Why stubble fires keep coming back
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 9 October 2026
Summary
- The article argues that stubble burning in northwest India is the combined result of three things: a groundwater-saving law (PPSSWA 2009) that pushed the paddy harvest later, a paddy-wheat incentive structure (MSP procurement and free or cheap power), and costly residue-management options.
- It compares Punjab's mostly machine-based (in-situ) approach with Haryana's cash-incentive model. It also questions whether the reported 90% fall in burning (2025 vs 2022) is accurate, because the satellite protocol used to measure it is limited.
- Its recommended fix is a mix of in-situ and ex-situ measures, medium- to long-term diversification away from paddy, and better measurement. It says penal provisions alone are unlikely to work.
Key facts for Prelims
- PPSSWA 2009 is a Punjab State law that bars paddy nursery sowing before 10 May and transplanting before 10 June. This is a groundwater-conservation measure whose side effect is a later harvest.
- Combine harvesters (leave ~1 foot of stubble) and the PUSA-44 variety (higher yield, 150–160 days to harvest) squeeze the paddy–wheat gap.
- In-situ measures: CRM machines (Happy Seeder, Super Seeder, Rotavator), short-duration rice varieties, direct seeding of rice (DSR). Ex-situ measures: using residue for bio-ethanol and compressed biogas (CBG).
- The National Green Tribunal ruled in 2018 that stubble-burning farmers could be excluded from MSP benefits. The Supreme Court upheld this view in 2023.
- CPCB deployed flying squads during the 2025 burning season. CAQM has directed that complaints be filed before the judiciary against officials responsible for lack of effective monitoring.
- CREAMS protocol = Consortium for Research on Agroecosystem Monitoring and Modeling from Space, built on NASA's MODIS and VIIRS polar-orbiting satellites. Polar satellites see India only at fixed times (10:30 am–1:30 pm) and capture active fires only.
- Geostationary satellites give continuous observation of the same area. A November 2025 Current Science study led by ISRO scientists used them.
- Stubble-burning emissions: particulate matter, carbon monoxide, VOCs and carcinogenic substances. Soil nutrients lost: nitrogen, sulphur, potash, phosphorus and micronutrients.
- The NASA GRACE satellite (gravity-based groundwater measurement) study of 2009 covered Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan.
- Prelims-relevant bodies: CAQM (statutory), CPCB, Parliamentary Committee on air quality, ISRO.
Data and details
- Scale: Punjab and Haryana together produce about 29 million metric tonnes of paddy straw. Burning runs from early October to end-November across northwest India (Punjab, Haryana, parts of UP).
- Groundwater: In 2012, about 73% of Punjab's cropped area was irrigated by groundwater, with a deficit of 14.31 billion cubic metres met by over-withdrawal. Groundwater fell by 0.36 m a year between 1999 and 2009. NASA GRACE showed Punjab, Haryana and Rajasthan lost 109 cubic km of groundwater between 2002 and 2008, then the largest depletion in the world.
- PPSSWA penalty: ₹10,000 per hectare for every month of contravention. Officers could destroy early-sown paddy, and their actions were exempt from legal scrutiny.
- Calendar squeeze: The paddy harvest moves to late October/early November, leaving only a 10–15 day window before wheat sowing.
- Procurement (2012–2024): Paddy procurement averaged about 37% of production nationally, against 87% in Punjab and 74% in Haryana. Wheat was 30% nationally, 70% in Punjab and 63% in Haryana. The national average includes these two States, so the real gap is even larger. Power is free in Punjab and almost free in Haryana.
- Cost of solutions: Happy/Super Seeders need a 60-HP tractor that sits idle most of the year. Hiring one costs about ₹10,000, with a long wait. Ex-situ measures cost ₹1,500–₹2,500 per acre.
- Enforcement 2025: 31 CPCB flying squads covered 18 districts in Punjab and 13 in Haryana. About 10,500 field functionaries were deployed in Punjab and 10,000 in Haryana.
- Haryana incentives: ₹1,000/acre for CRM use, ₹4,000/acre for direct seeding of rice, ₹7,000/acre for diversification to other crops, plus incentives for well-performing panchayats.
- CAQM's 2025 observation on Punjab: More is needed on timely CRM machinery, support for CBG plants and other straw-using industries, and enforcement. Punjab mostly adopted in-situ CRM with limited ex-situ initiatives.
- Claimed result: Punjab and Haryana together recorded a 90% fall in burning incidents in the 2025 paddy harvest against the same period of 2022 (Lok Sabha starred question No. 18, 1 December 2025). The article advises caution on measurement.
- Alternative estimate: A 2025 International Forum for Environment, Sustainability and Technology report, using multiple satellites to compute the actual fire-affected area, found a more gradual reduction of around 30%.
- Evasion: The Current Science study (November 2025, ISRO scientists) found farmers shifting burning to evening hours to avoid polar-satellite passes.
- Parliamentary Committee: It said penalising farmers should be the last resort. It recommended a minimum price covering all costs for selling stubble for ex-situ use, to guarantee farmers' income.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Static concept 1: Policy trade-offs and unintended consequences. A law made for one objective (groundwater conservation) shifted the harvest calendar into the cool, still-air winter months, creating an air-pollution problem. This is a standard case of cross-sectoral policy conflict (water vs air vs agriculture).
- Static concept 2: Market-distorting incentives. Assured procurement at MSP and free or near-free power make paddy and wheat the rational choice for farmers. That locks in a water-intensive monoculture whatever the regulation says.
- Static concept 3: Command-and-control vs incentive-based regulation. Penalising farmers (exclusion from MSP, fines) is set against positive incentives (per-acre payments). The article also stresses the risk of collusion between farmers and officials, which produces apparent rather than real reductions.
- Static concept 4: Remote sensing and measurement validity. What you measure, and when, shapes the policy conclusion. Polar-orbit snapshots versus geostationary continuous observation is a concrete S&T example.
Syllabus mapping: GS3 – Environment: air pollution, conservation & degradation; GS3 – Agriculture: cropping patterns, MSP/procurement, subsidies, irrigation; GS2 – Governance: Centre–State coordination, statutory regulators; GS3 – S&T: remote sensing applications.
Background primer
Stubble burning (crop residue burning)
- What it is:
- Setting fire to the leftover lower portion of crop plants after harvest. It is mainly paddy straw in Punjab and Haryana, and it peaks from October to November.
Punjab Preservation of Sub-Soil Water Act, 2009 (PPSSWA)
- What it is:
- A Punjab law that prohibits sowing the paddy nursery before 10 May and transplanting paddy before a notified date (10 June in the article). The Act empowers an authorised officer to direct destruction of paddy sown or transplanted early, at the farmer's expense.
- Founded:
- The Act received the Governor's assent on 2 April 2009 (Punjab Act No. 6 of 2009). It followed a 2008 ordinance.
- Mandate:
- Align paddy water demand with monsoon rainfall rather than pumped groundwater.
Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM) in NCR and Adjoining Areas
- What it is:
- A statutory body mandated to coordinate, plan and implement measures for preventing and controlling air pollution in the NCR and adjoining areas.
- Founded:
- It was formed under the CAQM in NCR and Adjoining Areas Act, 2021, which also dissolved the Environment Pollution (Prevention and Control) Authority (EPCA) set up in 1998. The 2021 Bill replaced an earlier ordinance.
- Mandate:
- It coordinates actions of Delhi, Haryana, Punjab, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh, frames action plans, and issues binding directions to State governments and local authorities. It has overriding authority over CPCB and State PCBs within its jurisdiction. It may impose environmental compensation on farmers who burn stubble (Section 15 of the CAQM Act).
- Why it matters:
- Air pollution is not localised, so inter-State and inter-city coordination is needed.
Crop Residue Management (CRM) Scheme (Central Sector, Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare)
- What it is:
- A Central Sector Scheme introduced from 2018-19 to support Punjab, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh and NCT of Delhi in tackling stubble-burning pollution and subsidising residue-management machinery.
- Mandate:
- Assistance of 50% for farmers buying CRM machinery, and 80% for cooperative societies, FPOs and Panchayats setting up Custom Hiring Centres.
- Why it matters:
- Farm Machinery Banks for custom hiring offset the high cost of individual ownership on small holdings.
MSP and public procurement (basic concept)
- What it is:
- The Centre's announced minimum support price, with government agencies buying grain at that price. In practice, assured procurement is concentrated in a few States, which skews the cropping choice, as the article's procurement shares show.
Additional context
- The standard measurement protocol. ISRO developed a Standard Protocol for estimating crop-residue burning fire events from satellite data, in consultation with State Remote Sensing Centres and IARI. CAQM issued it in August 2021. IARI's CREAMS Laboratory publishes daily fire-event data for Haryana, Delhi, Punjab, UP, MP and Rajasthan on this basis.
- CAQM itself flagged the evasion concern. A CAQM document noted that while burning events fell under the standard protocol, late-evening burning was reportedly occurring to evade satellite detection. It also stressed expanding drone and ground-based monitoring.
- PPSSWA was later amended. A document on the NGT website records that the Act was amended in 2014 to move the cut-off dates to 15 May (sowing) and 15 June (transplanting), after short-duration varieties became available.
- Enforcement lever. In November 2024, following repeated Supreme Court directions, CAQM doubled the fines (environmental compensation) on farmers who burn stubble, with the rate depending on landholding size.
Mains dimensions
- Policy-conflict causality: PPSSWA 2009 solved a groundwater problem but delayed the harvest into winter. A narrow window and combine-harvester residue made burning "almost a necessity". It is a case of siloed policy design.
- Incentive structure as the root cause: Procurement of 87% (Punjab) and 74% (Haryana) of paddy, against a 37% national average, plus free power, discourages diversification despite falling water tables. Regulation (PPSSWA) cannot succeed against subsidies that pull the other way.
- Cost and access barriers to technology: The 60-HP tractor requirement, the ₹10,000 hiring cost with waiting time, and ₹1,500–₹2,500 per acre for ex-situ options. A strictly punitive approach ignores that burning is the cheapest option for small farmers.
- Punjab vs Haryana — governance comparison: Haryana pairs in-situ and ex-situ measures with cash incentives, including ₹7,000/acre for diversification. Punjab leans on in-situ CRM, and CAQM noted gaps in machinery availability and enforcement. This fits the Parliamentary Committee's incentive-first recommendation.
- Punitive tools and their limits: NGT (2018) and the Supreme Court (2023) allow MSP exclusion, and CAQM wants officials pursued for poor monitoring. The author warns of perverse incentives, where collusion between farmers and officials leads to "showing" reductions rather than achieving them.
- Measurement and data integrity: The CREAMS protocol relies on MODIS/VIIRS overpasses (10:30 am–1:30 pm) that miss evening fires. The 90% fall in the official figure compares with about 30% on a multi-satellite fire-area basis. Policy credibility depends on combining polar and geostationary data.
- Way forward: Use short-term in-situ and ex-situ measures, a guaranteed price for straw to make ex-situ viable, crop diversification via procurement and power reform, panchayat-level incentives, and improved measurement methodology.
- Health and soil costs: Smog with particulates, CO, VOCs and carcinogens harms health. Nutrient loss, and loss of soil moisture and organic content, raises fertiliser use in the next cycle.
Possible Mains question
**GS3, 15 marks:** "Stubble burning in northwest India is not merely a farmer's choice but the outcome of a policy and incentive framework. Examine the factors behind its persistence and evaluate the effectiveness of the measures adopted by Punjab and Haryana."
Related topics
- Commission for Air Quality Management Act, 2021; EPCA; National Clean Air Programme; GRAP
- Minimum Support Price, CACP, public procurement and the Food Corporation of India; crop diversification schemes
- Groundwater depletion: Central Ground Water Board, Jal Shakti schemes, Atal Bhujal Yojana
- National Green Tribunal (powers, environmental compensation) and the "polluter pays" principle
- Remote sensing: polar vs geostationary satellites, ISRO, IARI
- Compressed Biogas / SATAT and the ethanol blending programme
Topics: GS3Environment
All current affairs of 9 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs