BrainParrot

Comparing SIR 2002-04 and 2025-26

GS2Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 13 October 2026

Summary

  • Protests against the SIR of electoral rolls have been renewed. Former Election Commissioners and Supreme Court judges have questioned the exercise in its present form. Some former judges and bureaucrats defend it.
  • On 12 Oct the Supreme Court said it had neither approved nor disapproved the changes to Form 6. Its 27 May judgment dealt only with the Bihar pilot SIR, and the changes came later, in July.
  • On the same day Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA-bloc leaders filed a petition seeking disclosure of the Election Commission's internal records on the SIR. Punjab's final rolls were also published, and the Keralam Assembly passed a resolution seeking the CEC's removal.
  • The explainer compares the 2002-04 SIR guidelines with the current exercise and proposes an audit and a slower, door-to-door process.

UPSC relevance: GS2 – Polity: Election Commission, electoral rolls, Representation of the People Act, right to vote

Key facts for Prelims

  • Article 324 (ECI's superintendence, direction and control) and Article 326 (adult suffrage, 18 years).
  • Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950 permits a special revision of the roll "for any constituency or part of a constituency". The proviso keeps the existing roll in force until the revision is completed.
  • Section 16 of the RP Act disqualifies a non-citizen from being enrolled.
  • Section 28 of the RP Act gives rule-making power to the Central Government. Section 31 punishes false declarations.
  • Form 6A is for overseas electors. Form 6 is for new electors, Form 7 for objection/deletion and Form 8 for shifting or correction.
  • Under Rule 25, rolls are revised under Section 21(2) intensively, summarily or partly each, as the ECI directs.
  • Lal Babu Hussein and Others (1995) is cited in the 2002 SIR guidelines. It requires the ERO to give adequate "probative value" to an applicant's presence in the existing roll.
  • The ECI's Manual on Electoral Rolls (2023) requires a notice to a traceable shifted elector. For an untraceable one, a notice is pasted at the last known address in the presence of adult witnesses, and deletion follows only after the notice period.
  • Past SIRs: eight earlier occasions, the last in 2002-04. The SC held in May 2026 that the ECI may order SIR for "many" or "all" constituencies in a State.

Data and details

  • Door-to-door verification used a preliminary list generated from the existing roll. Elected Panchayat members could help voluntarily.
  • Supervisors had to randomly check at least 25% of households covered by enumerators. Where an enumerator reported repeated visits to a locked house, the supervisor had to visit.
  • AEROs, EROs and DEOs had to check at least 12%, 5% and 2% of households respectively.
  • Onus of proving citizenship lay with a first-time applicant, tempered by Lal Babu Hussein (1995).
  • Shifted electors were treated as a transfer, not a deletion. The entry was struck through and marked "S", with a record of who reported the shift. Whole-family shifts needed personal supervisor verification. All areas were enumerated at the same time, so shifted electors were enrolled at the new address in the same exercise. The CEO acted as a clearing house to delete the old entry. Only people missed at the new address had to apply during claims and objections.
  • Bulk claims or objections by any individual, organisation or party were to be summarily rejected. The final roll was to be prepared only after all claims and objections were disposed of.
  • Electors not found, or who did not return the form, were excluded from the draft roll even if they had voted before.
  • "Shifted" electors were not re-enrolled at the new address through the same exercise. They must file Form 8 at the new place of residence, or apply afresh through Form 6, which is meant for new electors.
  • The Bihar SIR notification mandates only 10% random verification by supervisors, plus regular ERO monitoring meetings with AEROs, Supervisors and BLOs.
  • Electors must trace themselves or a parent to the rolls of the last intensive revision, nearly two decades ago, or produce citizenship documents. The explainer says this shifts the onus onto electors.
  • Software-generated "logical discrepancies" included spelling differences, more than six voters linked to one ancestor, and parent-child age gaps outside 15-45 years. The explainer says these arbitrarily excluded lakhs of eligible voters.
  • Form 7 objections were reportedly filed in bulk. On 9 Oct the ECI issued instructions capping the number an individual may file.
  • Legal concerns: the validity of the declaration attached to Form 6, the use of Form 6 to re-enrol electors deleted from draft rolls, and the cumbersome disposal of a large number of appeals.
  • About 13.3 crore voters were deleted.
  • About 2.7 crore (20%) were due to death.
  • 1.01 crore were flagged as duplicates. The body text says 8% and the "Gist" box says 7.6%.
  • About 9.5 crore (71%) fall under "absent, shifted and others". The article says many of them may be eligible for re-enrolment.
  • The explainer's recommendations: a detailed audit of finalised rolls, expedited re-enrolment claims including home visits, door-to-door enumeration, and final rolls only after all claims and objections are disposed of.
  • It also says the proviso to Section 21(3) lets the pre-SIR rolls stay in force for upcoming State elections until SIR rolls are completed after due process.
  • The SC clarified on 12 Oct (Justice Joymalya Bagchi, on the Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant) that the 27 May judgment, which was entirely about the Bihar pilot, pre-dated the Form 6 changes introduced in July.
  • The July changes required applicants to give ancestry details or linkage to previous SIR rolls on the ECINet portal.
  • The petition is by Priya Mishra against the Union government. Her counsel recalled the CJI's oral remark of 5 Oct that modified Form 6 was "not approved by us".
  • The 27 May judgment, authored by CJI Kant, said Form 6 under the 1960 Rules sets a framework of documentation tailored to revision under Section 21(2).
  • Form 6 is a statutory document in the Schedule to the 1960 Rules, so modifications should come only through proper lawmaking.
  • The ECI's 24 June 2025 notification included a Declaration Form (Annexure D, paras 4 and 15) to be filled with Form 6 or Form 8. It classified applicants by date of birth in line with the Citizenship Act and asked for documents.
  • Two sitting Election Commissioners called the Form 6 changes "illegal and unauthorised" (per the Edit piece).
  • The ECI's 26 Sept press note said the declaration was attached to Form 6 for the SIR and "upheld by the Hon'ble Supreme Court". It also said the Rules-prescribed forms apply in non-SIR periods.
  • The ECI's 1 Oct 2026 letter to CEOs said anyone not enrolled, or deleted, can apply at any time. BLOs must compare the current roll with the pre-SIR roll, list the missing electors, and make house visits to facilitate Form 6 enrolment.
  • Form 6 with the Declaration continues in States where SIR is ongoing. It is used without the Declaration in States where SIR is complete.
  • Rahul Gandhi (Leader of the Opposition, Lok Sabha) and other INDIA-bloc leaders filed a petition through senior advocate A.M. Singhvi and advocate Prasanna S. The other petitioners include Saugata Roy, Akhilesh Yadav, Tejashwi Yadav, Sanjay Raut, M.A. Baby, D. Raja, Mahua Majhi, Supriya Sule and E.T. Mohammed Basheer.
  • The petition seeks full disclosure of "files, agendas, minutes, notings and objections" recorded by Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi. It also seeks ECINET and ERONET access logs and the complete file of the 24 June 2025 decision.
  • It asks for an interim suspension of the SIR and an independent panel to audit deletions and modifications. The deletions are described as about 13 crore voters.
  • The CJI had declined the opposition's request for a meeting. His letter invited a filing on 12 Oct between 10:30 a.m. and 4:30 p.m. and promised the earliest possible hearing. The petition was technically filed at 4:37 p.m. Pending petitions on identical issues were listed for 13 Oct.
  • The INDIA bloc's "March for Democracy" ran from the Constitution Club to near the Supreme Court, where police stopped it. Congress said 2.5 lakh people took part. Rahul Gandhi said there is "one protest", aimed at removing CEC Gyanesh Kumar, and urged the CEC to "turn approver". He also claimed that 200 officers of the government are in touch with the Opposition.
  • Punjab: final rolls for all 117 Assembly constituencies were published after SIR. About 13.60 lakh names went unrecorded (relocation, absence, death or duplicates). The draft roll of 13 Aug 2026 had 1,93,94,435 electors.
  • The Keralam Assembly passed a resolution seeking CEC Gyanesh Kumar's removal and more transparency in the ECI. The ruling UDF and the Opposition LDF supported it, and BJP amendments were rejected. The resolution also urged the Centre and ECI to fix SIR defects.
  • Alleged institutional pattern:
  • a lax approach to Model Code violations in the 2019 general election;
  • a hurried December 2024 rule change, after a Punjab and Haryana High Court disclosure order, allowing the ECI to withhold video footage of voting after scheduled polling hours;
  • notices to parties over leaders' MCC violations in 2024, and exoneration of star campaigners;
  • dismissal of the Leader of the Opposition's complaints about rolls, with a demand that he file an affidavit or apologise;
  • the June 2025 SIR on nearly a billion electors.
  • It also cites the December 2023 selection law as damaging credibility.
  • Two fellow Election Commissioners alleged "illegalities": the Form 6 changes and denial of ECINet access to EROs.
  • Form 7 was allegedly misused for bulk deletion applications in Uttarakhand, Karnataka and other States.
  • Eleven judges heading Appellate Tribunals in West Bengal said the technical system impeded their work. The Maharashtra CEO flagged shortcomings that stopped EROs from exercising their legally mandated judgement. EROs in Goa emailed similar complaints.
  • After The Indian Express's 23 Sept revelations, the unanswered question is who filed more than 16 lakh objections against electors validly included.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • Article 324 vests the ECI with superintendence, direction and control over the preparation of electoral rolls and the conduct of elections. Article 326 gives universal adult suffrage to citizens aged 18 and above.
  • Section 21 of the RP Act, 1950 governs roll revision. Sub-section (2) is the ordinary periodic revision. Sub-section (3) lets the ECI, notwithstanding (2), direct a special revision for reasons to be recorded, "in such manner as it may think fit". The existing roll stays in force until the special revision is complete.
  • The Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 prescribe the forms and procedure (Form 6, 7, 8). Because the Act's rule-making power (Section 28) belongs to the Central Government, the central point of the Form 6 controversy is who may alter a statutory form.
  • The wider issue is the balance between roll "purity" (removing the dead, duplicates and ineligible entries) and inclusion (the right to be on the roll). It also touches the institutional trust a constitutional body needs.

Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional/statutory bodies (ECI); Representation of the People Act; electoral reforms; GS2 – Governance: transparency and accountability

Background primer

Election Commission of India (ECI)

What it is:
the constitutional body that supervises the preparation of electoral rolls and conducts elections to Parliament and State Legislatures. Article 324(1) grants it superintendence, direction and control of elections.
Founded:
25 January 1950, with the Constitution coming into force. The need was a single independent authority to run free and fair elections for the new republic.
Mandate:
roll preparation and revision, election conduct, enforcement of the Model Code of Conduct, and registration and oversight of parties.
Why it matters:
elections must be insulated from executive control so that the vote is free and fair.

Special Intensive Revision (SIR)

What it is:
a house-to-house, large-scale revision of electoral rolls. It is legally enabled by Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950, and governed by Article 324(1).

Forms under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960

Additional context

  • In the ADR v. ECI case (2025) the Supreme Court held that the ECI has power to conduct SIR under Article 324 read with the RP Act, 1950 and its Rules. It found the SIR satisfied proportionality: a legitimate purpose, non-excessive means and the least restrictive option.
  • The Court said the ECI may examine questions bearing on citizenship, but this does not divest anyone of citizenship claims or pre-empt the competent authority under the Citizenship Act.
  • The Court rejected the argument that special revisions can only be done in isolated constituencies. It held that a statewide SIR was proportionate to the scale of the problem in Bihar. The article reports that the ECI may order SIR for "many" or "all" constituencies in a State.
  • Bihar's Phase I numbers: the draft roll was released on 1 Aug 2025 and had 7.24 crore electors, over 65 lakh fewer than the 7.9 crore recorded on 24 June 2025.
  • Bihar's document requirement varied by birth date: those born before 1 July 1987 needed their own document, those born between 1 July 1987 and 2 December 2004 needed their own plus one parent's, and those born after 2 December 2004 needed their own plus both parents'.
  • The Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 were framed by the Central Government, after consulting the ECI, under Section 28 of the RP Act. This supports the Edit piece's argument about who can amend a statutory form.
  • Section 24 of the RP Act provides appeals against orders of the Electoral Registration Officer. The first appeal lies to the District Magistrate (or an ADM, executive magistrate, collector or officer of equivalent rank) under clause (a). A second appeal against the DM's order lies to the Chief Electoral Officer under clause (b).

Mains dimensions

  • Legal basis versus procedure. The power is settled: Article 324 with Section 21(3), as upheld by the SC in May 2026. The live questions are procedural. The Edit piece argues the Form 6 declaration goes beyond the 1960 Rules and that only the Centre can amend them under Section 28. The SC has now said it did not approve the modified Form 6 and will examine it.
  • Onus and exclusion. The 2002 guidelines placed the onus on first-time applicants and gave weight to presence in the existing roll. The current requirement to trace oneself or a parent to the last intensive roll is seen as shifting the onus onto ordinary electors. The 2002 "S" mark, transfer at the new address and CEO clearing house contrast with the current practice of excluding "shifted" electors from the draft roll.
  • Verification rigour. Supervisors had to check 25% of households in 2002 and only 10% in the Bihar notification. This gap is used to argue weaker safeguards. Software-generated "logical discrepancies" (age gaps, more than six voters per ancestor) replaced human judgement, and Appellate Tribunal judges and the Maharashtra CEO say the technical system restricts EROs.
  • Scale of deletion. About 13.3 crore voters were deleted, 71% of them under "absent, shifted and others". This pool is where wrongful disenfranchisement is most likely, so audit and home-visit re-enrolment are proposed. Punjab's 13.60 lakh unrecorded names show the trend continuing.
  • Abuse of objection forms. Bulk Form 7 filings, a 16 lakh+ objection question and a cap introduced only on 9 Oct. The 2002 rule of summary rejection of bulk objections is the benchmark.
  • Citizenship through the back door? Critics fear a quasi-NRC. The SC (ADR v. ECI) says the ECI can examine citizenship only for roll entitlement and cannot decide citizenship itself.
  • Institutional credibility and federal politics. The Edit piece places the SIR within a longer pattern: MCC enforcement, the 2023 selection law, the 2024 footage rule, and dissent within the Commission itself. Opposition parties have turned to street protest and legislative resolutions (Keralam), and Rahul Gandhi has openly framed the aim as removal of the CEC. Supporters, including some former judges and bureaucrats, defend the SIR as necessary for roll hygiene. The explainer's compromise is to keep pre-SIR rolls in force pending a due-process revision.
  • Way forward. An independent audit, expedited re-enrolment, door-to-door enumeration, finalisation only after all claims and objections are disposed of, transparency of ECI records, and rule-making through the proper statutory route.

Possible Mains question

**GS2, 15 marks (250 words):** "The Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls has been defended as a roll-cleansing exercise but criticised for shifting the burden of proof onto voters. Compare the 2002-04 and 2025-26 exercises and critically examine the legal and procedural safeguards needed to protect the right to vote."

Related topics

  • Article 324, ECI independence, and the 2023 CEC/EC appointment law
  • Citizenship Act, 1955 and the NRC debate
  • RP Act 1950 versus RP Act 1951 (rolls versus conduct of elections and disqualification)
  • Right to vote: constitutional or statutory right, and Article 326
  • Form 6B and Aadhaar-EPIC linkage
  • Model Code of Conduct

Topics: GS2Polity

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 13 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs