Can ECI punish voters for being lax, asks SC
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 29 October 2026
Summary
- A Supreme Court Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant questioned whether the ECI can permanently strip a voter of the right to vote merely because the voter was slow to return an enumeration form in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR).
- The Court also said the ECI was in "error" to force deleted, pre-existing voters to re-apply as new voters through Form 6.
- Alongside this, an op-ed by a senior advocate argues that the SC's 27 May 2026 SIR verdict raises serious constitutional questions. A Karnataka data analysis estimates about 64.5 lakh electors are "missing" from the state's final SIR rolls.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections and electoral rolls vest in the ECI.
- Article 326: elections to the Lok Sabha and Assemblies are on the basis of adult suffrage. The editorial lists the disqualification grounds as non-residence, unsoundness of mind, crime, and corrupt or illegal practice.
- Representation of the People Act, 1950 and the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 govern preparation and revision of rolls. Form 6 is for new inclusion, Form 7 for objection to inclusion or deletion, and Form 8 for shifting of residence.
- Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950 empowers the ECI to order a special revision of the roll. Section 16 bars enrolment of a non-citizen.
- The editorial argues only two qualifications (adulthood and Indian citizenship) are needed for inclusion in a roll.
- Article 32 (writs for fundamental rights), Article 141 (law declared by SC binds all courts), Article 142 (orders for "complete justice"), Article 144 (all authorities act in aid of the SC) are cited in the editorial as the SC's tools.
- Basic-structure lineage cited in the editorial: Golaknath v. State of Punjab (1967), Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973), Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975). The editorial's reading is that free and fair elections are part of the basic structure.
- In Mohinder Singh Gill v. CEC (1977), the SC upheld the ECI's broad Article 324 powers and noted that judicial review during elections is restricted under Article 329(b).
- Elector-to-Population (E-to-P) ratio: ratio of total electors on the rolls to the estimated total population (all ages, including those under 18).
Data and details
- SIR has "disenfranchised" nearly 13 crore voters across the country (as reported).
- The Bench was headed by CJI Surya Kant, with Justice Joymalya Bagchi speaking for it. Justice Bagchi asked whether being lax, inert or non-responsive can justify the ECI forfeiting someone's right to vote forever.
- ECI's counsel Dama Seshadri Naidu cited the 27 May Bihar SIR judgment as recognising ECI "residuary powers". Justice Bagchi replied that it is not a "binding precedent" and asked why those powers were not used to reach non-responding voters.
- "Logical discrepancy" was not a category in the Bihar SIR. It was permitted in West Bengal only as an interim arrangement, and the Court has not finally adjudicated its legality.
- Justice Bagchi asked how voters included in the 2003 roll, after an intensive revision, could be purged in 2026 for "logical discrepancy".
- Petitioners are activists Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri, represented by Prashant Bhushan and Neha Rathi. They argue that forcing voters to apply as "new" applicants makes them misrepresent themselves, an offence attracting imprisonment.
- The Bench said Forms 6, 7 and 8 are "cast in stone" and the ECI cannot alter them.
- Delhi: of 1,45,10,299 electors at the start of the SIR, 47,56,722 were marked as not having returned enumeration forms (absent, shifted, dead or duplicate), per Mr. Bhushan.
- The Court's hypotheticals: a voter on a month-long assignment outside Delhi being treated as "permanently shifted"; a voter moving from Vasant Kunj to Sarita Vihar needing only to disclose details to stay on the roll.
- Justice Bagchi said Form 6/7 requirements arise only after the final roll is published, not at the draft stage. He called the mismatch a "structural incongruity" and suggested letting deleted voters submit enumeration forms belatedly, open-ended and without timelines.
- CJI Kant asked why the SIR was being rushed in Delhi with no elections around. The last date for claims and objections in Delhi is 30 October.
- ECI's reply: voters were never "deleted", since they can return to the roll any time before filing of nominations for an election.
- Timeline: Bihar's last SIR was 1 January 2003; its last Special Summary Revision (SSR) roll was dated 6 January 2025; the fresh SIR was ordered on 24 June 2025. The SC verdict is dated 27 May 2026. The author says the SIR effectively questioned every Bihar roll between 2003 and 2025.
- Bihar Assembly elections were held in November 2025 and West Bengal's in April 2026, after the SIR, amid "widespread dissatisfaction".
- The verdict says ECI's power affects an individual's entitlement to be on the roll but does not divest citizenship claims or foreclose the competent authority under the Citizenship Act.
- The author says the words "limited" and "strict sense" carry no legal significance. He also argues the ECI's role in rolls is "strictly ministerial" and that it can disenfranchise an existing voter only with a pre-decisional hearing.
- Notably absent: the verdict names no document as conclusive proof of citizenship. Paragraph 158 says a ration card is not conclusive proof, unlike a passport or birth certificate.
- The Ministry of External Affairs, at a Passport Seva Divas briefing on 24 June 2026, said a passport is merely a travel document and not proof of citizenship.
- The author says citizens on the roll as of 6 January 2025 were effectively disenfranchised with effect from 1 July 2025.
- He argues the SC could have issued a writ of mandamus directing the government to specify citizenship documents.
- Proposed yardstick: Article 326 grounds only, with RP Act 1950 and the 1960 Rules required to comply with Article 326.
- About 64.5 lakh electors are potentially missing, based on an E-to-P ratio of 66.11 published by the Chief Electoral Officer (CEO).
- Of the 64.5 lakh, 38.41 lakh (59.5%) are in the 18–29 age group.
- Baseline: the 2020 Report of the Technical Group on Population Projections (National Commission on Population), also cited by the Karnataka CEO. Estimated population on 1 March 2026 is about 6.89 crore, of which 5.19 crore are eligible to vote.
- Final rolls have 4,54,55,689 electors (excluding Service Electors), a shortfall of about 64.5 lakh.
- Pre-SIR rolls had 5.54 crore electors, above the estimated 18+ population, which indicates duplicates and dead voters needed removal.
- During enumeration 1.08 crore names were deleted. Only 23.5 lakh (21.8%) were duplicates or deceased, and 78.2% were deleted as shifted or absent. Only 8.2 lakh net additions came in the Claims and Objections phase.
- Ages 18–19: only 33.1% enrolled (6.83 lakh against an estimated 20.66 lakh). Ages 20–29: 86.56 lakh against 1.11 crore (77.9%).
- Gender: under-enrolment is high among women aged 18–29, and the trend reverses at 30+. The gender ratio rose from 1,007 women per 1,000 men (January 2025) to 1,017.
- 13 constituencies have an E-to-P ratio below 50, mostly in and around Bengaluru. B.T.M. Layout is lowest at 39.23, with rolls shrinking by more than 50% (2.82 lakh to 1.41 lakh).
- Economist Jean Dreze says 66.11 is far below the 75% estimated share of adults in Karnataka's population in 2026. He says the gap is too big to be explained by projection errors.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Electoral rolls rest on Article 326, which gives every adult citizen the right to vote unless disqualified on constitutional or legal grounds. Article 324 gives the ECI superintendence, direction and control over rolls and elections.
- The statutory machinery is the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. Rolls must be accurate, but the ECI's power is not unlimited. Deletions must follow the statutory forms and natural justice, and a Court-defined proportionality test applies.
- This news is a live test of balancing "purity" of rolls against inclusion. The core question is whether an administrative lapse by a voter (not returning a form) can cancel a constitutional entitlement.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Representation of People Act; constitutional bodies (ECI); electoral reforms; Article 324 and Article 326 (universal adult suffrage); judicial review; basic structure.
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI)
- What it is:
- the constitutional body that runs elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President, and oversees the electoral rolls.
- Founded:
- 25 January 1950 (textbook fact), under Article 324.
- Members:
- a Chief Election Commissioner and such other Election Commissioners as the President may fix (Article 324(2), textbook fact).
- Mandate:
- Article 324(1) grants the ECI superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament and State Legislatures.
- Why it matters:
- an independent umpire to secure free and fair elections.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- a large-scale, intensive revision of electoral rolls by the ECI under its constitutional and statutory powers. It involves house-to-house enumeration by Booth Level Officers (BLOs), distribution and collection of enumeration forms, a draft roll, a claims-and-objections period, and a final roll after verification.
Forms under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 (as described in the article)
Additional context
- In ADR vs. ECI (2025), the SC held the ECI has the power to conduct SIR under Article 324 read with the RP Act, 1950 and its Rules. It found SIR satisfies proportionality: legitimate purpose, non-excessive means, least restrictive option.
- On citizenship, the Court said the ECI may examine questions bearing on citizenship, but this does not divest a person of citizenship claims or foreclose a decision by the competent authority under the Citizenship Act.
- The Court noted the process was made constitutionally compliant by safeguards added during the hearings, most notably inclusion of the Aadhaar card as a valid document.
- Phasing (PIB): Phase I was Bihar. The schedule for Phase II (12 States/UTs) was issued on 27 October 2025. On 14 May 2026 the ECI ordered Phase III in 16 States and 3 UTs, covering the entire country except Himachal Pradesh, Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh. Delhi is part of Phase III.
- West Bengal "logical discrepancy": in an interim order, the SC noted about 1.40 crore individuals had been issued document-verification notices, in mapped, unmapped and "logical discrepancy" categories. The logical-discrepancy category accounted for approximately 1.36 crore voters. Examples of such discrepancies include a mismatch of father's name, a mismatch of parents' ages, and more than six progeny. The SC later directed serving and former district judges to adjudicate claims and objections of persons placed under "logical discrepancy".
- Delhi: an ECI update reported over 2,98,400 hearings held for notices in unmapped and logical-discrepancy cases in Delhi.
- ECI's stated safeguards (Ministry of Law and Justice reply, based on the ECI press note): deletions follow due verification by BLOs through house-to-house enumeration. They fall into four categories: death, permanent shifting, duplicate entries, and electors found untraceable despite repeated visits.
Mains dimensions
- Constitutional limits on the ECI: Article 324 is a "continuous source of authority" (per the SC in the SIR verdict) but must operate within Article 326, the RP Act and the 1960 Rules. The Bench's remark that Forms 6/7/8 are "cast in stone" shows the ECI cannot redesign statutory forms.
- Process vs. right: treating non-response as forfeiture converts an administrative lapse into permanent loss of franchise. Hence the "structural incongruity" between SIR's enumeration phase and the Form 6/7 regime, and the Court's idea of open-ended belated submission.
- "Logical discrepancy" as an unsettled category: it was absent in Bihar and only interim in West Bengal, yet it was used to purge voters who were on the 2003 roll. This raises questions of arbitrariness, burden of proof and natural justice (pre-decisional hearing).
- Citizenship inquiry by the ECI: the verdict allows a "limited" inquiry. Critics argue this vests unguided discretion in the ECI while no document conclusively proves citizenship. The MEA's passport statement deepens the confusion.
- Inclusion deficits fall unevenly: in Karnataka, young first-time voters (18–19: 33.1%) and women aged 18–29 are most under-enrolled, and 78.2% of enumeration-phase deletions were "shifted/absent" rather than duplicate or dead. This feeds migrant, urban and youth disenfranchisement concerns.
- Electoral integrity vs. rush: the CJI asked why Delhi's SIR was being hurried with no election nearby. Elections held in Bihar and West Bengal after SIR add to trust-deficit concerns.
- Way forward: the Court should specify admissible citizenship documents and require a hearing before deletion. The ECI should keep enumeration open-ended and publish deletion reasons, with independent audits (judicial officers were used in West Bengal).
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has revived the debate between 'purity of rolls' and universal adult suffrage. Critically examine the Election Commission's powers and the safeguards required against wrongful disenfranchisement."
Related topics
- Article 324, Article 326, Article 329(b) and Mohinder Singh Gill (1977)
- Representation of the People Act, 1950 (Sections 16, 19, 21) vs. RP Act, 1951
- Basic structure doctrine (Kesavananda Bharati, Indira Gandhi v. Raj Narain)
- Citizenship Act, 1955 and the Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA)
- Right to vote: fundamental right, constitutional right or statutory right
- Electoral reforms: voter ID–Aadhaar linking, migrant voting
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 29 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs