BrainParrot

PACs ensure efficient use of public money: Om Birla

GS2Full notePublished:

Source: The Hindu, 4 November 2026

Summary

  • At a two-day conference of PAC chairpersons from 25 States hosted by the Keralam Assembly, Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla praised the convention of an Opposition Member chairing the PAC. He urged technology, data analytics and AI to clear delays, with some reports pending for 15–20 years.
  • Keralam CM V.D. Satheesan said legislatures cannot bar PAC scrutiny of CAG reports, and criticised CAG's methodology. PAC chair K.C. Venugopal asked the CAG to audit more, especially flagship schemes.
  • Separately, Venugopal flagged the absence of six States' chief secretaries at a recent PAC meeting on scholarships for SC students, and asked the Speaker to intervene.

UPSC relevance: GS2 Polity — Parliamentary committees, legislative oversight, federal legislatures; CAG

Key facts for Prelims

  • PAC: oldest parliamentary committee (1921); 22 members (15 LS + 7 RS); one-year term; no minister can be a member; Chair appointed by the LS Speaker from the Opposition since 1967.
  • Constituted under Rule 308 of the Lok Sabha Rules of Procedure.
  • Three parliamentary financial committees: PAC, Estimates Committee, Committee on Public Undertakings.
  • PAC examines Appropriation Accounts, Finance Accounts and CAG audit reports. CAG assists it.
  • Article 148: CAG. Article 151: CAG reports to the President/Governor. Article 115: supplementary, additional or excess grants.
  • PAC recommendations are advisory.
  • State legislatures have their own PACs. The conference involved PAC chairpersons from 25 States.
  • Setting: Keralam Assembly, Thiruvananthapuram; Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman Harivansh also attended.

Data and details

  • Conference: two days, PAC chairpersons from 25 States, hosted by the Keralam Assembly.
  • Birla: PAC reports are sometimes pending for 15–20 years. He urged technology, data analytics and AI to analyse expenditure data, spot trends, detect financial irregularities and monitor audit observations.
  • Keralam CM V.D. Satheesan: a legislature has no power to exclude a tabled CAG report from PAC scrutiny, and doing so is an "unhealthy parliamentary practice". He also said CAG's methodology often defeats the purpose of an audit. As his example, the 2010 CAG report on 2G spectrum estimated a loss of ₹1.76 lakh crore by extrapolating revenue from later benchmarks rather than actual market conditions.
  • Venugopal: the CAG should increase the number of audits and focus on flagship schemes such as Jal Jeevan Mission and Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana.
  • Venugopal's complaint: chief secretaries of six States were absent when called to give oral evidence on scholarships for Scheduled Caste students. He said this denied the committee a chance to examine shortcomings and secure corrective action, and urged the Speaker to intervene.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • India's financial accountability runs from the CAG audit through the PAC to Parliament or the legislature. The executive spends public money only with legislative sanction, and the legislature checks that it was spent as sanctioned.
  • The PAC's effectiveness depends on timely CAG reports, executive cooperation (appearance of senior officials, action-taken reports) and the chair's independence, which is why the chair traditionally comes from the Opposition.
  • The conference shows concern about delays, boycotts by officers and disputes about how CAG findings are treated.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Parliament and State legislatures — structure, functioning, powers; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability; GS2 – Constitutional bodies: CAG.

Background primer

Public Accounts Committee (PAC)

What it is:
a Parliamentary financial committee that audits government expenditure. It plays a crucial role in executive accountability to the legislature. It checks that public funds are used legally, efficiently and for the purposes approved by Parliament.
Founded:
introduced in 1921 following the Government of India Act, 1919 (Montford Reforms). It became a Parliamentary Committee under the Speaker's control in 1950.
Members:
22 members (15 from Lok Sabha, 7 from Rajya Sabha), elected annually through proportional representation by single transferable vote. Ministers are ineligible, and the term is one year. It is constituted every year under Rule 308 of the Lok Sabha Rules of Procedure.
Mandate:
examines the Appropriation Accounts, Finance Accounts and CAG reports. It evaluates efficiency, economy and propriety, not only legality. It examines excess spending, which is later regularised under Article 115.
Why it matters:
Parliament's control over the executive's purse. The CAG is described as its "friend, philosopher, and guide".

Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG)

Additional context

  • K.C. Venugopal was reappointed chairman of the Parliamentary PAC for the 2026–27 term.
  • The government generally submits action-taken notes on PAC recommendations within about six months. The Audit Para Monitoring System (APMS), introduced on the PAC's recommendation, tracks Action Taken Notes/Replies and helps reduce pendency.
  • The Kerala government's conference note gave the theme as "Audit, Accountability and Good Governance – The Evolving Role of the Public Accounts Committee". It said the first PAC was constituted in 1933 in the Travancore Legislative Assembly. It said the Opposition-chair convention was first implemented in the Kerala Legislative Assembly in 1957. Uttar Pradesh's official site separately claims the convention there dates from 1948, before the Lok Sabha adopted it in 1967.
  • Under Article 151(2), State PACs mainly examine the CAG audit reports submitted to the Governors of the States.

Mains dimensions

  • Opposition chair as accountability design: Birla calls the convention a sign of maturity and inclusiveness. It is a convention, not a constitutional or statutory rule, so its strength depends on political practice.
  • Delays and pendency: reports pending 15–20 years weaken the audit–PAC–action-taken chain. Remedies suggested are technology, data analytics and AI, plus Action Taken monitoring (e.g. APMS).
  • CAG–PAC relationship: Satheesan wants a serious discussion on how PACs treat CAG findings. His 2G example shows contested audit methodology (extrapolation and notional loss). Venugopal wants more audits focused on flagship schemes. The tension is between CAG's independence and methodological rigour on the one hand, and legislative review on the other.
  • Executive non-cooperation: absence of six chief secretaries on a social-justice scheme (SC scholarships) shows the limits of the PAC's leverage. Its recommendations are advisory, so it relies on the presiding officer's intervention to secure officials' cooperation.
  • Federal dimension: a conference of 25 States' PAC chairs promotes shared best practices across legislatures. Each State PAC works under its own legislature's rules.
  • Way forward: firm timelines for ATNs, stronger mechanisms to ensure officials' appearance, expert support and capacity building, publicly accessible follow-up trackers, and consultative engagement with the CAG.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 10 marks:** "Examine the role of the Public Accounts Committee in ensuring legislative financial oversight. What measures are needed to make PACs in Parliament and State legislatures more effective?"

Related topics

  • Parliamentary committees (financial, standing, ad hoc) and their powers
  • CAG: Articles 148–151, CAG's (DPC) Act 1971, audit types
  • Budget process: Appropriation, Finance Accounts, excess grants (Art. 115, 116)
  • Jal Jeevan Mission, PMAY and post-matric scholarships for SCs
  • Speaker's role and the office of the Presiding Officer

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 4 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs