BrainParrot

The examination overload, its enormous cost

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 30 October 2026

Summary

  • The author argues that India has stacked entrance and recruitment examinations on top of board and university exams. These layers cost money, cause stress, and are plagued by paper leaks. Cancellations have eroded trust in public examinations.
  • He proposes using standardised, moderated school-leaving and university results as the basis for admission, scholarships and recruitment. At most, one national aptitude test per exit level would be used to moderate scores.
  • The piece appears as Parliament has strengthened the anti-unfair-means law and a new high-powered committee has been formed in July 2026. He doubts that this and earlier reforms will fix the "design defect".

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Education, Governance; GS2 – Social Justice

Key facts for Prelims

  • Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024: enacted 12 Feb 2024, in force 21 Jun 2024. Offences are cognizable, non-bailable and non-compoundable. Candidates are outside its penal provisions. The five scheduled authorities are UPSC, SSC, RRBs, IBPS and NTA.
  • Amendment Bill, 2026: passed Parliament by 30 July 2026. It adds Special Fast Track Courts, time-bound investigation, trial and appeal, a Special Task Force and tougher penalties (see 2b).
  • NTA: set up in 2017 as a Society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. Non-statutory, under the Ministry of Education. Conducts JEE (Main), NEET-UG, CUET, UGC-NET and others.
  • Exams named in the article and their expansions:
  • JEE: Joint Entrance Examination. NEET: National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test. NATA: National Aptitude Test in Architecture. CLAT: Common Law Admission Test. CUET: Common University Entrance Test. CUET-PG: for postgraduate programmes.
  • GATE: Graduate Aptitude Test in Engineering. CAT: Common Admission Test. NET: National Eligibility Test (for research aspirants).
  • Recruitment bodies: UPSC, State PSCs, SSC and IBPS (Institute of Banking Personnel Selection).
  • Radhakrishnan Committee (2024): chaired by former ISRO chairman K. Radhakrishnan. It proposed DIGI-EXAM (modelled on DigiYatra) and restructuring of the NTA.
  • Education is a Concurrent List subject (stable textbook fact).

Data and details

  • The article says "millions" of young Indians face a "cascade" of exams. Layers named at four stages:
  • Undergraduate entry: boards plus JEE, NEET, NATA, CLAT, CUET, institution-specific tests.
  • Postgraduate: GATE, CAT, CUET-PG, university-level tests.
  • Research: NET.
  • Recruitment: UPSC, State PSCs, SSC, IBPS.
  • Failures named: paper leaks, dummy candidates, mark manipulation and "merit garbling", leading to repeated cancellations. Each wastes public money, delays admissions and recruitment, and erodes faith.
  • Timeline from the article: NTA review by a committee headed by a former space scientist in 2024; another high-powered committee in July 2026; a proposed strengthening of the law.
  • Cost burden: exorbitant costs fall disproportionately on poor and marginalised families. Exams reward the ability to pay for preparation over ability or diligence.
  • Process complications: centralised counselling for seat allotment complicates the process further.
  • Social consequence: several States have seen protests of varying scales.
  • Notably absent: the article gives no figures on candidates, costs or leaks, and it does not name the 2026 committee or the amended law. Its global-practice claim is not backed by named countries.
  • Reform proposals in the article:
  • Standardise board and university exams through normalisation, common moderation frameworks, external audits and periodic score equating.
  • Admission on moderated school-leaving results.
  • Scholarships on academic performance and track record.
  • Recruitment on verified academic records plus structured interviews.
  • At most one national scholastic-aptitude test at each exit level, used only to moderate board or university scores.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Education is in the Concurrent List. This is a stable textbook point. Both Parliament and State legislatures can legislate, and States run their own boards, universities and public service commissions. This is why national standardisation is politically hard.
  • Public examinations are a "gatekeeping" mechanism. They are meant to allocate scarce seats and posts fairly. They also raise the questions of equality of opportunity (Articles 14 and 16) and of whether merit measured in one sitting is merit.
  • The Prelims-level static core is the Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024 and the institutional ecosystem around it: NTA, UPSC, SSC and others.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Governance/Social Justice: issues relating to development and management of the education sector; statutory and regulatory bodies; government policies and interventions. GS2 – Polity: legislative response to a governance problem. GS4 – Ethics: integrity in public examinations and merit.

Background primer

National Testing Agency (NTA)

What it is:
an autonomous testing body under the Ministry of Education. The Union Cabinet approved its creation as a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. It is not a statutory body.
Founded:
the 2017–18 Budget speech announced it. The Cabinet approved it in November 2017. The aim was to relieve CBSE, AICTE and other agencies of running entrance exams, and to bring reliability and standardised difficulty.
Members:
chaired by an eminent educationist, with a Director General as CEO appointed by the Government and a Board of Governors drawn from user institutions. The DG is assisted by 9 verticals headed by academicians/experts. It got a one-time ₹25 crore grant and was meant to be financially self-sustaining.
Mandate:
the UGC-NET, JEE (Main), NEET-UG, C-MAT and C-PAT were entrusted to it. NEET-UG has been conducted by NTA since 2019. The CUET is also an NTA exam.
Why it matters:
a specialised, professional body with standardised, reliable testing, in the manner of advanced countries. The editorial contends this centralisation has created a new, failure-prone layer.

Public Examinations (Prevention of Unfair Means) Act, 2024

What it is:
the first dedicated national law against paper leaks and organised cheating in Central public examinations.
Founded:
enacted on 12 February 2024 and in force from 21 June 2024.

Additional context

  • The 2026 committee is a Nilekani-led task force. On 26 July 2026 the PM announced a high-powered task force on examination reforms under Nandan Nilekani. Its mandate is to recommend next-generation reforms: leak-proof, technology-driven, secure, transparent and tamper-resistant exams. The same July 2026 reform drive included the termination of 47 NTA officials.
  • The 2024 committee (the "former space scientist"):
    • It was a High-Level Committee of Experts set up by the Ministry of Education in 2024 and led by former ISRO chairman Dr K. Radhakrishnan. It followed the NEET-UG 2024 and UGC-NET irregularities.
    • Its report ran to 101 recommendations.
    • It recommended permanent domain experts in the NTA, government exam centres and State/District coordination committees. It also recommended DIGI-EXAM with Aadhaar-based biometrics, encrypted paper transmission, CCTV and AI monitoring, and a phased move to computer-based and adaptive testing.
    • It suggested NTA should conduct only entrance exams, not recruitment tests.
    • It proposed running exams like elections, using State machinery and presiding officers at each centre.
    • It suggested oversight of the private coaching industry and strengthening standard school education.
    • NTA has conducted 244 exams since 2018. Registered candidates rose from 67 lakh (2019–21) to 122 lakh (2022–23).
    • By 2026 a majority of the recommendations were reported as implemented or under execution.
  • Why the issue is live again: The NEET-UG 2026 exam, held on 3 May with over 22 lakh candidates, was cancelled by the NTA on 12 May 2026 after paper-leak allegations, and the matter was referred to the CBI. A re-examination was scheduled for 21 June 2026. This is not mentioned in the editorial.
  • The "strengthening of the law": this is the Amendment Bill, 2026.
    • It was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 27 July 2026, passed by the Lok Sabha on 29 July and by the Rajya Sabha on 30 July 2026.
    • It raises imprisonment to a minimum of five years, extendable to ten, and the maximum fine from ₹10 lakh to ₹50 lakh.
    • For service providers, the maximum fine goes from ₹1 crore to ₹5 crore and debarment from four to eight years.
    • For organised crime, the minimum term rises from five to seven years (up to ten), with a maximum fine of ₹10 crore.
    • The Centre can constitute a Special Task Force to investigate offences.
    • Investigation must be completed within two months and trial within three months of the charge sheet. Every State/UT must designate a Court of Session as a Special Fast Track Court, and Special Public Prosecutors are provided for.
    • Appeals are time-bound: no appeal is entertained by the High Court after 90 days from the judgment, sentence or order, and the High Court is to decide an appeal within three months of admission, as far as possible. The Bill has since received Presidential assent.
    • The Minister said 52 FIRs had been registered under the 2024 Act.

Mains dimensions

  • Design defect, not just implementation failure:
  • The 2024 Radhakrishnan review, the 2026 task force and the amended law all try to fix the system's operation.
  • The author asks whether the layering itself is the problem. NTA difficulties persisted after the 2024 review, so he doubts the reforms are working.
  • Note the contrast with the government's approach, which is to fix the existing exams: tougher penalties, tech security, a restructured NTA.
  • Original justification collapsed: separate exams were justified by non-uniform board standards and malpractice in boards. The author says the new layers have the same flaws. Paper leaks and cancellations (NEET-UG 2026 per 2b) show that.
  • Equity and social justice: coaching costs favour those who can pay. The Radhakrishnan panel itself recommended oversight of the coaching industry. Rural, poor and marginalised candidates are disadvantaged, with a direct bearing on Articles 14 and 21A and on equality of opportunity.
  • Learning outcomes:
  • Students "study to clear filters". Classroom teaching is displaced by coaching drilling, and the board exam becomes a formality.
  • This undermines the aims of NEP 2020, such as holistic, competency-based assessment.
  • Mental health: adolescence is turned into a "preparatory marathon", with stress and trauma.
  • Federalism and trust: the author contrasts distrust of teachers' multi-year assessment with trust in centralised agencies that have repeatedly failed. The fix he proposes is to improve State boards and universities, which are State subjects. This links to standardisation, normalisation and external audits.
  • Counter-arguments (analytical):
  • Board marks vary widely across boards and States, and grade inflation is a risk. A moderation framework would have to be credible.
  • Scarce seats in top institutions (IITs, AIIMS) need a common yardstick, and boards are themselves not leak-free.
  • A single national aptitude test per exit level may bring back the same problems.
  • Replacing entrance tests with school marks could raise the stakes of Class XII.
  • Recruitment by UPSC/SSC tests aptitude, not only qualifications, so records plus interviews risk subjectivity.
  • Way forward:
  • Strong Public Examinations Act enforcement with fast-track trials (2026 amendment).
  • Fewer, better exams: multi-stage or multi-session tests, harmonising entrance tests (as the Radhakrishnan panel suggested), and shifting load to board results.
  • Coaching oversight.
  • Independent audit and statutory status for the testing agency.

Possible Mains question

**GS2 (Education/Governance), 15 marks:** "The proliferation of entrance and recruitment examinations has made merit a function of the ability to pay for coaching rather than classroom learning. Critically examine the case for reducing exam layers in India, and discuss whether recent legal and institutional reforms address the underlying problems."

Related topics

  • National Education Policy 2020 (competency-based assessment, board-exam reforms, common entrance test)
  • Public Examinations Act, 2024 and the 2026 Amendment; State anti-paper-leak laws; Vyapam and other leak cases
  • NTA, UPSC, SSC and public service commissions (Article 315 onwards on UPSC/SPSCs)
  • Coaching regulation; student mental health (Kota-type concerns)
  • Equality of opportunity (Articles 14, 16, 21A); Concurrent List and education federalism

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 30 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs