treat as the author's argument.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: fundamental rights (Art. 21, Art. 326), tribal rights and welfare laws (FRA 2006, RFCTLARR 2013); GS3 – Environment: river-linking, protected areas; GS2 – Judiciary

Background primer

Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (RFCTLARR) — Section 38

What it is:
A central law that regulates land acquisition and R&R of affected families. It was passed by Parliament in September 2013, came into force in January 2014 and replaced the colonial Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
Why it matters:
No displacement before rehabilitation, and compensation and R&R as legal entitlements.

Forest Rights Act, 2006 (FRA) — Section 4(5)

What it is:
The Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006. It aimed to undo the historical injustice to forest-dwelling communities under colonial and post-colonial forest management.
Why it matters:
Secure and inalienable rights over forest land and resources as a basis for livelihood and conservation.

Ken-Betwa Link Project (KBLP)

What it is:
The first project under the National Perspective Plan for interlinking rivers; it transfers water from the Ken to the Betwa, both tributaries of the Yamuna.
Why it matters:
The National Perspective Plan (prepared in 1980) aims to transfer water from surplus to deficit basins. Bundelkhand is chronically drought-prone.

Additional context

  • The Environment Ministry's approval of the project is reported to carry conditions including planting of 2.5 million trees as compensatory afforestation and radio-collaring to monitor tigers and leopards.
  • An April 2025 Wildlife Institute of India report reportedly showed prey density at 6 animals per sq km, well below the ideal 30–60.
  • Per PIB, the Daudhan reservoir would submerge about 9,000 ha, including 4,141 ha of the Panna Tiger Reserve core and 1,314 ha of its buffer.

Mains dimensions

  • Statutory non-compliance: Failure to complete R&R six months before submergence (Section 38), freezing the 2018 cut-off date after eight years, and denying adult-child entitlements are legal violations, not policy gaps.
  • FRA and consent: Recognition of rights must precede eviction (Sec. 4(5)). Zero villages having recognised rights, and no gram sabha consent, contradict Niyamgiri and the Act. In core tiger areas, relocation must be genuinely voluntary.
  • Quality of resettlement: Plots of 20×50 ft without services, paper-slip titles and re-displacement for a canal show a failure of "land-for-land" rehabilitation and have livelihood and education costs.
  • Judicial delay: The 2019 CEC findings and a case frozen in the SC while construction proceeds illustrate how delay can create a fait accompli. This has implications for access to justice.
  • Environment vs. development: Hydrological viability of the Ken, felling of about 2.3 million trees, submergence of forest and tiger habitat, and sacred groves. Compare with river-linking claims on drought relief in Bundelkhand.
  • Repression and rights: Arrests of a Dalit woman councillor, police violence and electricity cut-offs raise issues of police accountability, protest rights (Arts. 19, 21) and gendered violence. These are the author's allegations, so a balanced answer should note the State's likely counter-position.
  • Governance and probity: The electoral-bond donor link to the tender winner raises the question of crony capitalism and transparency in procurement. It is an allegation in an opinion piece and should be flagged as such in answers.
  • Way forward: Pause displacement till FRA rights and R&R are complete, revise cut-off dates, independent review of Ken-Betwa's hydrology and ecology, time-bound judicial hearing, proper land titles, and social audits.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "Development-induced displacement of tribal communities often violates the statutory safeguards in the Forest Rights Act, 2006 and the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. Critically examine this with reference to recent river-project conflicts in Central India."

Related topics

  • PESA Act, 1996; Fifth Schedule; role of Gram Sabha
  • Environment Impact Assessment and Social Impact Assessment
  • National River Linking Project and National Perspective Plan
  • Project Tiger, Critical Tiger Habitat and Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972
  • Article 21 jurisprudence on livelihood; Article 326 and electoral roll revision

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 7 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs