Helping hand
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 5 November 2026
Summary
- Cyclones Arnab (landfall 28 October) and Murasu (3 November) hit the Andhra Pradesh coast, and southern Odisha was also affected by the first. Preparedness and a swift response kept casualties low.
- The editorial argues for stronger crop-loss compensation, a better PMFBY, central help for permanent restoration, and more science-institution collaboration with governments.
- It also says the Centre should act in the spirit of "cooperative federalism".
Key facts for Prelims
- NDRF/SDRF are established under the Disaster Management Act, 2005.
- 15th Finance Commission windows in NDRF/SDRF: response and relief 40%, recovery and reconstruction 30%, preparedness/capacity building 10%.
- PMFBY was launched in 2016. Farmer premium caps are 2% (Kharif), 1.5% (Rabi) and 5% (commercial/horticultural), with the balance shared equally by Centre and states.
- PMFBY has been voluntary for all farmers since 2020. Cover includes post-harvest losses for crops left to dry for up to 14 days.
- YES-TECH and CROPIC are PMFBY tools for yield estimation and crop-health verification.
- Cooperative federalism: the Centre and states work together, which includes fiscal transfers.
Data and details
- Arnab (landfall 28 October): damage in Andhra Pradesh estimated at about ₹4,526 crore. It also damaged nearly 90,000 hectares of standing crops in southern Odisha.
- Murasu (landfall 3 November): initial estimates show about 52,500 hectares of standing crops affected.
- Andhra Pradesh reports seven deaths from the two cyclones.
- Comparison, Cyclone Hudhud (October 2014): 63 deaths and damage of nearly ₹22,000 crore.
- Personnel from Karnataka, Telangana and Tamil Nadu helped rescue efforts.
- After a preliminary on-the-spot assessment, the Union government is expected to release the first instalment to affected states soon.
- PMFBY was launched a decade ago, but the editorial says it has not given farmers comprehensive cover.
- Policy points: the Centre's initial stand was that NDRF/SDRF were for relief, not recovery. It added recovery and reconstruction two years ago after the 15th Finance Commission's nudge.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Disaster response in India is run by states with central support. Money flows through the NDRF/SDRF windows recommended by the Finance Commission.
- Historically, funds covered only response and relief. Recovery and reconstruction came late, after the 15th Finance Commission's recommendation.
- Crop insurance (PMFBY) is the main risk-transfer for farmers. If it is not comprehensive, the burden falls back on the state and on farmers.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment/Disaster management (Disaster Management Act, 2005; NDMA/SDMA; disaster financing). GS3 – Agriculture: crop insurance and farm-income stabilisation. GS2 – Federalism: Centre-State fiscal relations (Finance Commission grants).
Background primer
NDRF / SDRF and the 15th Finance Commission
- What it is:
- The National and State Disaster Response Funds, set up under the Disaster Management Act, 2005, to pay for relief after notified disasters. Notified calamities include cyclone, drought, earthquake, fire, flood, tsunami, hailstorm, landslide, avalanche, cloudburst, pest attack and frost/cold wave.
Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY)
- What it is:
- A crop insurance scheme. It was launched in 2016 to give farmers a simple, affordable and comprehensive crop insurance product. It replaced NAIS and MNAIS from Kharif 2016.
Additional context
- PIB says ₹12,200 crore is allocated to PMFBY for 2026–27. PMFBY is being implemented by 25 States/UTs in Kharif 2026.
- PIB reports over 92.46 crore farmer applications insured since inception, with claims exceeding ₹2.06 lakh crore paid on over 26.33 crore applications.
- A World Bank review for the 16th Finance Commission found that the NDRF remained focused on short-term recovery, with limited use for long-term reconstruction.
Mains dimensions
- Preparedness pays:
- Seven deaths against 63 in Hudhud (2014), and damage of about ₹4,526 crore for Arnab against roughly ₹22,000 crore for Hudhud.
- The editorial credits the Real Time Governance Society (RTGS) and other technologies with reducing casualties and damage, so technology-enabled early warning and coordination matter.
- Caveat: the two events are not like for like, and Murasu's damage is still being assessed.
- Cooperative federalism in action: Karnataka, Telangana and Tamil Nadu sent personnel to help Andhra Pradesh. Money, however, still depends on central assessment and release, so timely first instalments matter.
- Disaster financing gap:
- The R&R window exists, but the editorial asks the Centre to give extra assistance when public infrastructure is badly damaged.
- It should also fund permanent restoration, not just relief.
- Risk: a World Bank review for the 16th Finance Commission found NDRF support stayed focused on short-term recovery, with limited use for long-term reconstruction.
- Agriculture and insurance:
- The editorial's figures (about 90,000 hectares in southern Odisha from Arnab and about 52,500 hectares from Murasu in initial estimates) add up to roughly 142,500 hectares of standing crops affected. The sum is the note's own, and Murasu's figure is still preliminary.
- PMFBY must be improved so that all farmers join, states should raise awareness and top up benefits, and a compensation framework for crop loss is needed.
- Science-government collaboration: As disasters become more frequent, higher-learning institutions (science and technology) should work with central and state agencies.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Preparedness reduced casualties in the recent cyclones on the east coast, yet farmers and states still bear heavy losses. Examine the adequacy of India's disaster financing and crop insurance framework and suggest reforms."
Related topics
- Disaster Management Act, 2005; NDMA, SDMA and NDRF (the force)
- Finance Commissions and Centre–State transfers
- PMFBY vs the Restructured Weather-Based Crop Insurance Scheme
- Early warning systems and IMD cyclone forecasting
- Cooperative federalism; Doctrine of "cooperative and competitive federalism"
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 5 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs