BrainParrot

Arlekar’s recommendation on KPSC chief sparks row

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 26 October 2026

Summary

  • Former Governor of Keralam Rajendra Vishwanath Arlekar reportedly recommended to President Droupadi Murmu the removal of Kerala PSC Chairperson M.R. Baiju over alleged irregularities in the PSC's running. The article calls the move unprecedented.
  • It became public days after Arlekar left. He is learnt to have sent it a week before being relieved, and Om Prakash Mathur has succeeded him.
  • Politics split. The CPI(M) and Opposition Leader Pinarayi Vijayan called it unconstitutional and an abuse of power. Most UDF Ministers who spoke supported it, but Revenue Minister A.P. Anil Kumar called it a constitutional impropriety.

UPSC relevance: GS2 — Polity: Constitutional bodies (State PSC), Governor–Government relations, federalism

Key facts for Prelims

  • State PSC chairman: appointed by the Governor; removed only by the President (Art. 317). The President removes UPSC members as well.
  • Removal for misbehaviour requires a Supreme Court inquiry and report under Article 145 procedure; the Governor can only suspend, and only after the reference.
  • Article 317(3) grounds for removal without inquiry: insolvency, paid outside employment, infirmity of mind or body.
  • Article 316: appointment and term (six years or age 62; ineligible for re-appointment as a member of that Commission). Article 318: regulations on number and conditions of service. Article 320: functions.
  • State PSC members' conditions of service cannot be varied to their disadvantage after appointment (as the Kerala PSC states).

Data and details

  • Alleged irregularities relate to PSC examinations for certain posts in the State Planning Board; a Crime Branch investigation is in progress.
  • Recommendation reportedly sent to the President one week before Arlekar was relieved; the news broke a few days after he left Kerala.
  • CPI(M) State secretariat: the move is unconstitutional. It questioned whether the government asked for dissolution when "no allegation can be proven or presented in court". It said the Sangh Parivar is targeting the PSC after the universities.
  • Pinarayi Vijayan (Leader of the Opposition): the recommendation to remove the Chairperson and dissolve the Commission is unlawful, a violation of constitutional provisions and gross abuse of power. It raised concerns about use of Lok Bhavans for the BJP's political agenda and asked the Congress-led UDF government to clarify its stand.
  • UDF Ministers: a majority of those who spoke on Sunday supported the Governor. Revenue Minister A.P. Anil Kumar called it a constitutional impropriety to hastily recommend action without the government's knowledge while an investigation was under way.
  • Notably: the article describes the move as unprecedented. The report is of a recommendation only; neither the President's response nor a Supreme Court reference is reported.

Static–dynamic linkage

Public Service Commissions are insulated from executive pressure by a special removal procedure. A State PSC chairman is appointed by the Governor, but only the President can remove him, and only after a Supreme Court inquiry. This shields commissions from removal by the government of the day. The news raises the question of what role a Governor has in setting that process in motion, and whether the State government's aid and advice is needed.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (UPSC/State PSCs, Arts. 315–323); Governor's role and discretion; Centre–State relations; independence of institutions.

Background primer

Public Service Commissions (Part XIV, Chapter II)

What it is:
A body created by the Constitution under Articles 315 to 323.
Founded:
the constitutional PSCs were created with the Constitution in 1950. They descend from the Federal Public Service Commission of 1926 and provincial commissions under the 1935 Act (stable textbook facts; the Kerala Commission's own founding date is not confirmed from trusted sources found).
Why it matters:
to keep recruitment fair and free of influence from any quarter.

Article 317 — removal and suspension

Additional context

  • In Supreme Court Reference U/A 317(1) No. 1 of 2023 (In re Mepung Tadar Bage, Arunachal PSC member), the President made a reference under Article 317(1). The Governor had requested the President to make a reference, and the President did so on 18 April 2023. In the same matter the Chief Minister had earlier asked the Governor to place the matter before the President. That is a precedent for the Governor-to-President route but with the State government's initiative. In the Kerala case, the Revenue Minister alleged the recommendation was made without the government's knowledge.
  • The reference was answered on 28 August 2025 (2025 INSC 1047). The Supreme Court found the allegations of misbehaviour not proved because nothing linked the member to the question-paper leak. It recommended that her suspension be revoked.
  • A 2003 Supreme Court reference (Special Reference 1 of 2003, Orissa PSC chairman) framed the question whether a President's reference under Article 317(1) must be preceded by Council of Ministers' advice under Article 74. The outcome is not confirmed from the sources found.
  • M.R. Baiju was recommended by the State Cabinet to the Governor for Chairman in 2022. He has been Chairman since 29 October 2022.

Mains dimensions

  • Constitutional design: Article 317 gives the Supreme Court a gatekeeping role to protect independence. A Governor's recommendation cannot itself remove anyone, and dissolving a PSC has no Article 317 basis.
  • Governor's discretion vs aid and advice: the Governor acts on ministerial advice except where discretion is allowed. The Revenue Minister's objection is about that. Supporters of the move would point to the State government's silence and the ongoing investigation. This echoes Mepung Tadar Bage, where the process started with the State.
  • Presumption of innocence vs institutional integrity: the Crime Branch probe is incomplete. Removal "at this stage" would pre-empt the inquiry. But allegations of exam irregularities damage public trust in recruitment.
  • Federalism and politicisation: the opposition frames it as targeting autonomous State institutions, like universities. The timing, days before the Governor's exit, adds to this.
  • Coalition fault lines: UDF Ministers are divided, which shows that institutional questions are being read through party lines.
  • Way forward: let the investigation conclude; use Article 317 reference if misbehaviour is established; codify norms on Governor–government communication with the President.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 10 marks:** "Public Service Commissions are insulated from executive control through a special removal procedure. Discuss the constitutional position on removal of a State PSC Chairman and the role of the Governor in this context."

Related topics

  • Governor: appointment, discretion, Articles 153–163, role in universities and Bills
  • Removal procedures of other constitutional authorities (Arts. 124(4), 148, 324(5)); Article 74 (aid and advice)
  • Recruitment-exam integrity (paper leaks and State PSC controversies); Centre–State relations

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 26 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs