Opposition flays BJP day after Independent MLCs ‘join’ ruling party in Bihar
Source: The Hindu, 2 November 2026
Summary
- Two Independents newly elected to the Bihar Legislative Council, Bansidhar Brajwasi (Tirhut Graduates') and Rahul Raj (Saran Teachers'), were announced by the BJP as having "joined" it. The BJP then issued a second note saying they had only "extended support".
- The RJD and Congress alleged violation of the Tenth Schedule and demanded disqualification. The RJD plans to approach the Acting Chairman of the Council and, failing that, the courts.
Key facts for Prelims
- Tenth Schedule was added by the 52nd Constitutional Amendment Act, 1985, and was amended by the 91st Amendment Act, 2003 (split exception deleted; the merger exception stays only for two-thirds).
- An independent member who joins any political party after election is disqualified. Nominated members have six months to join a party.
- Disqualification is decided by the presiding officer (Speaker/Chairman). The decision is subject to judicial review (Kihoto Hollohan, 1992). The Tenth Schedule has no time limit.
- The Tenth Schedule applies to Legislative Councils as well as Assemblies. Art. 171: Council strength is at most one-third of the Assembly and at least 40.
- Graduates' and teachers' constituencies each fill one-twelfth of a Council. Elections use PR-STV. MLCs cannot vote in Presidential or Rajya Sabha elections.
Data and details
- Seats: eight Council seats went to the polls. The BJP and JD(U) (NDA partners) contested four each. The BJP won two, JD(U) one, and the RJD two. The remaining three went to the two Independents and the Jan Suraaj Party (Prashant Kishor) (derived: 8 − 5 = 3).
- The two Independents defeated JD(U) candidates: Bansidhar Brajwasi beat Abhishek Jha (Tirhut Graduates') and Rahul Raj beat Anand Pushkar (Saran Teachers').
- Sequence on Saturday: around 8 p.m. the BJP issued a release welcoming the two. Brajwasi said he joined the BJP after CM Samrat Choudhary assured him that teachers' concerns would be resolved if they worked together. Nearly an hour later the BJP issued a second press note saying the two had "extended their support". Brajwasi then posted a Facebook video saying he had not joined the BJP and had only offered support. Rahul Raj did not comment.
- Reactions: Tejashwi Yadav (LoP, RJD working president) accused the BJP of "making a mockery of the Constitution". RJD MP Manoj Jha cited the Tenth Schedule and said the RJD would meet Acting Chairman Ram Bachan Rai, then go to court if he did not decide. Congress's Asit Nath Tiwari accused the BJP of "backstabbing" ally JD(U). Jan Suraaj called the episode a "cruel and vulgar joke".
- Notably, the BJP's own two press notes diverge ("joined" vs "support"), and there was no comment from Rahul Raj.
Static–dynamic linkage
Under the Tenth Schedule, a member elected as an Independent who joins a political party after the election is disqualified. The dispute is whether "joining" has happened or whether it was only "support". The Tenth Schedule applies to State Legislative Councils as well as Assemblies, and the presiding officer decides disqualification. Here that is the Council Chairman, and the Acting Chairman currently holds the post. Judicial review is available against that decision.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Anti-defection law (Tenth Schedule, 52nd and 91st Amendments); State Legislature (Legislative Council, Art. 171); role of presiding officers.
Background primer
Tenth Schedule (Anti-Defection Law)
- What it is:
- The provisions on disqualification of MPs and State legislators on grounds of defection.
- Founded:
- Added by the 52nd Amendment (1985), in response to the toppling of several state governments by party-hopping MLAs after the 1967 elections. The 91st Amendment (2003) deleted the "split" exception, which had allowed one-third of a party to defect without disqualification.
- Members:
- It applies to both Houses of Parliament and the State Legislative Assemblies/Councils.
- Mandate:
- A legislator is disqualified for voluntarily giving up party membership or for voting against the whip. An independent legislator is disqualified for joining any political party after election. A nominated member is disqualified for joining a party after six months. Mergers are exempt when at least two-thirds of the legislature party agree.
- Why it matters:
- To curb opportunistic defection, deter horse-trading and maintain government stability.
State Legislative Council (Art. 171)
- What it is:
- The upper House in the six States that have one. Bihar, UP, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana and Karnataka currently have a Council.
- Why it matters:
- A revisory chamber allowing representation of graduates, teachers and experts. Its legislative powers are limited, and the Assembly can override its amendments.
Additional context
- Delay in deciding disqualification is a recurring concern. In Keisham Meghachandra Singh v. Speaker, Manipur Legislative Assembly (2020), the Supreme Court said petitions should ordinarily be decided within three months. It also suggested a permanent independent tribunal in place of the Speaker.
- In April 2026 seven AAP Rajya Sabha MPs joined the BJP. This sparked a legal debate centred on the merger exception (Paragraph 4), with AAP filing a disqualification plea before the Rajya Sabha Chairman.
- In August 2026 the Supreme Court issued notices to twenty rebel Trinamool Congress MPs. This renewed attention on delayed disqualification under the Tenth Schedule.
Mains dimensions
- "Joining" vs "support": The Tenth Schedule turns on whether the Independent has "joined" a party. A formal statement of support may be used to avoid disqualification. Courts have read conduct as evidence (the Ravi S. Naik principle on "voluntarily giving up membership"), though that was decided for party members.
- Presiding officer's role: The Council's presiding officer is the first decider. There is no deadline in the Schedule, and political alignment of the chair raises neutrality concerns.
- Intra-coalition politics: The BJP winning against its ally JD(U) shows the strain inside the NDA (as claimed by Congress). The opposition's attack uses this to question the BJP's conduct.
- Special constituencies: Graduates' and teachers' seats are meant for non-party professional voices. Quick absorption of winners into a party defeats that purpose.
- Way forward: A statutory timeline for decisions (the SC's three-month norm in Keisham Meghachandra, 2020), or an independent tribunal in place of the presiding officer. Clearer definition of "joining".
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The anti-defection law was meant to ensure political stability but its enforcement depends on presiding officers. Critically examine, with reference to the recent controversy over Independent legislators in the Bihar Legislative Council."
Related topics
- Tenth Schedule: Kihoto Hollohan, Ravi S. Naik, Keisham Meghachandra Singh, Paragraph 4 (merger) and the 91st Amendment
- Legislative Councils: Art. 169, Art. 171 and Art. 172
- Role of Speaker/Chairman and neutrality
- Dinesh Goswami Committee and other electoral-reform committees on defection
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 2 November 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs