Can voters caught in tribunal cases be re-enrolled, Bengal CEO asks ECI
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 8 October 2026
Summary
- After the ECI's 2 October instruction, West Bengal's CEO asked whether 38 lakh+ voters with appeals pending before the SIR Appellate Tribunals can join the new re-enrolment drive. A senior ECI official gave no clear answer.
- The ECI told CEOs of all States/UTs where SIR is complete or under way to compare pre-SIR and current rolls. Eligible left-out electors are to be enrolled through Form 6 within a month.
- In Bengal, special camps and a CEO notice invite left-out ASDD voters and new 18+ voters to file Form 6. Opposition leaders called it an admission of wrongful deletions, and the CEO's office called the claims misleading.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: ECI's superintendence over rolls and elections. Article 326: adult suffrage (citizen, 18+, not disqualified).
- RP Act, 1950, Section 21(3): power to order special revision. Section 16 of the same Act bars non-citizens from enrolment.
- Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 govern enrolment and revision procedure.
- Form 6 = inclusion in the roll. Forms 7 and 8 = objection/deletion and correction/shifting. The latter two are standard Prelims knowledge and sit with Form 6 in the claims-and-objections window.
- ASDD = Absent, Shifted, Dead, Duplicate.
- BLO = Booth Level Officer; CEO = Chief Electoral Officer (State level).
- West Bengal's SIR was part of Phase II.
Data and details
- The ECI directed on 2 October that CEOs compare pre-SIR and current rolls and enrol eligible left-out persons through Form 6 within one month.
- At Tuesday's meeting, the ECI told CEOs to proceed on a war footing, starting with camps and then BLO door-to-door visits. Many CEOs asked about the time limit and protocols.
- Bengal CEO's query: do the 38 lakh+ voters with cases stuck in appellate tribunals qualify? The ECI official in the videoconference had no clear answer. Earlier ECI sources had told The Hindu the drive would not apply to tribunal cases.
- Tribunals have cleared 1.26 lakh of 38.31 lakh appeals, about 3%.
- The ECI set up 19 tribunals in March. Only 16 are functional, because three retired judges quit citing functional issues. Their posts are vacant.
- The tribunals follow the SC-supervised adjudication of roughly 60 lakh "doubtful and pending" cases by judicial officers from a Calcutta HC list. The Court directed a separate appellate body on 10 March.
- Over 58 lakh names marked ASDD were left out of the draft roll published in December 2025.
- Special camps have begun in Hooghly's Chanditala, Tarakeshwar and Chandannagar. The ASDD list is online on the CEO West Bengal site and on District Electoral Officer sites. Form 6 can be filed online or via BLOs.
- The Additional CEO, Arindam Niyogi, said the claim that Form 6 filers must be mapped to the 2002 roll is "complete misinformation". "No new voter has to be mapped."
- TMC MP Sagarika Ghose criticised the move as adding deleted voters only after the 2026 Assembly poll. The CEO's post called such claims misleading. Former State CEO Jawhar Sircar called the notice an "admission of guilt" over wrongful deletions.
- It is unclear whether the 27 lakh deleted from the final roll after adjudication found them "ineligible" can use Form 6.
Static–dynamic linkage
- Art. 324 gives the ECI superintendence, direction and control over electoral rolls and elections. Article 326 gives every citizen aged 18 or above, not otherwise disqualified, the right to be registered as an elector.
- The SIR is conducted under Section 21(3) of the RP Act, 1950, which gives the Commission discretion to overhaul rolls when ordinary revisions fall short.
- The tension is between roll "purity" (removing dead, shifted and duplicate entries) and universal adult franchise (no eligible citizen excluded). The appellate tribunals and Form 6 are the corrective, rights-protecting layer.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Representation of People Act, ECI, quasi-judicial bodies, electoral reforms; Prelims Polity – Elections.
Background primer
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls
- What it is:
- a focused, time-bound ECI exercise to update and verify electoral rolls. An intensive revision means fresh preparation of rolls through house-to-house verification by BLOs.
- Why it matters:
- no eligible citizen left out, and no ineligible person included.
Form 6
Judicially supervised appellate tribunals (West Bengal)
Additional context
- The Supreme Court had earlier deputed serving and former district judges to adjudicate claims of persons in the "logical discrepancy" list, and said orders of these judicial officers would be treated as orders of the court.
- The Court clarified that the mere pendency of an appeal gives no right to vote. Voters whose appeals were allowed before the cut-off dates were to be allowed to vote in the respective phase.
- After revision, the ECI put Bengal's electorate at over 7.04 crore, against 7.66 crore earlier, a reduction of more than 61 lakh.
- In ADR v. ECI the Supreme Court held that the ECI has the power to conduct SIR under Article 324 read with the RP Act, 1950. It also held that an ECI citizenship determination does not divest a person's claim to citizenship, which the competent authority decides.
Mains dimensions
- Franchise vs. roll integrity: the SIR aims to clean the rolls, but the Form 6 drive after the election cycle concedes that eligible people were left out. The Bengal figures are 58 lakh ASDD names in the draft roll and 27 lakh "ineligible" after adjudication.
- Capacity of the remedy: 38.31 lakh appeals, only about 3% cleared, 3 of 19 tribunals not functioning. Right without remedy is hollow, an access-to-justice and administrative-capacity problem.
- Unclear status of two groups: left-out ASDD voters (clearly invited to Form 6) versus voters in tribunal cases or declared "ineligible" (unclear). This legal ambiguity could be read as inconsistent treatment.
- Trust and politicisation: timing allegations from the TMC (Sagarika Ghose), Jawhar Sircar's "admission of guilt" charge and the CEO's rebuttal show the credibility strain on ECI.
- Quasi-judicial design: judges sitting as SIR adjudicators and tribunals, an unusual arrangement that tests the ECI's power under Article 324 alongside judicial oversight.
- Way forward: clear written protocol on tribunal-case voters, restoring the vacant tribunal posts, time-bound disposal, publication of reasons for deletion, and proactive outreach for migrants and the poor.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls seeks to ensure that no eligible voter is left out and no ineligible voter is included. Examine the challenges in balancing these two goals, with reference to the recent experience in West Bengal."
Related topics
- Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951 (qualifications, enrolment, disqualification)
- Article 324 plenary powers of the ECI and judicial review of ECI actions
- Citizenship Act and who decides citizenship (competent authority vs. ECI)
- Tribunals in India (Art. 323A/B) and access to justice
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 8 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs