Where should judicial restraint begin?
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 26 October 2026
Summary
- On 4 October Supreme Court judge Justice Ujjal Bhuyan spoke at a NALSAR moot-court event. He said the right to vote is constitutional and part of the basic structure, and that mass disenfranchisement would be arbitrary. Former CJI B.R. Gavai and some retired High Court judges said a sitting judge should not comment on a sub judice matter.
- The author tests the criticism against India's judicial code and comparative standards. He concludes that the propositions on voting and hearing largely track existing doctrine, but the "no court can condone" line comes closer to a conclusion on a live issue. Restraint depends on subject, specificity and proximity to adjudication.
Key facts for Prelims
- Restatement of Values of Judicial Life: adopted 7 May 1997 by the Supreme Court's Full Court. Clause 8 bars public debate on political matters or matters pending or likely to arise. Clause 1 is about conduct that sustains public faith in impartiality.
- Article 326: adult suffrage; Article 14: equality before law; Article 325: no exclusion from the general electoral roll on grounds of religion, race, caste or sex.
- Section 22, Representation of the People Act, 1950 (correction of entries); Rule 21A, Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 (notice, inquiry, hearing and reasoned determination before deletion).
- Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct: Principle 2.4 (restraint on comments that might affect a proceeding), Principle 4.11 (judges may write, lecture, teach on law and the administration of justice).
- The U.S. Supreme Court's 2023 Code of Conduct: Justices may speak and teach but should not comment on the merits of pending or impending matters.
- Basic structure doctrine is invoked in the speech (right to vote as integral to it).
Data and details
- July 2018: Justice Ranjan Gogoi, months before becoming CJI, said democracy sometimes needs "noisy judges" along with independent journalists.
- 4 October 2026: Justice Bhuyan's NALSAR valedictory address. He cited Articles 14 and 326, said Article 326 "cannot be tinkered with", and cited Section 22 of the RP Act, 1950 on notice and hearing, except for death.
- 5 October: Justice Vikram Nath (senior-most puisne judge) said impartiality and indifference are different.
- Critics: former CJI B.R. Gavai (said "judicial propriety" does not permit a sitting judge to comment on a sub judice matter), and former Delhi HC judges S.N. Dhingra and R.S. Sodhi. Justice Sodhi stressed the statutory framework governing voting rights.
- Pending matter: the West Bengal SIR litigation was before the Supreme Court. The ECI told the Court that more than 22 lakh deleted voters had appealed for restoration, and related matters were due on 5 October. Justice Bhuyan neither named the SIR nor sat on those Benches.
- 27 May 2026: a Bench led by CJI Surya Kant upheld the Bihar SIR in Association for Democratic Reforms v ECI. It called the right to vote constitutional but not absolute or unregulated, said Articles 325 and 326 require inclusion of eligible and exclusion of ineligible electors, and cited Rule 21A (notice, inquiry, hearing, reasoned determination).
- Comparative: Scalia (2003, Pledge of Allegiance) was asked to recuse and took no part. Lady Hale (2016) outlined arguments in pending Brexit litigation, stopped, and later sat in Miller. Ruth Bader Ginsburg criticised candidate Trump and called her comments "ill-advised".
- Indian practice: Justice B.V. Nagarathna at NALSAR (March 2024) criticised Governors withholding assent while related disputes were before the Court.
- Speech audit: at least 25 public engagements since 14 July 2023 (a conservative minimum); at least nine generated news reports, seven of them in 2026.
- 2026 themes: executive influence in judicial transfers, UAPA's low conviction rates, restrictive bail conditions, collegium transparency, frivolous prosecutions over food choices, poems, protests and slogans.
- Retired Justice Indu Malhotra called his criticism of the Supreme Court's 2024 Delhi Metro arbitration ruling an "indiscretion". Former Justice Sudhanshu Dhulia defended another July speech on dissent and criminalisation, but said sitting judges must exercise restraint.
- Gauhati High Court record: Monowara Bewa v Union of India (2017) rejected a Gaon Panchayat Secretary's certificate as an NRC linkage document, and the Supreme Court later set aside that broader conclusion in Rupajan Begum. In Sirajul Hoque v State of Assam (2019), the Supreme Court reversed a 2017 decision of his Bench where name variations contributed to rejection of a citizenship claim. In Md Anuwar Hussain (2014) he set aside a Foreigners Tribunal order for lack of sound logic, remanded, and ordered the petitioner's release.
- Scholars cited: Jasmin Moran and Christopher W. Schmidt (apparent-bias concerns without treating silence as the answer).
Static–dynamic linkage
Judicial independence and impartiality are the base of the rule of law. India has no statutory code of conduct for judges. The Restatement of Values of Judicial Life is a self-adopted, non-sanctioned code. So the debate is about the limit between informed constitutional commentary and prejudging a case. The tension is between a judge as an "engaged" public intellectual and a judge as an impartial arbiter.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Structure and functioning of the judiciary; judicial accountability; GS4 – Ethics: probity, impartiality and conduct of public servants.
Background primer
Restatement of Values of Judicial Life (1997)
- What it is:
- A charter adopted unanimously by the Supreme Court's Full Court on 7 May 1997, generally called the Code of Conduct for judges.
- Mandate:
- A judge shall not enter public debate or express views in public on political matters, or on matters pending or likely to arise for judicial determination. Justice must not merely be done but be seen to be done.
- Why it matters:
- sustaining public faith in judicial impartiality (Clause 1). Clause 8 is the one at issue here.
Additional context
- Justice Bhuyan, as Telangana High Court Chief Justice, was also Chancellor of NALSAR until his elevation to the Supreme Court. He became a Supreme Court judge on 14 July 2023. That date matches the article's baseline for its count of his speeches.
- The 2nd ARC recommended designating a Supreme Court judge as "Judicial Values Commissioner" to enforce the code. This shows the absence of an external enforcement mechanism that the article's debate runs into.
Mains dimensions
- What the code requires vs what it allows: Clause 8 reaches matters "likely to arise", which is broader than the U.S. code. The Bangalore Principles and the U.S. code still allow commentary on law and legal administration.
- The test (author's): subject of the speech, specificity of the conclusion, proximity to adjudication. Explaining an issue differs from appearing to answer it.
- Was Justice Bhuyan on settled ground? Voting as a constitutional right and the need for a hearing before deletion track the 27 May 2026 ruling. "No court can condone" mass disenfranchisement is the debatable part, though conditional.
- Recusal logic: the Scalia episode shows that if a case on the precise issue came to him, recusal could arise.
- Counter-arguments for judicial voice: the "noisy judge" tradition, Justice Nath's formulation, and Nagarathna's remarks on Governors. Silence cannot be the default for constitutional law, civil liberties, appointments and court administration.
- Speeches do not predict outcomes: his High Court record has both strict and claimant-protective strands.
- Institutional gap: an unenforceable code and inconsistent peer reactions (Malhotra vs Dhulia) show that controversy alone is a poor test. This supports calls for clearer norms.
Possible Mains question
**GS2/GS4, 15 marks:** "Judges are expected to be impartial but not indifferent. Examine the limits on public speech by sitting judges in India, with reference to the Restatement of Values of Judicial Life and comparative practice."
Related topics
- Judicial accountability: in-house procedure, impeachment (Arts. 124(4), 217), recusal norms; sub judice rule
- Basic structure doctrine; right to vote as constitutional vs statutory right
- SIR and ADR v ECI; Governors' assent to Bills
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 26 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs