BrainParrot

How the Supreme Court shaped due process in death penalty cases

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 4 November 2026

Summary

  • A former Supreme Court judge uses the Day Against the Death Penalty (Oct 10) to trace how the safeguards from Bachan Singh (1980) have fared over four decades.
  • He argues that individualised sentencing and the State's duty to prove that reformation is impossible are the conditions on which the death penalty is constitutional.
  • He notes that the Supreme Court has recently moved from the crime to the fairness of the sentencing procedure. Trial-court practice has barely changed, and high acquittal rates show the investigative system is error-prone.

UPSC relevance: GS2 Polity — Judiciary, fundamental rights (Art. 14/21), criminal-justice reform; GS4 (ethics of punishment)

Key facts for Prelims

  • Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980): Constitution Bench; upheld the death penalty; life imprisonment is the rule and death the exception; "special reasons" are required.
  • Section 354(3) CrPC, now Section 393(3) BNSS, 2023: "special reasons" are needed for a death sentence.
  • Test: death only where life imprisonment is "unquestionably foreclosed". Individualised sentencing weighs the crime and the criminal.
  • The burden is on the State to prove, by evidence, that the probability of reformation does not exist.
  • Machhi Singh (1983) shifted the inquiry towards the crime. The court itself acknowledged this in Sangeet v. State of Haryana (2013).
  • Ravji v. State of Rajasthan (Dec 1995, two-judge Bench) held that the nature and gravity of the offence, not the circumstances of the criminal, decides punishment. Santosh Kumar Bariyar v. State of Maharashtra (2009) held that it was decided in ignorance of Bachan Singh. Bariyar also clarified that life imprisonment is "unquestionably foreclosed" only when reformation is unachievable.
  • Manoj v. State of MP (2022): "practical guidelines" requiring the State to produce mental-health evaluations, reports on conduct in custody and a probation officer's report.
  • Vasanta Sampat Dupare v. Union of India (2025): a sentencing hearing compliant with Manoj flows from Articles 14 and 21. A death sentence without it is unconstitutional and can be reopened even after finality.
  • Waris v. State of MP (Sept 2026): conviction for rape and murder of a child upheld, but death commuted because the State led no evidence to exclude reformation.
  • The 262nd Law Commission Report (2015) championed reformation as a goal in death penalty cases.
  • A suo motu writ petition on the defence's right to a real and meaningful opportunity to present sentencing material has been referred to a Constitution Bench.

Data and details

  • A nationwide study of 306 death sentences (2018–2020) found 36.1% were pronounced on the same day as conviction and 18.4% on the next day. In most cases the defence neither argued nor presented mitigation evidence.
  • In 2025, trial courts sentenced 128 people to death. In 95.18% of cases where compliance could be assessed, the Manoj procedure was not followed.
  • Over the past decade, nearly one-third of death sentences decided by High Courts and the SC ended in acquittals.
  • In 2025 alone, the SC acquitted the accused in 10 of the 19 death penalty cases it decided, repeatedly noting seriously flawed investigations and prosecutions.
  • In Dupare the SC acknowledged that investigations often rest on "confessions extracted in opacity" and forensic material "of doubtful rigour".
  • Ravji was hanged in May 1996 and Surja Ram in April 1997. Bariyar (2009) noted that Ravji had been followed in at least six other death-sentence cases.
  • In 2012, 14 retired judges called the two executions "the gravest known miscarriage of justice" in independent India.
  • Bachan Singh itself warned that "Judges should never be bloodthirsty."

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Capital punishment is constitutionally valid, but only if the procedure is fair, just and reasonable under Art. 21 and non-arbitrary under Art. 14.
  • Life imprisonment is the rule and death is the exception, which needs "special reasons" in the judgment.
  • Sentencing is a separate stage from conviction. The court must consider the criminal's circumstances (age, mental state, reform potential) as well as the crime.
  • That makes the quality of the sentencing hearing the decisive safeguard against arbitrary and irreversible punishment.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Judiciary; fundamental rights (Art. 14, 21); GS2 – Governance: criminal-justice system reform. Essay/GS4: retribution vs reformation.

Background primer

Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) and the "rarest of rare" doctrine

What it is:
a Constitution Bench judgment that upheld the death penalty's constitutional validity but imposed conditions. These are guidelines for exercising judicial discretion, and the "rarest of the rare" formulation comes from this case.

Mercy powers (related)

Additional context

  • The Law Commission's 35th Report (1967) supported retaining the death penalty. Its 262nd Report (2015) recommended abolition for all crimes except terrorism-related offences and waging war against the State.
  • In Santosh Kumar Bariyar (2009), the SC said courts must give clear evidence explaining why a convict is unfit for reform or rehabilitation. The 262nd Report called this evidence requirement essential for objectivity in sentencing.

Mains dimensions

  • Doctrinal drift: Bachan Singh required special reasons for death, but Machhi Singh in effect asked for reasons to prefer life. Ravji went further and made the crime alone decisive. Two men were hanged on a principle the SC later called contrary to binding law (Bariyar, 2009).
  • From "rarest of rare" to process rights: the SC now treats a meaningful sentencing hearing as part of Art. 21. This is a procedural safeguard model (Manoj → Dupare), and it makes finality subject to review for defective hearings.
  • Implementation gap: the 2025 data (128 sentences, 95.18% non-compliance) and the 2018–20 study (same-day and next-day sentencing) show trial courts still do not apply the law.
  • Systemic fallibility: acquittals in roughly a third of cases, and in 10 of 19 SC cases in 2025, show flawed investigation, coerced confessions and weak forensics. An irreversible punishment is being decided in a system prone to error.
  • Reformation vs retribution: the State bears the burden of showing reformation is impossible (Waris). Gravity alone cannot foreclose life imprisonment. Public anguish at brutal crimes cannot override legal reasoning, as Ravji shows.
  • Way forward: enforce Manoj through trial-court training, mitigation investigation and probation reports, and reform investigation and forensic standards. The pending Constitution Bench will settle the defence's right to present sentencing material.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks:** "The 'rarest of rare' doctrine was meant to make the death penalty an exception, yet sentencing practice remains inconsistent. Critically examine how the Supreme Court's procedural safeguards since *Bachan Singh* have sought to secure due process in capital sentencing."

Related topics

  • Articles 14, 21, 72 and 161 (mercy powers); the curative petition
  • BNSS 2023 sentencing provisions; Section 235(2) CrPC hearings
  • Law Commission of India reports (35th, 262nd) on capital punishment
  • Fair trial, forensic reform and police investigation reforms
  • Reformative vs retributive theories of punishment (GS4/Essay)

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 4 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs