BrainParrot

SC agrees to hear AITUC challenge to definition of ‘industry’ in new law

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 29 October 2026

Summary

  • The Supreme Court agreed to hear a petition by AITUC (Tamil Nadu) challenging the definition of 'industry' in the Industrial Relations Code (IRC), 2020, calling it "deliciously vague".
  • The union says the Code's exemptions, from charitable institutions to sovereign functions of government, are too wide. The petition says the definition fails the "triple test" laid down in the 1978 Bangalore Water Supply case.

UPSC relevance: GS2/GS3 — Polity & Economy: Labour codes, judicial review, definition of 'industry'

Key facts for Prelims

  • IRC, 2020 definition of 'industry' sits in Section 2(p). The Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 defined it in Section 2(j).
  • Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa (1978): seven-judge Bench, Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, 'triple test'.
  • Triple test: (i) systematic or organised activity; (ii) employer-employee cooperation; (iii) production/distribution of goods and services to satisfy human wants.
  • The four Labour Codes are the Code on Wages, 2019; the Industrial Relations Code, 2020; the Code on Social Security, 2020; and the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020.
  • The IRC subsumes three Acts: Trade Unions Act, 1926; Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946; Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
  • Labour is in the Concurrent List, so States frame their own rules under the codes.

Data and details

  • AITUC (Tamil Nadu) petition agreed to be heard on Wednesday by a Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant. Counsel for the union: senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan and advocate Aarthi Rajan.
  • The union's grievance: the Code exempts everything from charitable institutions to "any activity of the appropriate government relatable to sovereign functions" to "any other activity as may be notified by the Central government".
  • CJI Kant asked whether there is a problem with the definition. Counsel said it does not meet the triple test.
  • In August 2026 a nine-judge Bench headed by CJI Kant reviewed the 1978 interpretation of Section 2(j) of the ID Act, 1947. The 2020 Code had already come into force, which largely made the reference infructuous.
  • CJI Kant observed that the future of 'industry' in Section 2(p) of the IRC is not burdened by the interpretation of 2(j) of the ID Act.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Whether a workplace is an "industry" decides whether its workers get protections such as dispute resolution, retrenchment safeguards and union rights. This is the gateway question in labour law.
  • Under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (Section 2(j)) the Supreme Court's 1978 judgment gave a broad, judge-made definition. Parliament has now enacted its own text in Section 2(p) of the IRC with express exclusions. The dispute is therefore about the legislature's power to narrow an expansive judicial reading, and the vagueness of that narrowing.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: judicial review of legislation, role of the judiciary; GS3 – Economy: labour reforms and industrial relations; GS2 – Social Justice: worker welfare.

Background primer

Industrial Relations Code, 2020

What it is:
one of four labour codes. It amalgamates and subsumes the Trade Unions Act, 1926, the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946 and the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
Mandate:
it covers registration of trade unions, work committees and grievance redressal committees, and aims at industrial peace and harmony. It also covers standing orders, trade unions, strikes and layoffs.
Why it matters:
the codes address the long-pending need to move beyond colonial-era structures.

Definition of 'industry' (Section 2(p), IRC 2020)

'Triple test' (Bangalore Water Supply and Sewerage Board v. A. Rajappa, 1978)

Additional context

  • In the Constitution Bench ruling referred to in the article, the Court held by a 5:4 majority that the 1978 triple test needed refinement, though its essential framework had stood the test of time. Pending proceedings under the 1947 Act will continue to be decided by the existing Bangalore Water Supply test.
  • Meaning of "industry" under the IRC, 2020 will be interpreted independently under its own text and statutory scheme, without being governed by the 1978 precedent.
  • Parliament had responded to the 1978 ruling with the Industrial Disputes (Amendment) Act, 1982, but its amended definition was not brought into force for decades (noted by the Supreme Court in an earlier reference order).
  • Central trade unions have expressed concern that severing the new Code from the 1978 precedent could cost workers collective bargaining rights, minimum wage guarantees and dispute-resolution mechanisms.

Mains dimensions

  • Legislature vs. judiciary: a 1978 judge-made, wide definition was met by a 2020 statutory definition with exclusions. The 1982 amendment was not brought into force for decades, which shows the long contest over the scope of 'industry'. The nine-judge Bench left the Code's text to be construed on its own terms.
  • Vagueness and delegation: the open-ended "any other activity as may be notified by the Central government" gives the executive power to carve out sectors. This raises concerns about excessive delegation and arbitrariness (Article 14).
  • Worker protection vs. ease of doing business: narrowing 'industry' may exclude institutions such as hospitals, educational institutions and municipalities that the 1978 test covered, leaving workers without industrial-dispute remedies. The government's stated aims for the Labour Codes are simplified compliance, ease of doing business and formalisation of employment (per the Labour Ministry/PIB).
  • Sovereign functions exception: the line between sovereign and non-sovereign government activity is historically difficult and is likely to be litigated.
  • Federal dimension: labour is a Concurrent subject, so State rules will determine implementation.
  • Way forward: clear statutory guidance or rules on the exclusions, and a judicial reading that reconciles the Code's text with worker-protection objectives.

Possible Mains question

**GS3 / GS2, 15 marks:** "The definition of 'industry' determines who gets protection under labour law. Examine how the Industrial Relations Code, 2020 departs from the Bangalore Water Supply 'triple test' and discuss its implications for workers and employers."

Related topics

  • Four Labour Codes and the 29 laws they replaced (Wages, Social Security, OSH, IR)
  • Directive Principles on labour (Articles 38, 41–43A) and Article 14 (arbitrariness)
  • Concurrent List and the labour federalism debate
  • Constitution Bench and larger-Bench references; stare decisis and prospective overruling
  • Gig and platform workers; fixed-term employment

Topics: GS2Economy

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 29 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs