BrainParrot

SC refuses to stay proceedings against Nicobar project

GS3Full notePublished: · Updated:

Source: The Hindu, 6 October 2026

Summary

  • A three-judge Supreme Court Bench headed by CJI Surya Kant refused the Union's plea to stay proceedings in the Calcutta High Court on a petition by former Union Environment Secretary Meena Gupta. The petition challenges the Great Nicobar Island Project as a threat to the fragile ecosystem and a violation of the Forest Rights Act, 2006.
  • The Bench urged the Calcutta High Court Chief Justice to decide the case without delay, including all connected petitions.
  • Justice Bagchi said the Court must distinguish between state security and commercial interests, and orally called preservation of culture a constitutionally protected fundamental right.

UPSC relevance: GS3 — Environment: EIA, forest and biodiversity; GS2 — Society/Polity: tribal rights, Forest Rights Act; GS3 — Security: strategic infrastructure

Key facts for Prelims

  • Forest Rights Act, 2006: recognises forest rights of Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (cut-off date 13 December 2005 for residence).
  • Shompen: a PVTG of Great Nicobar. The Nicobarese are a Scheduled Tribe (the article notes both groups as affected). Great Nicobar has a biosphere reserve and national parks.
  • NGT: statutory tribunal under the National Green Tribunal Act, 2010.
  • The Calcutta High Court has jurisdiction over the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.
  • Locus standi: the Calcutta High Court dismissed (in May) the Union's preliminary objection on petitioner Meena Gupta's locus standi, which was based on her not being a local.
  • Shompen Policy (2015) and Jarawa Policy (2004) relate to protection of PVTGs in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands.

Data and details

  • The project is worth over ₹72,000 crore and includes a container terminal.
  • Forest diversion cited in the High Court petitions: over 130 sq. km of pristine tropical forest.
  • NGT: twice disposed of apprehensions. It left the environmental clearance in place subject to conditions and a High Powered Committee to re-examine specific ecological impacts. A review against the clearance was rejected in April 2023.
  • Calcutta High Court: in May it rejected the Union's preliminary objection on Meena Gupta's locus (the objection was that she was not local). It scheduled hearing on 25–26 November on constitutional issues of fundamental rights and preservation of tribal way of life.
  • Arguments: AG R. Venkataramani and ASG Aishwarya Bhati say the project is of "immense" national and strategic importance and that there is "no loss of habitation". Venkataramani said the tribes were integrated and not in the protected category. Senior advocate S. Muralidhar (for Gupta) said the Shompen are classified as a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group, and that the maintainability argument is academic because tribal councils have been impleaded.
  • Bench: the Union may place NGT decisions before the High Court for whatever persuasive value they carry. It declined the AG's request to keep pressing the maintainability question, saying it would limit itself to asking the High Court Chief Justice to decide all petitions without delay.
  • Bench composition: CJI Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana.
  • Justice Bagchi's remark: some "filtration" is needed between what constitutes state security and what involves commercial interests. The remark on culture was oral, not a formal holding.

Static–dynamic linkage

  • India's Forest Rights Act recognises individual and community rights of forest-dwelling Scheduled Tribes, including Gram Sabha consent for forest diversion in the relevant area. In this case the legal question is whether the project's forest diversion complied with those requirements and respected tribal councils.
  • The Court's oral remark ties the cultural identity of tribes to fundamental rights (the likely textual anchors are Art. 29(1) on culture and Art. 21 on life/dignity; the article does not name the Articles). It also addresses the tension between national security claims and commercial components of mega-projects.
  • Multi-forum litigation matters here. The NGT dealt with environmental clearance, and the High Court is handling forest-rights and constitutional questions. This tests the division of labour among tribunals and High Courts.

Syllabus mapping: GS3 — Environment: EIA, forest diversion, biodiversity, role of NGT; GS2 — Society/Polity: Scheduled Tribes, PVTGs, Forest Rights Act, 2006; Art. 46; GS3 — Security: strategic infrastructure in the Indian Ocean Region.

Background primer

Forest Rights Act, 2006 (Scheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act)

What it is:
An Act that recognises the rights of forest-dwelling communities to forest land and resources.
Founded:
Enacted in 2006 to undo the "historical injustice" of non-recognition of forest rights (textbook).
Members:
Works through Gram Sabhas, Sub-Divisional Level Committees and District Level Committees. A Forest Dwelling Scheduled Tribe claimant must belong to an ST in the area, have resided there before 13 December 2005 and depend on forests for livelihood. Other Traditional Forest Dwellers must show three generations (75 years) of residence before 13 December 2005.
Mandate:
Recognising and vesting forest rights, and giving communities a role in forest governance.
Why it matters:
Rights-based conservation, with communities as protectors of forests.

Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups (PVTGs) and the Shompen

What it is:
A sub-category of Scheduled Tribes with a dwindling population, pre-agricultural technology and social isolation. The Shompen are classified as PVTG for exactly such reasons.
Mandate:
The Centre states that the Shompen Policy, 2015 and Jarawa Policy, 2004 guide the protection of PVTG interests.
Why it matters:
Special protection so that development does not erase small, vulnerable communities.

National Green Tribunal (NGT)

What it is:
A specialised tribunal under the NGT Act, 2010 for environmental disputes. In this case the NGT dealt with the environmental clearance challenge.

Additional context

  • Project components: An international container transshipment terminal, a greenfield international airport, township development and a 450 MVA gas and solar-based power plant. The proponent is the Andaman and Nicobar Islands Integrated Development Corporation (ANIDCO).
  • Strategic case: The project is described as a transshipment and defence hub that would reduce reliance on foreign ports and increase India's presence in the Indian Ocean region.
  • NGT: In its second round of litigation (reported February 2026), the NGT again upheld the environmental clearance, noting the project's strategic importance and compliance with ICRZ/CRZ norms.
  • Tribal-consent disputes: The Tribal Council of Little and Great Nicobar had earlier revoked its no-objection to denotification of the tribal reserve. Gram Sabha resolutions were challenged as being signed by settlers, who are not stakeholders under FRA, with at least 60 signatures repeated.
  • Later development (after this batch): On 30 October 2026 the Union Ministry of Tribal Affairs told the Calcutta High Court that four Nicobarese applicants were not "necessary or proper parties".
  • Jurisdiction: The Calcutta High Court has jurisdiction over West Bengal and the Union Territory of Andaman and Nicobar Islands.

Mains dimensions

  • Development vs. rights vs. ecology: The strategic case (Indian Ocean transshipment, EEZ) clashes with a fragile rainforest ecosystem and vulnerable tribal groups. Justice Bagchi's separation of security from commercial interests suggests the "national security" label cannot cover all project components.
  • Rights-based conservation: The FRA process (Gram Sabha consent, committees) is the key safeguard. Challenges to Gram Sabha consents and tribal-council withdrawals show consent can be manufactured or mis-specified.
  • Forum multiplicity: NGT (environment) and High Court (constitutional rights) can overlap. Delay and forum-shopping risks should be managed, as the Bench's "decide without delay" direction implies.
  • Cultural rights as fundamental rights: The oral remark that preservation of culture is a fundamental right (Art. 29 and Art. 21 are the likely anchors) strengthens arguments for habitat rights of PVTGs.
  • Way forward: Independent social and ecological impact assessment, no-go zones around tribal reserves, free, prior and informed consent, disaster-risk studies (the island is seismically active), and robust monitoring by an independent committee.

Possible Mains question

**GS3, 15 marks:** "The Great Nicobar Project illustrates the conflict between strategic development and the rights of Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Groups. Critically examine the legal and ecological issues involved."

Related topics

  • Environment Impact Assessment (EIA Notification 2006), Island Coastal Regulation Zone, 2019
  • National Green Tribunal Act, 2010; Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and amendments
  • PVTGs; Andaman and Nicobar (Protection of Aboriginal Tribes) Regulation, 1956; Art. 46; Art. 29; Art. 21
  • Biosphere Reserves (Great Nicobar); Andaman and Nicobar's strategic role (Indian Ocean Region)

Topics: GS3Environment

How we write and check these notes →

All current affairs of 6 October 2026 → · UPSC Current Affairs