Concerns over the collegium system
Source: The Hindu, 30 October 2026
Summary
- Retired Supreme Court judge Justice Sanjay Kaul has said former CJI D.Y. Chandrachud may have discussed proposed names for judgeship with the Union Government before the collegium met. He characterised it as seeking the government's "pre-approval", which erodes judicial autonomy.
- The explainer uses this to review the constitutional scheme, the evolution of the collegium, the NJAC episode, global practices and reform options.
Key facts for Prelims
- Art. 124: Supreme Court judges are appointed by the President after consulting the CJI. Art. 217: High Court judges after consultation with the CJI, Chief Justice of the HC and Governor.
- First Judges Case (1981): executive primacy. Second Judges Case (1993): collegium created. Third Judges Case (1998): reaffirmed, via Presidential Reference. Fourth Judges Case (2015): NJAC struck down.
- Collegium for SC: CJI + 4 senior-most judges. For HCs: CJI + 2 senior-most judges.
- 99th Constitutional Amendment (2014) created the NJAC; struck down in 2015 as violating the basic structure (independence of the judiciary).
- NJAC composition (per article): CJI, two senior judges, Union Law Minister, two eminent persons.
- The collegium is not mentioned in the Constitution; it is a judicial innovation. The MoP is a set of guidelines.
- If the collegium reiterates a recommendation after the Centre returns it, the appointment should be made.
Data and details
- The revised MoP has stayed unfinalised for 11 years since the NJAC judgment.
- UK Judicial Appointments Commission: 15 commissioners from the judiciary, legal profession and public. UK Supreme Court appointments use a selection commission of the UKSC President, a Senior UK judge and three other members, one from the JAC.
- South Africa Judicial Service Commission: 23 members, including the Chief Justice and representatives of the judiciary, legislature, executive, lawyers and academia. It recommends names to the President.
- US: federal Supreme Court judges are nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate.
- The article says India's collegium has no parallel in any other democracy.
- Alleged "pre-approval": Justice Kaul said Chandrachud "may have" discussed names with the government before the collegium met. The report is framed as a possibility ("may have").
Static–dynamic linkage
The Constitution provides for appointment by the President "in consultation" with judges. The Supreme Court's interpretation of consultation in the Second Judges Case (1993) and Third Judges Case (1998) created the collegium, a judiciary-led system that is neither in the Constitution nor in a statute. The issue is how to ensure independence from the executive and also accountability, transparency and diversity in appointments. The reported "pre-approval" would blur the line between judicial primacy and executive consultation.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Structure and organisation of the judiciary; Arts. 124 and 217; independence of the judiciary; separation of powers; Judges cases.
Background primer
Collegium system
- What it is:
- A judiciary-led mechanism for recommending appointments and transfers of judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts. Per the article, it was devised by the Supreme Court.
- Founded:
- Created in the Second Judges Case (1993) to keep appointments free from political favouritism, after the First Judges Case (1981) had upheld executive primacy. Reaffirmed in the Third Judges Case (1998).
- Mandate:
- Recommend names to the Centre. The Centre can return a recommendation with objections or reservations. If the collegium reiterates, the appointment should be made.
- Why it matters:
- Judges are best placed to assess the professional and technical merit of candidates, and the system insulates appointments from executive influence.
Memorandum of Procedure (MoP)
- What it is:
- Detailed procedure for appointment of judges, prepared by the Union Law Ministry in 1998 (per the article) as per the Second and Third Judges Cases.
National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC)
- What it is:
- Created through the 99th Constitutional Amendment (2014). It was to have the CJI, two senior judges, the Union Law Minister and two eminent persons. The Supreme Court struck it down in 2015 as violating the basic structure (judicial independence).
Additional context
-
Fourth Judges Case: the five-judge Constitution Bench declared the 99th Amendment and the NJAC Act unconstitutional. The bench (4:1 majority) acknowledged that all was not well with the collegium and that the time was ripe to improve the system of judicial appointments. It held that executive involvement in the NJAC undermined judicial independence and primacy.
-
NJAC design details: the NJAC had two eminent persons nominated by a committee of the PM, CJI and Leader of the Opposition. Any two members could veto a recommendation. Articles 124A, 124B and 124C were inserted to create and empower it.
-
Third Judges Case route: it arose from a Presidential Reference under Art. 143. It held that dissent by even two collegium members can halt a recommendation.
-
MoP follow-up: after 2015 the Supreme Court asked the government to revise the MoP in consultation with the CJI to bring more transparency. The revised MoP remains unfinalised.
-
First Judges Case background: S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981) held that the executive had primacy.
Mains dimensions
- Autonomy vs consultation: Pre-discussion with the executive undercuts the collegium's independence, in contrast to the intent of the Second Judges Case. The government's role is to object after a recommendation, not to pre-approve.
- Drawbacks: Lack of transparency and accountability, and alleged nepotism where relatives of sitting judges are favoured.
- Executive-judiciary deadlock: The MoP has stalled for 11 years because of differences over some aspects of the executive-drafted revision.
- Comparative models: The US (Presidential nomination and Senate confirmation), the UK (independent JAC) and South Africa (23-member JSC) offer broad-based models.
- Reform path: Short term, finalise the revised MoP for transparency and consultation. Long term, revive the NJAC with a broader composition (legislature, Bar Council, academia), while the judiciary retains a veto over the final recommendation.
- Constitutional constraint: The 2015 judgment holds judicial independence to be basic structure, so any new body must preserve judicial primacy to survive review.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The collegium system has protected judicial independence but is criticised for opacity. Evaluate the system and suggest reforms in the light of the NJAC judgment and comparative practices."
Related topics
- Judges Cases (1981, 1993, 1998, 2015); Art. 143 (Presidential Reference); basic structure doctrine
- Independence of the judiciary (security of tenure, removal of judges, Arts. 124(4), 217, 121)
- Appointment of Chief Justice of India (seniority convention); transfer of judges
- Judicial accountability and transparency; recusal and Judicial Standards and Accountability proposals
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 30 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs