What is the role of Legislative Councils?
Published:
Source: The Hindu, 3 November 2026
Summary
- Elections to 28 Legislative Council seats were held last week in Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra and Karnataka. Political exchanges afterwards, including the PM's remarks, drew attention to what Councils do.
- In Bihar, two Independent MLCs, Bansidhar Brajwasi and Rahul Raj, "joined" the BJP on October 31 and then denied it hours later, saying they had only offered support. NDA partner JD(U) asked the BJP to explain, and the Jan Suraaj Party sought their disqualification under the anti-defection law.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 168: provides for the constitution of State legislatures. Per the article, Maharashtra, Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana and Karnataka have Legislative Councils.
- Article 169: Parliament may create or abolish a Council by ordinary law if the Assembly passes a resolution to that effect by a special majority (two-thirds of members present and voting, and a majority of total membership).
- Article 171: maximum one-third of Assembly strength, minimum 40; composition ratios as above.
- Article 172: not subject to dissolution; six-year term; one-third retire every two years.
- Legislative procedure: no joint sitting; the Assembly's version prevails; the Council can only delay a bill by up to four months.
- GoI Act, 1935 provinces with Councils: Madras, Bombay, Bengal, UP, Bihar, Assam. Council members had 9-year terms with one-third retiring every three years; a joint sitting broke deadlocks after 12 months.
- Tenth Schedule: added by the 52nd Amendment, 1985; an Independent joining a party after election is disqualified; the presiding officer decides, subject to judicial review.
- Article 191(2): a Council member is disqualified if disqualified under the Tenth Schedule.
- Second Administrative Reforms Commission, report on Local Governance (2007).
Data and details
- 28 Council seats went to polls last week in four States (UP, Bihar, Maharashtra, Karnataka).
- BJP leaders celebrated winning four seats in Karnataka Council polls on October 28 (photo caption).
- Tamil Nadu Council: abolished in 1986 under M.G. Ramachandran; Assembly resolution for revival in 2010 under M. Karunanidhi; resolution against revival in 2011 under J. Jayalalithaa. Andhra Pradesh Council: abolished in 1985 under N.T. Rama Rao; recreated in 2007.
- Second ARC proposal: a "Council of local governments" in all States, with members elected only by local body representatives, since higher literacy makes separate graduate and teacher electorates unnecessary.
- Bihar details:
- Brajwasi beat JD(U)'s Abhishek Jha from Tirhut Graduates' seat.
- Raj beat JD(U)'s Anand Pushkar from Saran Teachers' seat.
- Raj had earlier been expelled from the BJP for six years.
- Both said they only offered support and had not joined, hours after "joining" on October 31.
- Jan Suraaj Party (Prashant Kishor) won one of the eight seats that went to the polls; its delegation met Council Chairman Ram Bachan Rai.
- JD(U) Bihar president Umesh Singh Kushwaha called the BJP's move a matter of "unity" within the NDA. JSP leader Kishor Kumar Munna said the two joined in "less than 72 hours" after winning.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Councils are the "upper house" at State level, but they are weaker than the Rajya Sabha: they have no joint-sitting mechanism and can delay a bill for only four months.
- The Bihar episode tests the Tenth Schedule: an Independent member is disqualified if they join a party after being elected. The decision lies with the presiding officer (the Council Chairman), subject to judicial review.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 — Polity: State legislature (Articles 168–173), Legislative Council powers; Tenth Schedule and anti-defection law; GS2 — Governance: Second ARC on local governance.
Background primer
Legislative Council (Vidhan Parishad)
- What it is:
- The upper house of a bicameral State legislature, a revising chamber meant to check hasty legislation by the Assembly.
- Founded:
- The Government of India Act, 1935 introduced bicameral legislatures in six provinces (Madras, Bombay, Bengal, United Provinces, Bihar, Assam), with restricted franchise. The Constituent Assembly debated it at length: supporters saw a check and balance, critics saw a burden on the exchequer.
- Members:
- The maximum strength is one-third of the Assembly, with a minimum of 40. Election pattern: one-third by local bodies, one-twelfth by graduates, one-twelfth by teachers, one-third by MLAs, and one-sixth nominated. Under Article 172 the Council is not subject to dissolution; members serve six years, with one-third retiring every two years.
- Mandate:
- Review and delay legislation. Ministers, including the Chief Minister, can come from the Council. Under Article 169, Parliament may create or abolish a Council by ordinary law after the Assembly passes a resolution by a special majority.
- Why it matters:
- A deliberative second chamber and a voice for local bodies, teachers and graduates, though in practice its creation and abolition have been driven by politics.
Tenth Schedule (Anti-Defection Law)
- What it is:
- Added by the 52nd Amendment Act of 1985 to curb political defections by legislators.
Additional context
- In Keisham Meghachandra Singh v. Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly (2020), the Supreme Court said Speakers must decide disqualification petitions within a reasonable time, with an outer limit of three months. It also recommended an independent, permanent tribunal in place of the Speaker.
- In Padi Kaushik Reddy v. State of Telangana (2025), the Supreme Court criticised delay by the Telangana Speaker and directed disqualification proceedings to conclude within three months of 31 July 2025. It urged Parliament to revisit the Speaker's role in such decisions.
- The Tenth Schedule itself sets no legally binding time limit for the presiding officer's decision, which allows strategic delay.
- The Tenth Schedule's merger exception allows a party to merge with another if at least two-thirds of its legislators agree. It protects mergers, not an Independent who joins a party.
Mains dimensions
- Weak but not irrelevant: Councils have limited legislative powers (a four-month delay at most), yet they allow experts and special constituencies a voice and give ministers a route that avoids direct polls.
- Politics of creation and abolition: Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh show how Councils are abolished or revived when a new government comes in. This undercuts the "revising house" rationale.
- Second ARC reform: Turning Councils into "councils of local governments" could strengthen local self-government (73rd/74th Amendments) and make the second chamber distinctive. The explainer's author argues the alternative is abolishing them in the six States.
- Anti-defection in practice: The Bihar "joined, then denied" episode shows how a party can claim an Independent's support without a formal joining. Whether the Tenth Schedule applies depends on proof of joining a party, which makes the presiding officer's role critical. Delay or partisanship in deciding such petitions weakens the law.
- Coalition management: JD(U)'s public query to the BJP, and the earlier expulsion of Raj, show friction inside the NDA even in a graduates' or teachers' constituency.
- Way forward: Time-bound decisions on disqualification (the Court has set an outer limit of three months), a possible independent tribunal for defection disputes, and a clearer role for Councils.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Legislative Councils are often described as an 'ornament' in State legislatures. Discuss their constitutional framework and role, and evaluate the Second ARC's suggestion of making them 'councils of local governments'."
Related topics
- Rajya Sabha vs Legislative Council (powers, money bills)
- Tenth Schedule: grounds, merger exception, presiding officer's role, Kihoto Hollohan and Keisham Meghachandra
- 73rd and 74th Amendments (local bodies); Second ARC reports
- Governor's nominations (Article 171(5)) and MLC elections
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 3 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs