Police denotify Jantar Mantar as designated protest venue
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 13 October 2026
Summary
- On 12 Oct the Delhi Police denotified Jantar Mantar as a designated protest venue. It replaced it with three grounds farther from Parliament and government offices. Activists say this makes it harder for citizens to reach decision-makers.
- The order follows a Union Home Ministry committee's recommendations on alternative venues. Three days earlier the SC and the Union government had both said central Delhi is too cramped for protests.
- The move came after two days of detentions of anti-SIR protesters. On 12 Oct a large INDIA-bloc march reached the Supreme Court area largely unhindered.
- Allegations of custodial ill-treatment have reached the SC, and a Delhi High Court hearing is listed. The CJI asked that the Supreme Court not be "dragged into" political protest.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 19(1)(a): freedom of speech and expression. Article 19(1)(b): assembly peaceably and without arms. Article 19(2) and 19(3): reasonable restrictions. Public order is a ground for 19(3).
- Article 19(1)(c) is the right to form associations or unions.
- Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India (2018): the Jantar Mantar and Boat Club case. The SC recognised the right to protest, rejected the blanket ban, and directed regulated guidelines.
- Amit Sahni (2020): public ways cannot be occupied indefinitely. Anita Thakur (2016): excessive force.
- Section 163 BNSS is the provision for prohibitory orders. The Delhi Police Commissioner issues standing orders for protest regulation.
- The 2018 "golden rule" (per the Hindu report): the protester's right is balanced with the right of residents to live peacefully. The 2020 Shaheen Bagh judgment: the protester's right is balanced with the commuter's.
- Right to protest and detention also engage Articles 21 and 22. Parliament and government offices lie in the New Delhi district near Jantar Mantar.
Data and details
- New designated venues:
- Ramlila Maidan, about 4 km from Jantar Mantar;
- Burari Ground, about 15 km away;
- CBD Ground, East Delhi, about 13 km away.
- Revised SOPs for the three grounds are to be issued separately. The order was issued by Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar on the Home Ministry committee's recommendations. It modifies Standing Order L&O/48/22 of 28 April 2022.
- Protesters say Jantar Mantar's value was its proximity to Parliament, government offices and the press. Activists quoted include Bhim Kumar (15+ years of protests) and Shabnam Hashmi (since 1975).
- A four-page order by a Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant recorded all parties, including petitioners, as favouring a "spacious, open" alternative site with basic amenities. It asked the competent authority to consider this.
- The petitions challenged the government's move to restrict access into and within the capital to halt the 10 Oct protests demanding the CEC's resignation.
- The CJI remarked that central Delhi had no washroom, medical or drinking-water facilities. The court and government also discussed inconvenience to commuters.
- A similar suggestion was made in August to Solicitor General Tushar Mehta.
- The petition had sought discontinuation of Jantar Mantar as the usual venue and designation of Ramlila Maidan or another large ground as the principal site.
- The protests demand rollback of the special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls and the resignation of CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The 12 Oct INDIA-bloc rally began at the Constitution Club of India on Rafi Marg and was joined by AISA, SFI and KYS.
- The Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) leaders Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka wrote to the DCP, New Delhi, seeking a date within 24 hours for a peaceful protest at Jantar Mantar. They called the move an assault on the fundamental right to protest and warned the "entire country will become Jantar Mantar". Founder Abhijeet Dipke also said Jantar Mantar is a "spirit of resistance".
- Jairam Ramesh called the move a sign of "extreme panic". Akhilesh Yadav called it the BJP government's "biggest defeat".
- The Delhi High Court will hear two petitions on 13 Oct, on the closure and the alleged assault on protesters during the 10 Oct protests.
- Thousands were detained on 10, 11 and 12 Oct, including journalists, youth-organisation members and minors.
- On 12 Oct, Naujawan Bharat Sabha, RWPI and Disha Students' Organisation held a flash-mob rally at Barakhamba Road against the denotification. They were stopped at Sansad Marg and detained.
- Detainees alleged beatings, verbal abuse, denial of water and phones being taken. One RWPI member said detainees fainted in a police van. Disha member Aranya was allegedly held by the throat on 10 Oct and isolated and beaten on 11 Oct. Journalist M. Rajshekhar said he escaped assault only by identifying himself as a non-protester.
- One detainee, Arjun Unnikrishan, described being taken to an "isolated, enclosed police camp near the LIC building". Another group was taken to Pandwalan Khurd.
- Rajya Sabha MP A.A. Rahim moved the SC alleging illegal detention, "secret transportation" in compartmentalised vehicles, and custodial torture of DYFI leaders and activists on 11 Oct at Connaught Place.
- He alleges a bus was driven to a guarded space near a Daryaganj restaurant, and detainees were put in a police van divided into five cells and beaten. Several personnel wore no name badges. Release came at about 7:30 p.m.
- He seeks a declaration that curtained or sealed vehicles as places of detention are illegal, binding guidelines, a court-monitored inquiry, FIRs against officers and compensation. The Home Ministry is the respondent.
- Dipke said that during preventive detention police told him of his grandmother's death and that they had come with arrest papers at 3:30 a.m. He calls this mental torture and wants the unedited footage released.
- Police sources said about 300 social-media posts allegedly spreading rumours or creating unrest were taken down, as police monitor platforms to curb misinformation.
- Bengaluru: at least 100 people were detained when they tried to march to the Karnataka CEO's office. Journalist Aakar Patel was detained and three photographers were manhandled. A senior officer said Freedom Park is the only designated protest site, so protesters outside it had to be detained.
- On Sunday (11 Oct) the SC held an "extraordinary, exceptional" hearing. It directed the Union and Delhi Police to stop illegal detentions and allow free movement of people, traffic, Metro and rail services, "subject to law and public order".
- On 12 Oct the CJI, on a three-judge Bench with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana, said peaceful protest must happen but the SC should not be dragged in. He wanted no obstruction to lawyers, staff or litigants and said every Bar member can protest at the identified locations.
- The Supreme Court Bar Association (president Pradeep Rai) raised illegal detention of lawyers and suspension of the Internet. Senior advocate A.N.S. Nadkarni's petition for a lawyer sought similar protection. Senior advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan said he was still waiting for the Bench to admonish police to maintain restraint.
- The petitioners said none of the Section 163 BNSS prohibitory orders was publicly available. The SC will hear all three petitions on 13 Oct.
- On 12 Oct the INDIA bloc's rally from Constitution Club to the Supreme Court proceeded under prohibitory restrictions under Section 163 BNSS and heavy deployment. Delhi Police and CRPF personnel facilitated it and barricades were opened at the Shangri-La roundabout. Students noted the contrast with the previous two days.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Protest has no separate article. It is derived from freedom of speech (Article 19(1)(a)) and the right to assemble peaceably without arms (Article 19(1)(b)). These are subject to reasonable restrictions under Article 19(2) and 19(3), chiefly public order.
- The legal test is regulation versus prohibition. The State may regulate time, place and manner, but may not prohibit protest outright or exclude it from effective venues. This is the question behind a venue shift.
- Detention and policing engage Articles 21 and 22 and the limits on use of force. Prohibitory orders under Section 163 BNSS must be public, proportionate and evidence-based.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Fundamental Rights (Article 19(1)(a), 19(1)(b), 19(3)), Articles 21-22; role of police and judiciary; GS3 – Internal Security (law and order); GS4 – ethics of policing
Background primer
Right to protest (Article 19(1)(a) and (b))
- What it is:
- the freedom to peacefully express dissent and assemble, which the courts treat as a fundamental right.
- Why it matters:
- protest acts as a feedback and accountability mechanism in a democracy.
Section 163, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS)
- What it is:
- the provision under which authorities impose prohibitory restrictions on assemblies for public order. It is the BNSS successor to Section 144 CrPC.
Delhi Police Standing Order L&O/48/22 (28 April 2022)
Additional context
- In the MKSS case the SC noted that Jantar Mantar had been used for years and that Ramlila Maidan alone might not be enough. It directed the Commissioner of Police to frame guidelines for regulated protests at Jantar Mantar and the Boat Club area.
- The 2018 ruling struck down the NGT's blanket ban on protests in central Delhi and ordered police to frame balanced regulations instead.
- Amit Sahni v. Commissioner of Police (2020, the Shaheen Bagh matter) held that the right to dissent is constitutional but public spaces cannot be occupied indefinitely.
- Anita Thakur v. State of J&K (2016) held that excessive police force against protesters violates fundamental rights.
- In Re: Ramlila Maidan Incident (2012) protected peaceful assembly against arbitrary police action.
Mains dimensions
- Regulation versus prohibition. The SC in 2018 accepted regulation of Jantar Mantar but not a blanket exclusion. Shifting designated sites 4 to 15 km from Parliament raises whether the right is being preserved in form but diluted in substance. The 2018 Court itself doubted that Ramlila Maidan alone would be adequate. Against this, the State relies on commuter inconvenience and the 9 Oct SC remarks about the lack of amenities.
- Judicial signalling. On 9 Oct the Court and the Union agreed an alternative, amenity-equipped site was needed. The Court asked the "competent authority" to consider it. The Court did not itself fix a site. The police then designated three grounds 4 to 15 km away, which raises the question of whether they match the "spacious, open" site with amenities that the order envisaged. The petition itself had sought Ramlila Maidan or another large ground as the principal venue.
- Proportionality of policing. Mass detentions of students, journalists and minors, sealed vehicles, allegations of custodial violence, denial of water and Internet suspension (alleged by the Bar) raise Article 21 and 22 issues. The next-day facilitation of the INDIA bloc's mass march invites questions of equal treatment between organised parties and unorganised youth protesters. Students asked why they needed political leaders alongside them to be heard.
- Transparency of preventive orders. Section 163 BNSS orders were reportedly not public. Publication is basic to being able to challenge restrictions.
- Protest, courts and political parties. The CJI's plea that the Supreme Court not be made a site for agitation reflects institutional-neutrality concerns. The Court was simultaneously hearing petitions against the government's access restrictions and the detentions.
- Federal spread. Similar detentions in Bengaluru, where only Freedom Park is designated, show that designated-site regimes can narrow protest everywhere.
- Information control. Takedown of about 300 posts is a form of speech regulation that needs a clear legal basis and judicial review.
- Way forward. Amenity-equipped sites near the seat of government, published and time-bound SOPs, independent oversight of detention conditions (including inquiry into the DYFI allegations), and clear Section 163 BNSS publication norms.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks (250 words):** "The right to peaceful protest is a fundamental right but is subject to reasonable restrictions. In the light of the recent denotification of Jantar Mantar as a designated protest venue, discuss how courts have balanced the right to protest against public order and the rights of residents."
Related topics
- Article 19(1)(a)-(c), Article 19(2)-(3) and the doctrine of reasonable restrictions and proportionality
- Articles 21 and 22: arrest, detention and D.K. Basu guidelines
- Preventive detention versus preventive arrest, and Section 163 BNSS (earlier Section 144 CrPC)
- Shaheen Bagh (2020) and the farmers' protest cases
- Police reforms and accountability
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 13 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs