Protests will go on until CEC resigns: Rahul
Published: · Updated:
Source: The Hindu, 8 October 2026
Summary
- Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi said protests will continue until Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar resigns over alleged "vote chori" (vote theft). This followed his second consecutive day of detention by Delhi Police on the way to a Jantar Mantar dharna.
- Opposition MPs and two Chief Ministers joined the INDIA bloc protest. Youth organisations called a separate agitation for 10 October demanding the CEC's resignation and a rollback of the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls.
- Related developments:
- An FIR was filed against Gandhi and others.
- The Congress called a "black day".
- The INDIA bloc has had no response to its request to meet the President.
- BJD distanced itself from an Odisha bandh call.
- Digvijaya Singh announced a yatra on "vote chori" and "chanda chori".
- Note: these are political allegations and demands. The notes record them as reported claims, not established facts.
Key facts for Prelims
- Article 324: superintendence, direction and control of elections vested in the ECI. Article 324(5): CEC removal as for a Supreme Court judge. Other ECs are removable only on the CEC's recommendation.
- CEC and Other ECs (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023: Section 11(2) mirrors the removal standard. The selection committee is PM, Leader of Opposition and a Union Minister. Term is six years or age 65. No re-appointment. Salary and service conditions equal the Cabinet Secretary's (earlier: a Supreme Court judge's).
- Removal motion: 100 LS or 50 RS signatures. Three-member inquiry committee under the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968. Special majority in both Houses. Order by the President.
- Grounds for removal: proved misbehaviour or incapacity. No CEC has ever been removed.
- SIR: Section 21(3) of the RPA 1950 lets the ECI direct a special revision "for reasons to be recorded". Section 16 of the RPA 1950 bars non-citizens from enrolment. Registration of Electors Rules, 1960.
- Article 326: universal adult suffrage for Lok Sabha and Assembly elections.
- Article 19(1)(a)/(b): free speech and peaceful assembly, with reasonable restrictions under Article 19(3).
- BNSS Section 163 (prohibitory orders in urgent cases of nuisance or apprehended danger) replaces Section 144 CrPC. BNSS Section 172 (detain/remove a person disregarding a lawful police direction) is a new provision with no CrPC counterpart.
- Jantar Mantar in New Delhi is a designated protest site.
- INDIA = Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance.
Data and details
- Timeline and numbers:
- Wednesday, 7 October: second day of detention for Gandhi and other leaders. A three-hour bus procession ended in an impromptu sit-in at a roundabout a couple of hundred metres from Jantar Mantar, in front of the Le Meridien and Shangri-La hotels. Gandhi was taken to Barakhamba Road police station and released by 8 p.m.
- Tuesday: the INDIA bloc marched from Parliament towards the ECI office. Delhi Police detained about 260 people, including 10 MPs.
- Participants: Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge and general secretary K.C. Venugopal (whose buses were stopped), CPI(M)'s John Brittas, CPI's P. Sandosh Kumar, RJD's Manoj Jha, TMC's Derek O'Brien and Mahua Moitra, and CMs A. Revanth Reddy (Telangana) and V.D. Satheesan (Keralam).
- Absent: Samajwadi Party members were conspicuously missing. The Congress said the invitation went out at short notice and some parties could not respond.
- Events:
- Police carried Gandhi on their shoulders into a van. Congress workers punctured one tyre, so the van went only a short distance.
- A viral image showed Priyanka Gandhi Vadra lying on the street with a copy of the Constitution. A large contingent of women police removed her and other women leaders.
- She alleged MPs were beaten ("scratched me all over") while "simply" seeking a meeting with the Election Commissioners.
- Gandhi called the police action a "panic reaction" and said nothing by Modi and Shah would stop the protest.
- Gandhi has stressed a "politics of resistance" and called the fight one to protect "the most sacred thing" in the country.
- CPI(M)'s John Brittas said the only appropriate course is for Gyanesh Kumar to quit forthwith.
- AISA's Neha Bora framed the 10 October call as "we the people of India" versus the BJP and said the youth groups will not tolerate isolated detentions. CJP's Saurav Das said the government should hold talks with a youth delegation instead of using force.
- Legal action: Delhi Police registered an FIR against Gandhi, Vadra and others for alleged forcible entry into Akashvani Bhavan during Tuesday's protest. At least 10 MPs and others were named. The police said protesters breached barricades. The case is under criminal trespass, following a complaint by Akashvani staffers.
- Congress response: K.C. Venugopal's circular says leaders were "brutally manhandled, lathi-charged and seriously injured". State units were asked to observe a black day with protests on Thursday. INDIA bloc leaders are likely to continue protests on Thursday.
- President: the INDIA bloc has had no appointment from President Droupadi Murmu.
- They suggested 7, 8 or 9 October for a 15-member delegation, one from each of the top 15 constituent parties.
- The President's office informally said the delegation should be limited to 10. The Opposition agreed but heard nothing.
- A 23 September letter from CPI(M) MP John Brittas sought constitutional intervention on the SIR and on the "pending proceedings" for the CEC's removal. It also sought the Union government's support before the Supreme Court for declaring the SIR "void ab initio". On Wednesday the President's Secretariat forwarded it to the Legislative Department, called it "self-explanatory", and asked that action taken be communicated to Brittas.
- Youth call for 10 October (a Sunday) at Jantar Mantar:
- Organisers: AISA, Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), AISF, SFI and ASAP.
- Demands: the CEC's resignation, SIR rollback, voter rolls restored to January 2025, and reform of the law on appointing Election Commissioners. CJP's Saurav Das also wants arrests and criminal proceedings against those who took "illegal decisions".
- AISA president Neha Bora said the June NEET-irregularities protest ended with Cabinet Minister Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation and this time it "will lead to the CEC's ouster".
- The slogan is "Dilli Chalo". They allege the government is mobilising "extremist groups" to derail it.
- Delhi Police acknowledged the intimation letter and the organisers completed paperwork and an undertaking, but the police are yet to give permission.
- AISA–CJP interview (Neha Bora): coordination is "on an agenda basis". AISA is a radical-Left student movement, while CJP is "still figuring out". AISA is reaching out to NSUI and IYC. She said Jantar Mantar is a designated protest site "on paper" but inaccessible. Mobilisation is planned in Okhla, Jamia Nagar and Mangolpuri, where many names were struck off the rolls, mostly of poor, working-class people. She said humour and satire are a response to fear. They worked together at a long Jantar Mantar movement in July and on a 2 October call (CJP called a Mumbai protest).
- BJD in Odisha:
- The BJD insists it is equidistant from the BJP and Congress.
- Chief whip Pramila Mallik said as part of the INDIA bloc the BJD backed the Odisha Bandh on Thursday, then backtracked within an hour, saying the BJD is in no alliance.
- Spokesperson Lenin Mohanty said it "neither supports nor opposes" the bandh.
- The party had issued a similar clarification a day earlier after its Rajya Sabha MPs joined the INDIA march.
- Congress's Santosh Singh Saluja called the BJD directionless and prone to aligning with the BJP.
- Digvijaya Singh's "Satya Sanatan Swabhiman Yatra": starts 20 October from Mahakal Temple (Ujjain), via Orchha, ending at the Ram Temple in Ayodhya. About 850 km at 15 km a day. It demands an impartial probe into "vote chori" and "chanda chori".
Static–dynamic linkage
- The Election Commission is a constitutional body under Article 324, and its independence rests partly on the security of tenure of the CEC. The CEC can be removed only on grounds and in a manner equal to those for a Supreme Court judge.
- The political demand for "resignation" is therefore different from the constitutional route of removal. The latter needs proved misbehaviour or incapacity and a special majority in both Houses.
- The SIR is the Commission's intensive door-to-door revision of electoral rolls. The legal basis and limits of SIR, plus the 2023 law on appointing Election Commissioners, are the static questions behind the protests.
- Protest-versus-order tension: Article 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(b) protect speech and peaceful assembly, subject to reasonable restrictions (Article 19(3)). Police use preventive powers such as detention and prohibitory orders.
Syllabus mapping: GS2 – Polity: Constitutional bodies (ECI), electoral reforms, Representation of the People Act; separation of powers; fundamental rights (Article 19) and police powers; GS2 – Role of civil society and pressure groups
Background primer
Election Commission of India (ECI) and the CEC
- What it is:
- A constitutional body entrusted with superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, State Legislatures and the offices of President and Vice-President.
- Founded:
- constituted under Article 324 at the commencement of the Constitution (1950). The multi-member Commission (CEC plus other Election Commissioners) is permitted by Article 324. The Supreme Court upheld the structure in N. Seshan v. Union of India.
Removal procedure for the CEC (the constitutional route behind the "resign" demand)
- Members:
- a Supreme Court judge, a High Court Chief Justice and a distinguished jurist.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR)
- What it is:
- A large-scale, labour-intensive exercise with physical verification, in which Booth Level Officers visit each household to verify every registered voter. It differs from the routine desk-based summary revision.
Additional context
- Judicial position on SIR: On 27 May 2026, the Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of the ECI's SIR in Bihar. The Court said the ECI can examine citizenship for electoral purposes but cannot make final determinations of citizenship, which lie with competent authorities under the Citizenship Act. It directed the ECI to refer 2003-roll deletions on non-citizenship grounds to a competent authority within four weeks. Bihar's roll went from about 7.9 crore registered voters to a final 7.42 crore electors.
- A July 2026 report says the Supreme Court observed that SIR is limited to electoral purposes and cannot be used to determine citizenship or deny welfare benefits.
- West Bengal SIR: 19 appellate tribunals began hearings on 13 April 2026, and more than 34 lakh appeals had been filed as of 11 April. Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 requires notice, inquiry and hearing before deletion.
- Earlier removal attempts: Earlier in 2026, notices seeking the CEC's removal were reportedly submitted in both Houses, backed by 130 Lok Sabha and 63 Rajya Sabha MPs, and were then rejected by the presiding officers.
- Appointment context: In a March 2023 ruling, the Supreme Court had directed that the selection panel include the PM, Leader of Opposition and CJI.
- Police powers in protests (ForumIAS explainer): Under Section 172 of the BNSS, police may detain or remove a person who disregards a lawful direction. The person must be taken before a magistrate or, in petty cases, released within 24 hours. Section 163 BNSS allows prohibitory orders, and one was imposed across New Delhi during the protests.
Mains dimensions
- Independence of the ECI: the demand targets the CEC personally, but the structural questions are:
- the 2023 selection committee (executive-majority) and the removal of the CJI from it;
- the asymmetric protection for ECs, who are removable only on the CEC's recommendation;
- the Commission's dependence on government staff for operations.
- Constitutional vs political route: resignation demands bypass Article 324(5). The route needs 100 LS/50 RS signatures and presiding-officer admission, and earlier notices were rejected (2b). Opposition's approach to the President fits the process, but the President acts on the Council of Ministers' advice. The Secretariat's step of forwarding the petition to the Legislative Department illustrates that.
- SIR as the substantive grievance: concerns over deletion of poor, working-class and migrant voters (Okhla, Jamia Nagar, Mangolpuri were named) versus the ECI's case for roll accuracy. The SC upheld SIR's legality (May 2026) while insisting on safeguards, referral of citizenship questions and judicial review. The key conflict is universal adult suffrage (Article 326) against roll purity.
- Right to protest and public order: designated protest sites (Jantar Mantar) versus preventive detention, prohibitory orders and a pending police permission for 10 October. The FIR for criminal trespass at Akashvani Bhavan shows the legal consequences of crossing barricades. Opposition leaders call it assault on elected representatives. Police say barricades were breached and directions to disperse were ignored.
- Opposition cohesion and mobilisation:
- SP's absence and the BJD's repeated disavowal show fragile alliances.
- AISA–CJP "agenda-based" cooperation, Gen Z/humour as a mobilisation style, and Congress's "black day" are all modes of agitation.
- Digvijaya Singh's yatra uses religious-cultural symbolism (Mahakal to Ram Temple) for a poll-integrity message.
- Missing/negative facts: the President's office has not responded to the meeting request. Delhi Police have not given permission for 10 October. The SP did not join. The article gives no ECI response to the allegations.
- Way forward: transparent SIR audits and publication of deletions, equal protection for all Election Commissioners (as the 255th Law Commission report recommended for Article 324(5)), a broader selection panel, and structured dialogue between the ECI and parties.
Possible Mains question
**GS2, 15 marks:** "Examine the constitutional safeguards for the independence of the Election Commission of India. In light of the recent controversy over the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls, discuss whether those safeguards need strengthening."
Related topics
- Article 324–329; Representation of the People Acts, 1950 and 1951; Registration of Electors Rules, 1960
- Removal of SC judges (Article 124(4)); Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968; N. Seshan case; 255th Law Commission report on electoral reforms
- CEC and Other ECs Act, 2023 and the Supreme Court's March 2023 ruling on the selection panel
- Right to protest: Article 19, reasonable restrictions, BNSS preventive powers; role of the President and the Council of Ministers
- Federal/party politics: INDIA bloc, regional parties' equidistance (BJD), anti-defection and party system
Topics: GS2Polity
All current affairs of 8 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs